×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

(OP)
Greetings,

I am puzzled by the seemingly different behavior that Cola exhibits under different bottle sizes.  For example, I opened a new 2 liter bottle of Coke.  I then distributed it between 2 smaller containers and the remaining in the Original Bottle.

The Coke distribution is as follows:

Bottle 1: Filled to  Capacity , 0.5L (Approx).
Bottle 2: Filled to  Capacity , 0.5L (Approx).
Bottle 3: (Original) Contains , 1.0L (The Remaining).

After 2 hours, all of the bottles are opened, and their contents are tasted.  The results that I experienced are as follows:

Both bottles 1 and 2 were "flat" (Less carbonation), and had a displeasing taste.  The Coke in bottle 1 maintained the same taste and carbonation level that it originally had (Approx.)

My question is this: Why does the coke in the smaller bottles lose carbonation, while the coke in the larger bottle remains unchanged?  Here are some of my observations.

After a small amount of time (1 hour), the smaller bottles are highly pressurized and the containers are generally hard to squeeze.  The larger bottle is easy to squeeze. Why does it seem like the smaller bottle is under more pressure than the larger bottle, but yet the soda from the larger bottle is more carbonated and tastier?  All containers were filled with extreme caution so as not to produce surface "fizz."  The containers were both cold from refrigeration.

Also, I recently purchased one of those pumps that replaces the bottle cap of a soda container.  When pumped it re-pressurizes the container, supposedly maintaining freshness.  The instructions say do not pump to such a degree that you cannot squeeze the bottle, as this device is more effective at a lower pressure.  Why not higher?

What am I missing?

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Well it seems you thought of most everything, and it's an interesting question.  Some possibilities might include the disturbance of even gentle pouring and contact with air.  You say you pressurized each container as well so it should not be a matter of head space so much.  Your glass bottles, I assume they were clean.  If you used a detergent that is mildly basic, as many are, residuals on the glass could buffer the cola, and actually neutralize the carbonic acid.  Just a thought.  Could be a possibility.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

(OP)
Interesting,

Well, all of the bottles are plastic with extensive rinsing and no soap residue.  Regarding the possibly of the slightest amount of disturbance to effect the carbonation, I do not think that this is an issue.  All 3 samples experienced an insignificant amount of disturbance (2 receiving, 1 pouring).  Also, I have a feeling that even if I was able to transfer the cola with zero disturbance, that the results would be the same.  As far as pressurization is concerned, I did not pressurize the bottles myself.  They pressurized themselves through the expansion of carbonation after the bottle was sealed.  Interesting though, that after sealed for 2 hours, the smaller bottle was under higher pressure than the larger bottle, but yet the lower pressure, larger bottle had more carbonation.  There is one other variable that I can think of.  Maybe there is a relationship between pressure, capacity of bottle, and amount of liquid.  The small bottles were filled to about 95% capacity, while the 2.0L bottle was 50% filled before resealing the bottles, and awaiting testing.  Hmm...I have to do more experimenting...

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

There are some other factors here.
What were the final temperatures in all the bottles?
Heat will drive the carbonation (CO2) out of the liquid.
From your description it appears that this happened to a greater extent in the smaller bottles because they tasted flat and there was more pressure in the head space.
1 liter will stay colder (less heat transfer area per volume) than 0.5 liters.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Are you actually measuring the pressure in the two bottles or just performing a squeeze test?  The larger bottle generally feels softer because of its geometry...hmm I have a couple 0-20 digital pressure gauges in my garage.  Did you try having a spare 2L bottle and transferring the remaining 1L bottle that has been cleaned and prepared the same way as the smaller bottles?  This might rule out cleaning and transfer effects.

The pouring process may be highly effecient at mass transfer because of the relatively large survace area as the small stream of fluid is transferred from one bottle to another...no fizzing but high diffusion rate and loss of CO2?

The apparrent higher pressure in the small bottle?  An illusion?  What causes the bottle to become pressurized at all?  I'm guessing...  The partial pressure of CO2 in the headspace is initially very low but CO2 in the soda is high(er); this is the driving force so the pCO2 in the headspace increases.  Since the headspace is smaller the pCO2 can equalize faster.  The CO2 transfer rate might be higher in the large bottle but equilization takes much longer.

To test...do the pressures equilize at t=long time?  Large bottle may be even higher at t=long time since no losses from transfer.

What does everybody think?

Carl

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

SteveBzzz,

What about Pepsi? How does that peform?

Seriously, why not try this-

Take two 2L full bottles at the same temp. Open one and empty, leaving a clean bottle (don't rinse). Open the other and pour half into the empty bottle. Recap both and see what pressures develop and do the taste test.

If there is any difference then it could only be a result of the pouring. I'm sure there's many other experiments to devise to test various theories - lucky it's Christmas time and the beverage won't go wasted.

Cheers,
John.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Presume your experiment was with plastic bottles. Carbonated drinks in plastic bottles breathe through the plastic surface. That's why there is a taste difference in cola drinks between a plastic bottle closer to the manufacturing date and one closer to the expiry date. In cans this phenomenon is not significant.

Now the above phenomenon depends upon the surface area / unit volume of carbonated drink . The smaller bottle would have a larger surface area and it will tend to lose more CO2 through diffusion. Moreover , while transferring basically you have agitated the liquid , therby increasing the driving force for this diffusion and hence there is a tendency for more CO2 to escape in the smaller bottle.

Hence the smaller bottle by combination of higher surface area and higher driving force for diffusion happens to lose its fizz faster.

How is this for an explanation !!!

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

(OP)
Hmmmmm,

Well, there is a Coke plant about 20 minutes from my house.  I guess I could just show up there with my questions and a hidden camera

OK, Here are my reactions to some of the various questions posed to me.

I did not measure the temperature of the colas because I did not feel it necessary.  The cola was cold, taken from the refrigerator, I'm guessing about 45 degrees F.  I did not think this to be a factor since all of the samples were drawn from of the same source, and therefore were the same temperature.  When removed from the refrigerator a few hours later, I assumed also, that they were of equal temperatures.

I did not actually measure the pressure difference because I did not think I needed the numbers at that point.  My observation is this.  Initially both small (.5L) bottles were filled to capacity, and the large (2L) bottle is therefore emptied to contain 1L or 50% of it's capacity.  After a few hours the bottles were observed and tasted.  Before opening the smaller bottles, I observed that they were basically rock hard.  I would say that there was a 1-2 ounce gap of space at the top of the bottle when sealed.  The larger 2L bottle was under relatively less pressure, because the bottle was able to be squeezed.  Could this have something to do with the fact that water can't be compressed?  The slightest release of CO2 in the smaller bottles will rapidly increase the pressure because the bottle is filled to 95% capacity with only a small volume of remaining space to pressurize?

I did the cola transfer with extreme caution as not to disturb the soda and cause fizz.  However, it is possible that it "invisibly" dissipated during flow?  To rule this out, I suppose I could fill a bucket with coke and devise a method to submerge the bottles in the bucket and to fill them in this method in which to eliminate transfer flow loss.  Think of dipping a glass sideways in a sink full of coke, and filling it that way.  In any case, if there is a carbonation loss, would it not occur equally in all of the samples?

Yes, it does seem that the larger bottle takes a lot longer to achieve the same pressure of that of the smaller bottles, leading me to conclude that there is more CO2 loss from the larger cola sample.  But yet when tasted, the Cola from the larger bottle clearly has more gas in it and tastes better.

gkandy, yes you are absolutely correct about the taste differences and gas behavior between glass and plastic.  I prefer glass personally.

You stated, "The smaller bottle would have a larger surface area...it will lose more CO2 through diffusion...smaller bottle has a surface area and higher driving force for diffusion...to lose its fizz faster."  Did you get that backwards, or is it my bad?

Well, it's going to be a long and potentially costly weekend.  I may abandon Coke and Pepsi all together and get Walmart soda!

I will conduct more experiments this weekend.  I especially like the one about pouring half of a 2 litter bottle into an empty 2 liter bottle, thus having 2 large bottles that are both half filled.

Wish me luck

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Steve,

Your dedication to the pursuit of scientific truth is amazing.

Here's another experiment you might try.

Take two 2L full bottles of Coke. Open both and pour down the sink. Fill one up with tap water. Pour from that one, half its contents into the other one. No, that's the wrong plan. You start with one full 2L and two full 500mL bottles, OK?. Yeah, that's it. Open all bottles and pour contents away. Fill the big bottle with water and then, from that one, fill the two small bottles. Put all bottles in fridge and see what pressures develop. Then you'll see if the "rock hard" condition of the small bottles is  a result of the bottle size or the carbonated Coke. Actually, I see now you don't need to buy any more Coke. You must be up to your knees in empty bottles of all sizes by now (and a bloated belly?). Just take some empties and do the original experiment with water. Here's another - you're an adult, right? Find a child about half your size. You each drink quickly 1L of freshly opened Coke. Observe results.

Tis the silly season.

Cheers,
John.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

(OP)
I give up.

I'm to tired to continue.  First of all, I shouldn't be drinking so much soda.  Second, I have a new experiment.  Why does chocolate milk have expiration dates that are sometimes two months long, whereas regular milk expires in about a week?  When I was young my grandmother used to give us milk that had been stored in the freezer. Unfortunately, I don't remember what it tastes like.  I froze a container of milk tonight, and will report back soon as to it's progress.  Any ideas?



Happy Holidays

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Steve:  I would like to know about your project - pse contact me.

<nbucska@pcperipherals.com>

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Steve -

In reference to your question of gkandy's surface area - he's actually referring to specific surface area.  This means the surface area per unit volume.  This property would be important if the concern is interaction between the soda and the plastic, as more soda would be in contact with more area of the plastic in the smaller bottle.  It's a little confusing, but it makes sense if you think about it for a while.  Again, I think this only really matters if the concern is soda to plastic interactions, if CO2 is indeed breathing through the plastic.

Despite possible abandonment of the project, my only other thought is the composition of the bottles... are the smaller bottles the same plastic as the 1L bottle?  Different plastics will have different characteristics, which would play a role if breathing is an issue.  And I think someone else mentioned it, but the higher pressure you note in the smaller containers is likely due to the partial pressure of CO2.  Essentially, if you have two identical volumes of soda at the same temperature, the two volumes would yield the same partial pressures of CO2 above the soda.  If you put a volume in a much smaller container, the soda would try to produce the same pressure (for lack of a better way to say it).  Essentially, I think the higher pressure you're noticing only comes from the decreased amount of free volume in the container.  To check this, try perturbating a full 2L bottle of Coke.  The full bottle will likely exhibit the same type of hardness you're experiencing with the smaller containers, as there is a very small amount of free space in the unopened container - it's the reason you hear a hissing noise when you first open a bottle...the gas inside is pressurized and wants to escape.

Anyway, sorry to hear a sufficient answer didn't quite arise from your experiments.  Best of luck on the milk thing (you might try to find a biological explanation, rather than chemical, though - expiration dates usually have to do with the spoiling of the milk.  Perhaps the chocolate variety allows the addition of extra preservatives that would alter the flavor of regular milk?)

Best of luck!
Jason

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Steve,

I applaud your scientific curiosity.  While I agree that the tongue of a Coke afficionado is a very sensitive tool, the first thing to do when doing any research is to make sure your gauges are OK.  You need to perform gauge R&R first, in other words get a consilium of 3-5 Coke afficionadoes like yourself and measure their evaluations of the three Coke bottles.

The taste differences are most definitely related to the release of CO2 when you are pouring the Coke from the 2-liter bottle into the smaller ones.


I look forward to hearing more from you!  Good luck and happy New Year!
The order in which you are filling these bottles will matter a lot in this experimentation.  So when you are designing your experiment make sure you rotate the smaller bottles giving each an equal chance of being the first to be filled.

To minimize that effect, try connecting the source and destination bottles with an airtight hose and setting up an air bleeding valve on the top of the destination bottle.  But set up you hose in such a way that your destination bottle would be filling from the bottom, not over the top.  It will take some ingenuity, but I am sure you can handle it. That should make sure that you are not introducing the additional effect of gas release due to abrupt expansion.

Also, make sure you distribute the Coke into the smaller bottles in such a way that you do not let air into the source bottle in between the pourings.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

(OP)
Hmmmmmm....

Well, I got a food-saver for Christmas.  For those of you who don't know what it is, It's a vacuum bag sealer.  You place your food in a special bag, then insert the open end into the machine.  Press the button and presto!  It sucks all of the air out, and you've got a nicely vacuum-packed meal...or the specimen of some experiment.  Imagine, I can do all of the above experiments with various combinations of vacuum combinations.

Happy holidays.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Steve, be careful about sucking out the CO2 from carbonated drinks: once you apply vacuum to the Coke bottle, you will lose your CO2: the partial pressure of dissolved CO2 in the Coke bottle will become higher than the partial pressure of CO2 in the space above the Coke, and it will want to escape...

On the contrary, when pouring, you want to keep all bottles under the same pressure.

Good luck and Happy New Year!

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

I have a new question for all the Coke experimenters out there....  My first interview question as an engineer was, "Why does Coke fizz more when you pour it over ice than into an empty glass?"

14 years later, I am still searching for a decent answer to this question, but sad to say I have used it myself now just to see what individuals say.

Any thoughts?

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Railbaron, that's a good one!  I think it does so because the ice cubes work as packing in a stripping column: they develop the phase contact area, thus increasing the efficiency of this desorber.  Try doing it with different ice pieces in shape, size, and order (vs. random) and see how it comes out then.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

I think I follow azg's reasoning... on that level, it is also (mid-pour) giving a much higher exposed surface area to the air. Try similar experiments without ice, but rather with a room temperature plastic or glass, to take eliminate the temperature variable.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

That's a good point!  Also, ice melts into the cola, which complicates the big picture, as it may alter the solubility product for CO2 in the mix.  

BTW, here's another question: which way will ice alter the "fizz" compared to plastic or glass? I wouldn't bet my paycheck on it, but I think it will promote the acceleration of the release of CO2:  there is a thin film of water on the ice, and upon contact, CO2 wants to escape, as carbonic acid is formed in the reaction, but it is very unstable, decomposing into CO2 and water.

Any other bets?

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

(OP)
Greetings all,

Well, I have more or less stoped wasting...oops...I mean devoting my time to this experiment.  However...

Walmart had a closeout sale on rootbeer making kits.  It comes with everything you need to make 3 liters of rootbeer and or cola.  The process takes a few weeks, so I will keep you posted.

I am going to make a gallon of chocolate milk, using 2% and nestles quick.  Why make a glass at a time, when you can make a gallon?  I figure at least i'm going to get some protein from this experiemnt.

Steve

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Milk with rootbeer? Yummy...

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

My 2 cents:

Repeat your initial experiment but prior to capping all the bottles, taste from each.  Maybe the flatness happened right away.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

I think I have two answers for you...
First, with respect to you chocolate milk life question: A lot of chocolate milk is UHT pasteurized and can therefore be stored for long periods of time without going bad.  In Europe and Australia (among others perhaps, I have no idea) it's quite common to buy UHT pasteurized regular milk that you can then keep on the shelf for months, without refrigeration.  However, UHT milk tastes wretched, which probably explains why those of us in North America, with our more discriminating tastes, can only tolerate the stuff if it has chocolate flavouring in it.

As for a pump to pressurize and thus preserve your cola... I don't think this would work unless you were to pump the headspace full of CO2.  The equilibrium between dissolved and gaseous CO2 depends only on the partial pressure of CO2 in the gas phase.  Ambient air contains too little CO2 to make this practical.  You can buy small (12 g I believe) cylinders of CO2 for applications like bicycle tire inflators and air gun propellants.  Best of luck.

Thanks very much, now I have to try this coke experiment myself to try and figure it out.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

donmackenzie -
My wife's family was in the seltzer business back in the roaring 20's and 30's.  For a long time, we had a little pump they gave us that we used to re-pressurize Coke bottles after openning.  It sure seemed to keep the soda tasting fresh for much longer than without it.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Can't help it! Have to add my two cents, pedantically.
Hint: How do we spell "SUPERSATURATION"? How about "NUCLEATION SITES"?

No matter how the CO2 is added to a soft drink, it is obvious that there is more CO2 in a soft drink than would be in equilibrium with the small content of CO2 in atmospheric air since a soft drink container is pressurized, at least slightly, when you buy it. The vapor space of the container has a fairly high content of CO2; still not enough to cause any harm.

The amount of total "CO2" dissolved into the liquid is primarily determined by the following equilibriums:

1) Physical dissolution of CO2 gas
       CO2(g) <--> CO2(aq)  math: [CO2(aq)] = Kg PCO2
i.e. the concentration, [] indicating mole per liter of CO2 dissolved into the liquid where it is part of the aqueous (water) solution ( thus CO2(aq) ) is related to the partial pressure of the CO2 gas, PCO2, and the constant relating these quantities, Kg, (or 1/Kg', depending upon definition) is Henry's Law constant which varies with temperature, somewhat with concentration of other components of the solution, and slightly with pressure (usually neglect pressure variation, particularly up to about 5 atmospheres pure CO2). At total pressures generated by small pumps, forget about the total pressure making a difference in this equilibrium. The total pressure is sum of the partial pressures of the gas components so adding air (~79% nitrogen and ~21% oxygen and only about 0.03% CO2) pressurizes the container by increasing the partial pressures of nitrogen and oxygen. Okay, there is a small increase of CO2 partial pressure but it is very small. Okay, also there is some increase of dissolved nitrogen and dissolved oxygen due to the increased pressure (same equilibrium principles but smaller constants); the dissolved N2 and O2 will pop out when the pressure is released but it is small compared to CO2. There is a another reason for increased pressure (with an air pump) to help maintain "freshness" (carbonation), see below, but it is the CO2 partial pressure which governs in the dissolved gas equilibrium not the total pressure (to any appreciable extent). However, CO2 also interacts chemically with water, which nitrogen and oxygen do not. Hence, more equilibriums...

2) Hydrolysis
     CO2(aq)  +  H2O  <-->  H2CO3
     math: [H2CO3] = Kh [CO2(aq)]
Carbonic acid ( H2CO3 ) is formed which is actually not that weak as acids go meaning it dissociates fairly easily. Hence ...

3) Dissociation
     H2CO3  <--> HCO3-  +  H+
or   H2CO3  +  H2O  <-->  HCO3-  +  H3O+
     math: [HCO3-][H+] = Ka [H2CO3]

These latter equilibriums increase the total amount of CO2 that is absorbed into a water solution. With the right data for these equations, one can calculate the total amount of CO2 dissolved in the solution but ONLY WHEN EQUILIBRIUM is reached which can take a long time. This might be done for the original carbonation process (e.g. supposing the liquid is highly pressurized in a stirred vessel with a pure CO2 gas before bottling) and calculations would give the residual amount of CO2 in a soft drink that has gone totally flat and is in equilibrium with atmospheric air pressure.

When a soft drink is opened, the partial pressure of CO2 above the liquid is reduced but it doesn't explode. Yes, shaking before opening will cause a lot of initial "foaming" and you can feel a greater pressure on the wall of a plastic container that has been shaken but this is the result of the liquid already being supersaturated with CO2 and carbon dioxide seems to supersaturate water solution quite easily. Other gases can also supersaturate but not as much as CO2; don't forget about those other equilibriums which also take up CO2 into the solution.

Supersaturation means that the actual concentration of the CO2 in the solution is higher than the equilibrium concentration and it is a meta-stable condition like an egg balanced on a sharp point. A shock like a sudden temperature change (contact with ice), or a shake will induce a change towards the more stable condition; CO2 gas will come out of the liquid.

In a closed bottle, shaking causes some gas to come out and the partial pressure of CO2 increases so the total pressure increases as well; it doesn't take much CO2 release to raise the partial pressure enough in a small space to attain a condition near equilibrium. If the bottle is opened at this point, the agitated contents will spew forth since the shock is not yet dissipated, but if the bottle is left standing for a long while, things settle down, the higher pressure dissipates through the cap seal (and somewhat by permeation through the plastic) and the solution becomes supersaturated again as the pressure falls, there is not a lot of CO2 lost but the drink will become flat a bit sooner than if the bottle was not shaken.

Even without any shocks, the CO2 will continue to be lost as the supersaturated condition still slowly works toward equilibrium. As noted in the other replies, this is faster in a plastic bottle than in a glass bottle due to permeation loss. Smaller plastic containers do have more permeation loss due to a larger specific area (area per volume). In a more impermeable glass bottle, the loss is more likely around the cap seals which aren't perfect.

When a container is opened, air mixes with the gas in the vapor space of the container, CO2 content/partial pressure decreases and there is a greater driving force for CO2 to come out of solution. Yet, leaving the container alone, it will still take quite some time for equilibrium to be reached and the soft drink to be fully flat. First the dissolved CO2 near the surface comes out, as the concentration of dissolved CO2 decreases, the other chemical equilibriums shift towards dissolved CO2, more dissolved CO2 can come out of solution. As the concentrations near the surface are depleted, more of the CO2 components from lower depths diffuse upwards, etc. So it takes awhile.

Pouring the liquid into another container, even very slowly, will set up slow currents that help to keep the concentration even throughout the whole volume and the CO2 will come out faster. Especially in the container receiving the liquid while the remaining liquid in the original container still seems to retain its carbonation longer even though it probably has similar currents set up due to the pouring action (okay, probably somewhat to a lesser extent). However, the major factor for the faster rate of CO2 loss in the receiving container is due to the exposure of the carbonated liquid to a new set of nucleation sites.

The CO2 gas coming out of solution has to form a bubble which is not that easy by itself. A nucleation site makes it easier for the bubble to form; so more nucleation sites, more bubbles. Once a tiny bubble forms, it is easier for more CO2 to join this bubble. It is easier for more CO2 to join a bigger bubble than a smaller bubble.

The original container has nucleation sites but these have been "conditioned" by prolonged exposure to the carbonated solution. Nucleation sites in a different container also hold on to a bit of atmospheric air when the soft drink is poured in (aside from residual dust or other extraneous material providing additional sites) so these nucleation sites are more active. Also, smaller receiving containers have more sites per volume than larger containers. So there is more fizz in the smaller receiving containers and they go flat faster. The fizz, or rising bubbles, also stir the contents a bit. If we pour into a container with ice, there is thermal shock, more convection currents, greater exposure of liquid to air, and (believe it or not) more nucleation sites (quality of the ice water is probably a factor as well, hmmmm? i.e. more contaminants, more imperfections = more nucleation sites); most of these factors have been raised already.

If we can make the bubbles smaller, then the rate at which CO2 comes out of solution will be slower. Gas volume is inversely related to pressure. So pumping up the orginal container with air (even though it is not CO2), can slow down the loss of dissolved CO2.

That's how I see it.
Although this is a bit of fun, there are serious industrial and medical applications/problems related this subject.
Regards

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Tom, WoW!  That was a cool dissertation there.  Your spelling of "SUPERSATURATION" and "NUCLEATION SITES" was immaculate :)  Would you mind addressing the issue of pouring cola onto ice cubes (variation of amount of fizz with the size / shape of ice and other materials) and mixing milk with root beer? ;)  These issues were touched upon here, but never to the depth.  I predicted that smaller ice cubes should create more fizz.  What do you think?

Cheers!

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Sorry about any rambling or hasty generalizations, azg.
You seem to have covered the important factors of fizzing on ice, i.e. increased area which not only increase air-liquid contact but also allows for more nucleation sites. So according to the logic, there should be more fizzing if the ice pieces are smaller since the smaller pieces have more area per volume.
 
You mentioned other factors such as a thin water layer on the ice which could "smooth" the surface and reduce nucleation sites. I think that you will get more fizzing if the soft drink is poured over "fresh" ice (straight from the freezer).
I am also pretty sure (haven't had any time recently for field shtudies) that you get more fizzing on ice if the soft drink is warm (not stored in the fridge) for two reasons:
1) greater thermal shock disturbs the supersaturation condition more, and
2) gas solubility is generally lower at warmer temperatures so the CO2 will tend to come out of solution faster.

I would tend to disagree with the thought that the water layer on ice promotes fizzing through carbonic acid formation/decomposition. However, this leads into the specifics of how the equilibrium constants differ in various solutions.

Generally, gas solubilities decrease in aqueous solution when the concentration of other added components increase so diluting the soft drink with water should increase the solubility and reduce the amount of CO2 escape (but the amount of water on the ice is small and won't change the overall concentrations very much during the pouring).

Gas solubilities are often compared simply on a basis of "values" taken to be the Henry's law constant but are really the total amount of gas absorbed at particular conditions. Such a comparison mistakenly ignores the other chemical interaction equilibriums that might occur.

Any acid gas such as CO2, chlorine, sulfur dioxide, etc. will have chemical interactions with water. Also, there can be other chemical equilibriums involved. For example, the water hydrolysis of chlorine forms two acids, hydrochloric acid (HCl) which essentially dissociates completely in to hydrogen ions (H+) and chloride ions (Cl-) and hypochlorous acid (HOCl) which is a weaker acid for which the dissociation equilibrium must be accounted for in calculations; and more interestingly, chlorine also complexes with chloride ion to form a trichloride ion:
Cl2(aq) + Cl-  <--> Cl3-.
One can talk about other complexations of components and hydrations, etc. which are usually ignored under typical conditions and lower concentrations of the components.

It is possible that there are interactions of CO2 with other components of the soft drink solution. I haven't studied it, but have suspicions that there might be interactions with sugar. If so and if they are significant, then a case might be made for a thin water layer on ice causing more fizzing.
One can also bring surfactants into the issue. A component of the soft drink may suppress bubble formation and contact with water could reduce the surface concentration of the component enough to remove the suppression of bubble formation, if so, more fizzing.
These are only speculations on my part. I think there is greater fizzing on fresh ice compared to ice having a water layer but would have to re-do observations.

Mixing milk with root beer...
Regurgitation rather than speculation comes to mind.
Definitely a more complicated mixture.
Milk contains "fats" and compounds that could be surface active.
Never did it. I'll try to think about it.
Regards

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

, Tom!  I wouldn't even think about it (milk + root beer).  I once mixed hot milk and vodka (I was then a young and stupid ChemE student, and it was on a dare) inside of me.  Yuck!

Seriously, I think milk and root beer would cause a different kind of foam: extremely dense, with very low content of gas.  Which may cause the CO2 (g) to have a different dynamics than cola on ice: at first there will be rapid foam formation, and then it will achieve an equilibrium at a different concentration, as CO2 will reach saturation in the foam and the partial pressures will equilibrate.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

I think you're right, azg. Milk is mainly an emulsion where most of the "fat" components aren't actually dissolved but stay dispersed for a long time throughout the solution because they are so finely divided, especially after homogenization. The tiny particles of fat would provide nucleation sites for gas evolution, especially with the added thermal shock due to contact with ice. So an initial fast rate of foaming. A dense foam would imply the presence of surface active components that stabilize the gas bubbles. I seem to recall this being the case in ice cream soda float drinks. The dilution effect of more solution would help in reaching the equilibrium condition faster but the drink is then pretty flat.

Hot milk and vodka!
I'm going to the restroom now.
Regards

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Hey Tom,

Actually this has been bothering me ever since, but I decided never to proceed with experimentations in that direction anymore:  what happens to the hot milk and vodka in an acidic environment at 37 degrees C?  What exactly was it that decided to shoot up? ;)

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Gag reflex, depending upon your constitution?
Biochemistry is not my field, forgotten a lot of organic chemistry as well. Might guess that carbonates, if any, e.g. calcium carbonate in milk would react with acids to release CO2 gas, may push liquid up, reflex takes over. But would also be a factor in milk with soft drink. My last on this tangent.
Regards

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Mine too.  Sorry about the unpleasant memories

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

With soda in plastic bottles  you are concerned with the "permeation rate" of CO2 thru the plastic wall.  The permeation rate is = solubility x diffusivity, or P=SD.  A balloon goes flat quickly when you blow it up my mouth because the CO2 is soluble in the balloon rubber.  When the coke is put in the two smaller bottles, there is no CO2 dissolved in the plastic, and the coke goes flat because the plastic absorbs the CO2.  With the larger bottle the CO2 is already at equilibrium with the plastic bottle wall in terms of solubility.  The flat coke tastes bad possibly because plastic monomer dissolves in the coke.  Monomers are frequently carcinogenic - like vinyl and acrylic monomers

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

Milk in the stomach curdles - turns into a cottage cheese. That's the acid at work. The fats in milk will absorb alcohol and hold onto it for some time. It's a good plan to have fatty food in you before imbibing. Without the fats, the alcohol goes straight to the blood.

Is this the longest-lasting thread in the Chemical Engineering forums? You don't know where a question will lead.

Cheers,
John.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

John, I think it (at least one of).  Probably because on most other threads, a person would receive a satisfactory response and go on back to work.  Here it is just a way to talk about serious issues with a smile.

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

(OP)
chemenco,

Do you mean that the CO2 is actually absorbed into the plastic itself?  If so, how would glass react?

Steve

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

SteveBzzz,
Yes, the CO2 actually dissolves in the plastic, and over time it diffuses through to the outer surface and is lost.  Given enough time, all the CO2 will be lost in this manner.  CO2 is lost through plastic bottles more rapidly than through glass because the solubility and diffusivity of CO2 in glass are less than in plastic.
I don't have the numbers in front of me but I suspect that due to the relatively low solubility of CO2 in plastic (compared to cola), and more importantly the low mass of plastic relative to that of the cola it holds, that this is not a major contributor to the loss of CO2.
Any thoughts anybody?

RE: Cola behaves differently in various bottle sizes ???

If not CO2, could the caffeine -added to all cola drinks- have any effect when transferring cola from one bottle to another ?

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources