×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

(OP)
I am working on a budgetary number for a parking ramp. The large footing pads do not have an actual rebar design yet, but there is a note stating that the reinforcing requirements shall be 1% of the concrete volume.

The sizes are as follows:

10-0 x 10-0 x 28" (8.641975 CY or 233.3333 CF)
12-0 x 12-0 x 32" (14.22222 CY or 384 CF)
14-0 x 14-0 x 36" (21.77778 CY or 588 CF)
20-0 x 20-0 x 42" (51.85185 CY or 1400 CF)
25-0 x 25-0 x 48" (92.59259 CY or 2500 CF)
20-0 x 31-0 x 48" (91.85185 CY or 2480 CF)
31-0 x 20-0 x 48" (91.85185 CY or 2480 CF)
34-0 x 20-0 x 48" (100.7407 CY or 2720 CF)

How do you go about calculating what the rebar would be? In my experience in jobs of this size, the footing pads have a double layer of rebar (one top and bottom).

If you need any further information from me, please let me know.

Regards,
Chris

RE: Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

1% of concrete volume (for steel volume) seems simple to me. Whether the estimate proves correct or not will be known once the design is done.

RE: Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

Dont know if this will help but I came across a conversion factor by weight for unknown rebar.
Multiply your CF x 165= x tons/2000 lbs per ton = tons of concrete w/ rebar.
Your example:
233.33 x 165 = 38499.45 / 2000 = 19.249 tons

Let me know if this does anything for you.

RE: Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

frostryan's conversion factor is well off the mark. 1% of 233.33 CF is 2.33 CF of steel, which weighs about 1140 pounds. I have no idea if that is what the footing requires, but that is what the note says.

RE: Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

generally require area of steel as a percentage of the area of the structural element. not sure how volume of steel entered into the picture.

What I have done previously is take a fully designed, similar structure, calculate the weight of steel for that structure as a percentage of the concrete volume and use that number for estimating. Say 140 lbs steel per cubic yard which will give you a fairly heavily reinforced structure such as a box culvert

RE: Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

cvg,
The 1% volume would give 132 pounds/CY, so not far from your estimating value.

RE: Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

frostryan's formula essentially says that rebar is 4.4% by volume (or given a prismatic section, this is the steel area as a percent of gross area of section).

If you subscribe to a unit-weight-of-reinforced-concrete formulation such as frostryan's, a bunch of algebra yields the following:

Vs ≡ (w-wc)/(ws-wc)*V [EQUATION 1]

Where V = Total volume of reinforced concrete element
Vs = Total volume of steel in the element volume
w = unit weight of total volume (= 165 lb/ft3 according to frostryan's formula)
wc = unit weight of concrete (= 150 lb/ft3 - a typical value)
ws = unit weight of steel (= 490 lb/ft3)

This seems pretty steep to me, but ymmv. It would probably be useful to run a bunch of typical concrete elements that you use in your particular application and see what you come up with.

If you calculate the weight of your steel for a given concrete volume, you can then calculate "w" as follows:

w = Ws/(ws*V)*(ws-wc)+wc [EQUATION 2]

Where Ws = Total weight of reinforcement for a given total volume V.

You'd then have a handy-dandy value for "w" (again, in frostryan's example w = 165 lb/ft3) to plug into EQUATION 1, to estimate your steel weight from a given volume of concrete. I suggest this calculation is idiosyncratic to the typical types of concrete elements you deal with, and your particular detailing preferences. But if you have a large enough "database" against which to apply EQUATION 2, then EQUATION 1 would be a very handy formula. I'd suggest having a value of "w" for beams of s certain size, another for columns (possibly by type), another for slabs, and so on.

OH...simply multiply the result of EQUATION 1 by ws (= 490 lb/ft^3, e.g.) to obtain the WEIGHT per unit volume, since you typically want that value rather than just the volume:

Ws = ws*(w-wc)/(ws-wc)*V [EQUATION 1a]

That variable "w" is the linchpin for the whole procedure.

"No one is completely useless. He can always serve as a bad example." --My Dad ca. 1975

RE: Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume


hokie66 "The 1% volume would give 132 pounds/CY, so not far from your estimating value"

If you assume 1% by volume (or area of prismatic section - which incidentally is the minimum reinforcement required for a column by ACI 318), then:

w = 0.01(ws-wc)+wc = 0.01*(490 lb/ft3 - 150 lb/ft3) + 150 lb/ft3

= 153.4 lb/ft3

(Compare with the value of 165 given in frostryan's formula).

"No one is completely useless. He can always serve as a bad example." --My Dad ca. 1975

RE: Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

I cannot believe that this is causing so much angst.

If the concrete volume is 233.33ft3 and steel weighs 490lbs/ft3, then at 1% reinforcing by volume

steel reqd = 1 / 100 *233.33 * 490 = 1143lbs.

What has concrete density got to do with it?

RE: Reinforcing requirements based on % of concrete volume

rapt...we can overthink anything! hokie66's first answer was the right one and nothing necessary beyond!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources