×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

(OP)
I have calculated the moment of inertia of a 2x4, 18-inch deep modified metal-plated flat truss as 1312.79 from standard "equal rectangle" formula in the AISC manual. Can someone tell me where to obtain wood floor truss section properties listed? I believe this looks correct. I am not into wood trusses, but I need to check some deflection figures. Hmmm.

Thank you for your assistance.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

I typically use the 100% chord value, as I believe you have done, and reduce it by 15% to account for shear deformation. I don't know of anywhere where this is tabulated.

I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

(OP)
KK . . . Thank you for responding. I am attempting to verify some deflection calculations from a plate mfgr. software program. Do you know if they reduce their I in their calculations?

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

They wouldn't have an "I" per se. Rather, they would use true truss theory to determine displacements, similar to how we might do in SAP, RISA, etc. Or, goodness forbid, by hand.

I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

(OP)
Using the 1312.79 I came up with a smaller deflection, using TPI formulas, than the deflection that shows up on the individual truss print. 0.72 inches by my calc. - 1.19 inches on the print

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

I would expect their value to be higher than yours as their value includes the shear deflection that will occur via elongation of the truss webbing. In this case, my 15% estimate would have been considerably low.

I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

When I was just starting in the engineering profession, my boss told me to increase deflection by 10% when using moment of inertia determined from the chords only. He was referring to open web steel joists, but it should be about the same for wood trusses 18" deep.

For 2x4 chords and depth of 18", moment of inertia cannot be as high as you have calculated.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

I believe I = 552 in4. That is about 42% of your calculated value. So your deflection should have been .72/0.42 = 1.71". Increase that by 10% = 1.88" which is 58% more than shown on the print. Something's wrong somewhere.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

Agree with BA. Your arithmetic is obviously wrong.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

(OP)
Guys . . . so what equasion should I be using to figure for a wood truss 18 inches deep with 2x4 chords & 2x4 webs - 4 inch dimension horizontal? Obviously, I am using the wrong equasion.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

You quoted the AISC "equal rectangle" equation. That is correct. bd^3/12, and deduct bd1^3/12. If the 2 x 4 members are flat, your I will be larger than BA's answer, which I think assumed the members vertical. I get 716, based on 1.5 x 3.5 members. I don't know exactly how big a 2 x 4 is in the US these days.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

You should use the following:
I = 2*A*y2
A is the area of one 2x4 = 1.5*3.5 = 5.25in2
y is the distance from the centroid of the truss to the centroid of 2x4 = 7.25"
so I = 2*5.25*(7.25)2 = 551.9

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

I don't know what formula the TPI recommends. It might be the difference between two rectangular areas, the outer one being 1.5 x 18 and the inner one being 1.5 x 11 (the clear distance between chords).

That would give you I = 1.5 (183 - 113)/12 = 562.6, a little more than found before. The difference is the moment of inertia of two 2x4 which I believe should be ignored.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

BA, in his last post, he said the members are horizontal, so the two rectangles would be 3.5 x 18 and 3.5 x 15.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

Okay hokie, I missed that. In that case I = 2*5.25*8.252 = 714.6 in4

Or, using the other formula, I = 3.5(183 - 153)/12 = 716.6 which is only a little more because Ichord is small.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

(OP)
BAretired & hokie66 - Thanks for your patience & diligence. I had the right equasion, just somehow used the wrong d1.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

Quote (DCEngr1)

Using the 1312.79 I came up with a smaller deflection, using TPI formulas, than the deflection that shows up on the individual truss print. 0.72 inches by my calc. - 1.19 inches on the print

There is still a problem, however. Using 714.6 in4, you should calculate a deflection of 0.72*1312.79/714.6 = 1.32" which is 11% more than the value on the print; and if you increase deflection to allow for web member distortion, you would have 1.32*1.15 = 1.52" according to KootK or 1.32*1.10 = 1.45 according to my old boss, neither agreeing with the published value within acceptable tolerance.

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

A little off topic, but I too was always told to take a 15% reduction for shear deformation of the web members when analyzing a truss based upon the moment of inertia of the chords. This was from one of my professors in school.... and I believe my old boss as well. I still use this number today, however, I could never prove that it is correct or incorrect if required. Good to know I can at least do one thing right :).

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

Just subtract the I of a 3.5x15" from a 3.5x18" rectangle. Easier math.

When I am working on a problem, I never think about beauty but when I have finished, if the solution is not beautiful, I know it is wrong.

-R. Buckminster Fuller

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

Easier than what?

RE: Moment of Inertia - 18-inch deep 2x4 Modified Warren Flat Truss

SteelPE,

If you make a little truss in RISA, you get something close to the 85% number. Could have just been dumb luck on my part. I can never come close to matching the Mitek software deflections.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources