stairs reinforcement - how to detail at best? logic or purely in plan?
stairs reinforcement - how to detail at best? logic or purely in plan?
(OP)
Hi
it is a long debate in our office how to detail the staircases at best. There are different opinions so that's why I would like to hear your opinion
I believe that a reinforcement drawing must make things clear and easy to understand for the steel fixer. That's why i would even indicate in the layout bend bars as "bend bars" whereby they should be in the plan view just straight.
See attachment
What is your opinion? How would you indicate your re bars in the layout? Bend? to make things more clear or "correct in plan" just streetlight?
lolobau
it is a long debate in our office how to detail the staircases at best. There are different opinions so that's why I would like to hear your opinion
I believe that a reinforcement drawing must make things clear and easy to understand for the steel fixer. That's why i would even indicate in the layout bend bars as "bend bars" whereby they should be in the plan view just straight.
See attachment
What is your opinion? How would you indicate your re bars in the layout? Bend? to make things more clear or "correct in plan" just streetlight?
lolobau






RE: stairs reinforcement - how to detail at best? logic or purely in plan?
http://files.engineering.com/getfile.aspx?folder=4...
RE: stairs reinforcement - how to detail at best? logic or purely in plan?
RE: stairs reinforcement - how to detail at best? logic or purely in plan?
RE: stairs reinforcement - how to detail at best? logic or purely in plan?
RE: stairs reinforcement - how to detail at best? logic or purely in plan?
Concrete sections should normally be shown at 1:20 scale, so that is what I would want.
RE: stairs reinforcement - how to detail at best? logic or purely in plan?
just that the scale is quote odd 1:20?
we usually go for 1:25
althought I belive it must be shown as large as possibel if the drawin has the space. Why not blow it up to 1:18 for example if it fits on the drawing. You anyway are not allowed to measure ( to scale) from the drawing so why not showng thigs as clear and big as possibel
by reinforcement drawings like for example stairs fligh sections. Would you really indicate the scale? or also blow them up? basicaly explode the section? to achieve such an diagram
RE: stairs reinforcement - how to detail at best? logic or purely in plan?
Your section looks good. The top bar labelled 7 is probably not required full length, but I would put a bend on the bottom end.