Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Use of B31.4 for temperatures belwo -30 degrees 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

nipra03

Mechanical
Sep 7, 2011
29
I was recently made aware that the B31.4 code states (400.1.2) that it was not developed for piping with design temp. less than -30 dgrees C. My query is what code do we follow for cases where we have lower temps e.g. -34 C as is the case for some areas of NE USA.
The Canadian pipeline code Z662 which is similar to B31.4 does not have this limitation.
My interpretation is although it says "not developed", we can still apply the code with engineering judgement .
Am I correct ?


 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

"Was not developed" are the key words.
Use A333 as bimr suggests.
I have done the same for liquid anhydrous ammonia pipeline at -33C using A333.
 
It seems that you go into process piping area with the temperature.
 
If you are building a pipeline, you don't have the choice of changing codes (will you drop the pipeline markers, will you drop the burial depth provisions, etc), although you could incorporate various aspects of B31.3 if appropriate, which doesn't mean you are stretching the B31.4 code all that much by simply lowering the temperature, as long as the material is used within its limits.
 
Good luck at moving oil at -33C; light ends (gasoline) no problem. Are you misinterpreting the low ambient temperature as the MDMT?
 
I posted a reply which got lost, but my point is where do you stop? -40, -50 ??

Also B 31.4 has another section - 401.2.3.7 which strongly implies that outside the -30C / 120C range the design stress or design factor would need to be modified. Sure you can get material to work down to temperatures outside those limits, but maybe not at a DF of 0.72??

31.3 would result in a higher wall thickness, but work outside the written boundaries of a code and you are in gradually increasing murky waters.

The real issue is is that a temperature the pipe will actually see.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.
 
Cold isn't as dangerous as hot, as axial loads are usually tension, as are hoop stress, so both being on the same side of Mohr's circle means lesser total shear stress. The tendency for buckling is also greatly reduced. It definitely stops at the material's range, or wherever the analysis gets fuzzy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor