×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

(OP)
Dear Experts,

As per the subject, if an upstream IED using Modbus and downstream IED using IEC61850 communication, how to implement the intertrip/interlock function between them?

The upstream and downstream equipment are located very far from each other where hardwire connection is not possible and fiber optic is the only solution.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

Some form of intermediary device that can speak both Modbus and IEC61850 would be about the only option.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

https://www.selinc.com/SEL-2505/?v=2#st_options

Depends on what you mean by "very far". You would need dark fiber available to use the SEL-2505, but with single-mode, it has a range of 80 km.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

MODBUS is not designed for critical functions like breaker interlocking. For this you should use the IEC61850 protocol. A possible solution is to hardwire an output from the Modbus device and use a low end IEC61850 capable device as a converter and have it transmit the contact status via the IEC 61850 protocol over fiber to the remote site using the IEC 61850 capable IED. But even in this config there will be some additional milliseconds of delay, which may or may not be acceptable in your specific application.

If you proivde details on the two IED's you are using we might be able to proivde a better answer.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

Use SEL2506 with HW connection between both IED. 8 DI, 8DO, fast and simple.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

Or, if you want a bit more information about what happens in the link replace one or both of the SEL-2505s with an SEL-2411, a bit of over kill but with full SER capability where the 2505 provides no SER.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

(OP)
The distance is about 3-4km. We are still in design stage hence the IED models are not available yet.

Using a converter sounds like the feasible solution. The fiber optic cable need to go through a FO patch panel if I'm not mistaken. I need to use two/four core for the intertrip/interlocking?

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

What kind of interlocking are we talking about? Is it for life safety, or just maintaining a switching sequence?

Regards
Marmite

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

(OP)
The interlock is to prevent downstream breaker to be closed when the upstream breaker is still open. So there must be a permissive to close signal from upstream.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

Have you considered installing a VT on the upstream side of the downstream breaker? Then you could block close on a dead line; you could even trip on a dead line. Let the power system tell you the status of the upstream breaker.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

So, do you want to know if the upstream feeder is live before you allow the downstream breaker to close? Or, do you want to know if the upstream breaker is closed? They may not be the same thing. I would consider a VT as David suggests. The simpler the better for interlocking.
Regards
Marmite

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

(OP)
I just want to know the upstream breaker is closed and in service position.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

intretrip is protection signal. it must be safety, fast signal.
you can use only dedicated devices, Im strongly not recommended use any media converters.
interlocks is additional signal, same FO

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

What, if anything, has to happen to the downstream breaker when the upstream breaker is opened or trips?

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

(OP)
For the interip protection, it's possible to use a converter for converting the fiber optic signal. Since there is no conversion of communication protocol but only the type signal being changed, the action should be fast enough. Please let me know your opinion.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

OP - Can you clarify what protocol you are referring too? You say thatthere is no conversion of communication protocol, but Modbus and 61850 are not compatible, they are two different protocols regardless of the physical layer. Are you referring to different solution (SEL devices are an excellent solution) that has been proposed? what protocol are you converting between electrical and optical? If you provide the sequence of components you are considering from beginning to end, we may be able to help you find a viable solution.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

(OP)
Sorry for the late reply. I'll put in point form for a better description of the problem:

1. Downstream IED must be compatible with IEC61850 as per project specification.
2. Upstream (separate power provider)IED not necessary to follow IEC61850 and they can use whatever communication protocol.
3. Intertrip/Interlock between the IED must be thru fiber due to the long distance.
4. Upstream IED not confirm having fiber optic connection port. Downstream IED fiber optic connection will be used to connect to electrical control system. Most probably there won't be additional fo ports available.

SEL device help to convert the fiber optic signal. But it didn't solve the communication protocol issue.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

It seems to me that you need to find an upstream IED that will take a 52a contact from the breaker and convert it to IEC61850. Using Modbus communications from an upstream IED would not be fast enough to meet your requirements for IEC61850 even if you could convert the protocol.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

The SEL device solution solves the protocol problem by ignoring it. Hard wire in at one end and hard wire out at the other end. The interlocking function could be hard wired or it could happen in logic.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

(OP)
I can use two SEL device as davidbeach pointed out. For the interlocking signal maybe I could suggest extra core in the fiber optic cable connection between the two IED.

Or I can use the protocol converter as jghrist stated. But when you said 'would not be fast enough to meet your requirements for IEC61850' are you referring to the GOOSE messaging?

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

I am assuming GOOSE messaging and that if the project specification was for IEC61850, then the speed of IEC61850 would be required. I don't know if there is a protocol converter.

Using two SEL-2505's would be the simplest and probably most economic solution if the Mirrored Bits communications would be acceptable.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

I would do what jghrist recommended. Cheap, easy and effective.

RE: Intertrip/Interlocking between IED which using different communication protocol

(OP)
Dear All,

Thanks you for your supportive answers. I have few options now and will choose the most economical solution when finalize the design.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources