×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

(OP)
Dears,

What are the applicable ways of Dismantling a bolted steel tank.

Background

The tank diameter is 26 meter and 10 meter height.
The tank has been on service for ten years.
the Tank Type is Bolted.

Thanks,
M.ALFAREH

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Depends on the future use of the tank doesn't it?

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

(OP)
The tank will go to scrap. It will not be used anymore.
I need to know what are the applicable ways to dismantle bolted tanks so we can use the best way to suit our capability.

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Cut it up with a torch. Cut out segments and drop the pieces down with a crane. Start at the top and work your way down. You can cut off the bolts if you like.

http://www.etradeasia.com/products_detail/367461/7...

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

(OP)
Thanks bimr,
what is the best way, (Safe, Time saving, efficient), that we can cut it out to segments

by welding machine
by grinder
by undoing the nuts
or other way

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Oxy/Acetylene torch if the metal can rust. undoing nuts or using grinder if stainless steel.

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

i just read your other post and regret making a comment.... you must have somebody who has experience to do this. Your questions show a truly fundamental unfamiliarity with this. You in no way provided us with the information needed to say how to do this safely. All methods of disassembly are UNSAFE without an experienced tank demolition contractor at the helm. You need a solid approach to phase this work in a way that protects the workers. Trust me... you don't want ANY inexperienced demolition workers either.

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

(OP)
Thanks darthsoilsguy2,

the tank is made of carbon steel, therefore, Oxy/Acetylene torch is the suitable way to dismantle it.
Is there any standards, recommendation, or common practice for such process?
I know it seems simple, cut and lift to the ground, but i am curious if there is any documented procedure.

Thanks,

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

(OP)
Dear darthsoilsguy2,

thanks again for the comment above, No need to regret, your comment was helpful for me.

FYI, the dismantling work will be handled by fully experienced team and engineers, the regulations are very strict in our plant.
My post above is to allow me understand the applicable ways of dismantling in order to understand the discussions/proposals of the dismantling team and be ready to show them our concerns.

Thanks,

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Farah,

I am fully agree with BIMR.

Erect scaffold full around the tank. Cut piece by piece using cutting torch. That lift by the crane put on the ground.

The scaffolding height must be adjusted to give a good access for the cutter and rigger.

This must be very old tanks. I don't think you can use electrical spanner to un-installed the bolts one by one.

The work just reverse from the erection. I mean we erect the tank from the bottom to the roof one by one so we dismantling from the roof to the bottom one by one as well.

Good luck

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Hire a demolition crew. They will bring in a nibbler and the tank will be gone in a day or less.

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

(OP)
Thanks Syah, well elaborated.

Thanks IFRs, Demolition with Nibbler is not allowed, apiece by piece dismantling is required.

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Where is the tank located and what were the contents ?

Were the former contents flammable or combustable or hazardous ?

What are you going to do about the partially embedded tank floor ?

Will the foundation also be demolished or do you intend on some kind of reuse ?

Foundation demolition will be formidable and require the use of power/air tools (jackhammers).

If power tools are allowed/required for foundation renovation.....then I do not understand why a nibbler would be banned.

What is the reasoning for this ?

MJCronin
Sr. Process Engineer

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

(OP)
Dear MJCronin ,

Where is the tank located and what were the contents ?
It is in the accommodation area of portable water tank farm, the content was water.

Were the former contents flammable or combustable or hazardous ?
No

What are you going to do about the partially embedded tank floor ?
it shall be removed in a safe way then go to scrap

Will the foundation also be demolished or do you intend on some kind of reuse ?
the foundation will be demolished and replaced with a new one.

Foundation demolition will be formidable and require the use of power/air tools (jackhammers).
Yes, the foundation will be demolished with a jack hammer or air compressor hammer

If power tools are allowed/required for foundation renovation.....then I do not understand why a nibbler would be banned

What is the reasoning for this ?

Nibbler is not banned but demolition is not allowed due to client requirements, the tank shall be dismantled into pieces, even though, it will go to scrap.

Thanks,

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Wow, what happened to that tank? Did the ground collapse causing the floor plates to rupture or did the tank leak and wash out the foundation?

First thing you need to do is fill in the hole with something solid.

If might seem initially a good idea to unbolt it, but with 10 years for paint and rust you'll spend so long trying to remove the bolts that you'll regret it. The sealing used will by now have the consistency of a super glue and the plates will not part very easily and could distort the tank. As per the posters above, I would scaffold this thing, attach some lifting pads to the roof and cut the roof off as a single element then cut plates out just below the original bolt line, both vertical and horizontal. Best cutter - probably torch, but you could use grinders - will just get gradually slower as you progress down the tank and take off one layer at a time.

Have no one inside the tank while your doing this as there is a risk a tank as damaged as this could just collapse inwards.

I would strongly urge you to employ a firm that has dismantled damaged tanks before because this could go horribly wrong.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

(OP)
Thanks Bimr,
Thanks LittleInch,

The tank had some leakage from bottom, The tank will be dismantles by experienced people and I need to understand the process.





RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

(OP)
Regarding the type of torch to be used,
Which type would be preferred in our case Gas torch or plasma Cutting torch.

the steel plates are about 10 mm thick and 2 m height and are glass coated.
In addition, is there a standard/recommended length of the pieces to be parted from the tank.

Thanks,

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Acetylene welding torches are used. The size of the pieces will depend on the crane and other equipment. The steel on bolted tanks is usually thin material.

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Fareh,

I used gas torch to cut the plate for dismantling purpose.

I use plasma during fabrication of bottom plate and roof plate.

It is correct the size of the piece that need to be cut its depend on your lifting equipments/gears.

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

fareh,

Size of plate is really just a matter of local practicality - how big is your crane, how much room have you for laydown and further cutting and how big are your trucks taking this stuff away?

you want to remove the walls in layers, probably no fewer than three for a tank this big to still give the tank some rigidity whilst it is being cut apart.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: Bolted Steel Tank Dismantling

Hi Fareh. We will have almost same project. We are still in document submittals for preliminary approval. In any case do you have Method Statement for dismantling the tank? Im trying to get one.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources