×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

LVL Crushing

LVL Crushing

LVL Crushing

(OP)
Was in a crawlspace today of a 3 story, wood framed condo. Was there investigating continued complaints of sheetrock cracks. Based on my laser measurements, pier settlement seems to be the biggest offender. However, I also observed many instances of the 3-ply, 18" LVL beams in the crawlspace showing signs of crushing over their SYP wood blocks (see attached). I measured about 1/4" of crushing with a computed existing load reaction of about 7k or 200 PSI perp. to grain. The SYP appears unfazed by the load. WTF? I though the LVL design values were about 750 psi for perp. to grain loading.
The LVL brand is "Weldwood" which appears to have been bought out years ago. My guess is no help from the new owner.

The building is 10 years old and pretty consistently lightly loaded with retirees (trussed roof clear spans the crawlspace). As such, I doubt the load changes much. Do you think the crushing has done all it is going to do?

RE: LVL Crushing

I would have put money on the plates crushing before the LVLs. It's hard to tell from the pictures. Maybe the environment had something to do with the glue losing capacity. Don't know.

When I am working on a problem, I never think about beauty but when I have finished, if the solution is not beautiful, I know it is wrong.

-R. Buckminster Fuller

RE: LVL Crushing

Are you sure the LVL is crushing? It looks like the SPF 2X block to me...

Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)


RE: LVL Crushing

If the glue loses capacity then you'd most likely see a direct reduction in compression perp. to grain.

A picture taken from slightly above the plate looking at the LVL would help determine that the plate isn't spreading/crushing at the end as well.

Any thoughts on redistribution of floor loading caused by pier settlement? Further, floor loading at this one reaction point is actually more than you think, especially if the LVL's are continuous over supports allowing redistribution of load due to settlement of piers at surrounding areas.

Just a thought...

Virginia PE, SE

RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
@PJW.
It is happening at most of the piers. The LVL's are cont, but about 4 spans worth so the reaction is not that much more than simple span.
The owners want to just patch up the sheetrock at this point and visually monitor it.

RE: LVL Crushing

The 2nd picture is definitely helpful. You can see the grain deformation in the 2nd.

Are moisture and temperature something to consider in the NDS load factors? It is a crawl space, so moisture is probably higher (probably not temperature, most likely cooler).

It's probably best to just visually monitor settlement and crushing at the plate.

Virginia PE, SE

RE: LVL Crushing

Is it a built up beam? If so are all of the plys flush at the bottom?

I have seen similar crushing where one of the plys was a bit thicker than it's counterparts, so the load was directly on that one ply until it crushed down flush with the rest and gave full bearing.

RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
@Signious - it looks like the plys are flush.

I have had so many problems throughout the years of sagging LVL's that the manufacturer's blame on "putting them up wet" so now I oversize them considerably (even more than I always have).
Now I have to contend with crushing at the bearings - jeez!

RE: LVL Crushing

Are there floor joists that frame into the sides of the LVL, or does the floor framing bear on the LVL? I wonder if it's a load distribution through the built up beam. If they aren't connected together properly, one side can take more load than the other, depending on the spans. I've read about this happening, but I've never seen anything like it before. Are all the plies crushing?

RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
They are all dropped beams so the load should be pretty evenly distributed

RE: LVL Crushing

I'm guessing the spans are pretty similar, so that would rule out the uneven loading. That's very unnerving to see it crushed like that under such a relatively light load. Is the LVL crushing on both sides of the blocks?

RE: LVL Crushing

If the pier was settling, why is the metal strap to the right in the second picture buckled? Looks more like the pier has heaved, particularly considering the fact that the crack in the footing to the right appears to be wider at the top than further down.

Can't explain why the LVL would fail over the SPF though, unless there was water/moisture damage. Is the crawl space vented properly? Any standing water in the crawlspace?

Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)


RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
@mike20793 - some are, some are not. Might be that the pier cap is not level.
@M^2 - The strap is not buckled. It was installed in the wrong location and just beat with a hammer until it met the LVL.

RE: LVL Crushing

Is the crawl space vented properly? Any standing water in the crawlspace?

Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)


RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
The crawlspace did not seem overly wet and did not see any mold growing on the trusses. I did not bring my moisture meter with me, however.
Might be worth another trip out there.

RE: LVL Crushing

Just because it is not now does not mean so in the past. Any recent floods in the area?

Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)


RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
Went back to the site with my moisture meter. Readings on all beams were between 15 and 17%. Over 16% is not considered a dry service condition. I imagine in the summer, the readings would be a lot higher. It is a large crawlspace with very little venting and an incomplete vapor barrier. My guess is the elevated moisture has some responsibility for the crushing of the LVL's.

RE: LVL Crushing

What is the metal strap? It almost looks like a post base. Is there a concentrated load above that was intended to transfer into the post base? It appears there is a large gap between the post base and LVL's?

RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
It appears to be a poorly located tie-down strap that is performing zero function

RE: LVL Crushing

Have you run the numbers on the bearing. I don't know why I didn't think of this earlier but prior to forte there was a program to design lvl and lsl beams called TJBeam and it didn't check bearing

When forte came out with the bearing check included I know it was a shock for some people how often bearing was the controlling failure mode.

Is it possible that the original designer didn't check?

In my experience deep narrow lvls don't do well with bearing

RE: LVL Crushing

The 2x (2x10 ?) treated horizontal spacer is squished (picture 1 and 2) and the LVL is squished also (picture 2).

But the horizontal 2x10 is in a" safe" (flat) condition, isn't it?

But, the two seem to have squished "safely" in that they are not delaminating nor distorting across the web: Only the lower "flange" of the LVL is distorted - and that distortion is on the bottom of the lower flange. The upper flange appears un-distorted, doesn't it?

What do the other posts in the basement look like?

RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
The upper portion of the LVL;s are fine. This is a crawlspace, not a basement. The situation is similar on about 50/% of the piers.

RE: LVL Crushing

You said 3 storeys right?

Does this post only pick up a small portion of the main floor?

7k seems low for standard residential loading, at 60PSF total that's just over 100 sqft. A 3 ply 18" lvl should be more than capable of that.

RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
@Jayrod12;

I based the numbers on the current loads - which are about 20 psf total (not the design loads). The girders do not span very far.
You use 60 for residential? I use 40 live and 10 dead. Even if the actual dead is higher, I know I the floor will never see 40 psf anyhow.

RE: LVL Crushing

This is definitely moisture related, and detail related.

The 2X member on which the LVL bears is not treated, and there is no building paper between the concrete aid the 2X plate to prevent moisture migration. The LVL is seeing moisture from the concrete through the 2X plate.

The LVL specs in the #TJ-9020 Specifier's Guide definitely say that they are not for use in a "wet" environment, however they do not allude as to what they consider "wet". Probably have to call Weyerhaeuser on that. The Fc Perp is 750 psi and cannot be increased for duration of loading, so a higher than allowed load should not be the problem here.

I would recommend jacking up the LVL to relieve the load to the 2X plate, pulling the plate out, installing 2 layers of 90# building paper over the concrete, and reinstalling the 2X plate. May have to temporarily disconnect the strap too. I would also recommend better ventilation in the crawlspace, even if has to be forced. This will not remove the deformation, but prevent more from occurring.

Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)


RE: LVL Crushing

Fair enough. But it is entirely possible it saw something closer to design loading at some point and the crushing occured. There's no rebounding from that.

and even at 1/4" of crushing that's still likely a tolerable amount if it doesn't progress further. I would be any damage seen above is 95% due to pier settlement and 5% others factors (I still wouldn't attribute the whole 5% to lvl crushing)

RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
@Mike;

How do you know it is not treated - i bet it is.
Also, no one has every put anything between the 2x and the pier in any structure I have been in - just not a common practice around here.
I have already recommended a sealed crawlspace system.

@Jayrod - "But it is entirely possible it saw something closer to design loading at some point and the crushing occured"
I find this unlikely, but certainly possible. My money is on the moisture

RE: LVL Crushing

I like Mike's hypothesis

RE: LVL Crushing

@ XR250: The plate looks like either DF or Pine, not Hem-fir, and has no PT indentations or discoloring at the periphery from what I see. Perhaps there is another photo?

Thanks boo1. I try to please... bigsmile

Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)


RE: LVL Crushing

I am apologizing in advance for this - but I promised myself a long time ago I would speak up whenever I see something like this.

"Also, no one has every put anything between the 2x and the pier in any structure I have been in - just not a common practice around here."

This really irks me. It is a really easily accomplished task, and everyone knows why it is important. Saying no one does it is a really piss poor excuse not to require it yourself, it is a code item where I am, and I suspect a code item anywhere - wood in contact with soil-contacting concrete is P.treated or 6mil poly gets put down.

RE: LVL Crushing

Signious:

I fully agree...

Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)


RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
@Mike and Signius - Please take some chill pills!

Mike - Our PT wood is pine and it does not have indentations. Once it ages, you cannot tell the difference between PT and non-PT.
@Signious - my comment assumed that a PT sill plate was used - which it typical in all of our construction.

FWIW, I have been doing this since 1991 and have literally been in 250 crawlspaces per year since then (probably significantly more than anyone on this forum). Most of the homes I look at are 40 to 80 years old and have their pine or oak beams bearing directly on masonry piers. Few have any rot. The ones that do typically have a widespread problem as well. As such, the whole "don't let non-PT wood touch masonry" argument does not hold too much water with me (no pun intended) even though I adhere to that rule. Even in this particular case, some of the LVL beams were bearing directly on masonry. Their moisture readings were no different than any other beams and were actually in the best condition.

RE: LVL Crushing

Been there too over 40 years. To each his own. Good luck.

Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)


RE: LVL Crushing

What is a better hypothesis then?
Could wicked moisture be seasonal or one time, wetting the LVL leading to the localized crushing?

RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
My guess is that in the summer, the MC is alot higher. Also, alot times the LVL's are very wet from sitting on the jobsite (despite the coating). So the crushing may have occurred during construction before they "dried out" . I am going to have them get the moisture under control. At that point we can discuss whether they want to spend the money to jack and re-shim for a larger bearing area.

RE: LVL Crushing

The 2x is appears to be a piece of treated southern pine. The green hue comes from the treating process. It's almost as hard as the concrete it sit's on! If you've ever tried to drive a nail thru it after its aged (even a short while)you know that you have a better chance of hitting the lottery. I put down at least a hundred miles of this stuff as exterior decking back in the day and it was hard to work with. Not sure where this building is but I'm on the eastern seaboard and it is(was)the material choice.

RE: LVL Crushing

Quote (boo1)

Could wicked moisture be seasonal or one time, wetting the LVL leading to the localized crushing?
Just thought of this. Here's a thought based on my experience with this type of lumber. Most of the time we had full packs of pt lumber delivered to the job site based on the size of decks and such that we were building. If the packs had been exposed while stored at the lumberyard (uncovered) then the outer most pieces of the pack had started to dry and become hard and brittle. For the most part this type of lumber had an extremely high moisture content fresh out of the inside of the pack. I wonder if when this was constructed, was the piece of 2x overly wet and it "wicked" into the lvl. May not have been the only contributing factor but based on all the fluids that I wiped out of my eyes driving nails into this stuff it could be possible.

RE: LVL Crushing

(OP)
@4Thorns -
I hear you about the wet PT lumber. I think if that was the case, the LVL's would have slid off s the stuff can be like ice when wetbigsmile
BTW, it is central NC

RE: LVL Crushing

I'll go against some of the great ones here and vote against moisture being the suspect. I believe this is a result of differential settlement resulting in rotation in the beams and hence localized compressive stress at the edge of the bearing plate. I am wrong if the crushing is uniform under the beam. The two photos were not helpful enough.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources