×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

bars cut by acetylene torth

bars cut by acetylene torth

bars cut by acetylene torth

(OP)

The worker use acetylene to cut excess rebars protruding from a footing. When a rebar is heated by acetylene until it is cut. How much is the thermal expansion of the bars inside the concrete? What is the strain usually? Would it be more than the strain the concrete can handle and would the concrete crack from the inside from the thermal expansion of the bars?

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

Not a big deal. Heating is very localized as would be any effect on concrete. Not enough heat transfer to affect the concrete more than a couple of inches away.

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

(OP)

Quote:

Not a big deal. Heating is very localized as would be any effect on concrete. Not enough heat transfer to affect the concrete more than a couple of inches away.

If you hold a rebar and acetylene torch the front of it a foot away. Are you saying the heat of the torch won't even travel 1 foot? Isn't it iron a great heat conductor?

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

Slight correction: Acetylene provides enough heat to get the steel up to orange heat. The cutting starts when the oxygen is turned on. At that point, acetylene is superfluous; iron is the fuel.

As to the other points, yes, the steel conducts heat fairly well, but the concrete is a pretty good heat sink, and effectively limits the temperature excursion.

Should you elect to conduct an experiment, do be careful; concrete spalls violently when heated directly by oxyacetylene.


Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

The previous, last sentence is very important from a safety related point of view. Welding (or cutting) of steel on/adjacent to/partly embedded in concrete can have disastrous consequences due to the moisture content of (cured) concrete.

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

will there now be rebar exposed to soil where it was cut off? or is there more footing to be poured? Sounds like the fact you may now have zero concrete cover on the rebar is the bigger issue.

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

Campro: Does it really matter? Steel stress there is pretty skimpy. How far in will corrosion go? Probably not far.

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

Corrosion will go as far as any and all of the metal left inside the concrete can touch both air (oxygen) and the metal, and goes faster when ANY water or humidity near the metal can't evaporate because it is trapped under the concrete.

Sure, it will be a little bit slower deep inside the concrete because air flow is limited down there, but it will never stop corroding. Completely covered rebar will NOT corrode.

Cut off rebar (by definition!) will be left with the ends exposed, and is likely to be further exposed by the concrete spalling from incidental heating at the concrete surface.

To the original question. This is a bad idea, but not because of the thermal expansion of the rebar. The distance between "cold" rebar and the very hot tip is very, very short once the rebar goes into the concrete and doesn't get hit with the flames. thus, there very very little linear thermal expansion. Right at the surface, the rebar is constrained against movement INTO the concrete, and has no restraint against expanding into the air outside the concrete, so it will tend to expand away from the surface, not axially nor radially into the concrete. Spalling is a danger.

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

Cutting with a grinder is preferable. After cutting, apply a little tar over the cut ends.

BA

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

racookpe,
Cutting it off at the surface will not lead to corrosion deep within the footing unless the footing is in a very corrosive environment. The alkalinity of the concrete protects the reinforcing. There is always oxygen within concrete, as it is a porous material, but corrosion does not occur as long as the pH is high.

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

I was looking at 'worse case" - near ocean, concrete piers and railings with constant exposed conditions (winter salt + summer heat/humidity). 25+ years and the foundations and rebar and exposed steel bolts (embed anchor bolts) in concrete were "gone" underneath the towers and bents I've looked at.

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

What about floors with mesh that may not all be held up during concrete placement. I've never run into a problem there.

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

(OP)
racookpe1978

[To the original question. This is a bad idea, but not because of the thermal expansion of the rebar. The distance between "cold" rebar and the very hot tip is very, very short once the rebar goes into the concrete and doesn't get hit with the flames. thus, there very very little linear thermal expansion. Right at the surface, the rebar is constrained against movement INTO the concrete, and has no restraint against expanding into the air outside the concrete, so it will tend to expand away from the surface, not axially nor radially into the concrete. Spalling is a danger. ]

Were you describing about concrete or bars spalling (breaking away into pieces)?

What is the evidence concrete can act as heat sink of the bars inside it.. concrete are not metal and doesn't conduct heat so easily. It is said concrete conducts heat only about 1/500 the rate of silver.

Not that I'd do it again. The workers did it without my knowledge. I won't let them do it again, but want to know the principles. Ty

RE: bars cut by acetylene torth

Thermal inertance of a heat sink has more to do with mass than with conductivity. Trust me on this; I live in a concrete block house; it takes a long time to react to any temperature change at its surface.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources