×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Smart projection views
7

Smart projection views

Smart projection views

(OP)
In NX drafting, is it possible to have smart projection views?

If I 2D rotate the Base View parallel to the sheet (Edit> Orient View Tool); I need to see the orthogonal projection views updates accordingly.

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

No.

John R. Baker, P.E.
Product 'Evangelist'
Product Engineering Software
Siemens PLM Software Inc.
Digital Factory
Cypress, CA
Siemens PLM:
UG/NX Museum:

To an Engineer, the glass is twice as big as it needs to be.

RE: Smart projection views

Do they do that into SolidWorks?

RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
Yes. Indeed. But I have to verify since I currently spend 99% of my time with NX.

You guys wanted to see other software functionality and when I show them with examples, I’m being accused for promoting the other software in this NX forum.

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

Please feel free to show as much examples of Solidworks functions that do not exist in NX today as you want because, as a long time UG user and developper, I'd really like to understand why SW is today the most used over the planet and in areas that goes beyond CAD.
No shame in shaking the old UG dog as it is, all in all, for its benefit.

RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
daluigi,
Unless someone specifically ask or inquire, I rarely mentioned about any other software and names in this forum. Recently, for one of my other replies, one blogger wrote,

Quote:

But please note that while posting SolidWorks videos may give you some level of personal satisfaction, when it comes to posting them in an purely NX oriented forum, even here on Eng-Tips, they tend to add very little to the process where others have come here to learn to use NX in a more productive and efficient manner.

First of all I can confirm that the software you questioned behaved as expected and beyond. Whatever I tested, all the dependent views were following the drawings standards and rules and also responded dynamically prompting with warnings and helping to resolve any shortfalls. While testing it, I felt how fluid and user-friendly it is and as a long time past user, how much I miss the productivity.

I think this is a basic functionality you expected from any CAD software. As parent, you show and teach your children the rules and how to behave, well and promptly as you move along in the real world. Even if I replace the Base View, the children adopted the new parent accordingly. With NX, the views are kind of dumb, no prompts, and sitting waiting until you see the problems and correct them. Maybe some of you wanted that way, to be in total control.

With my short YouTube research I couldn’t find a suitable clip to prove my findings. (I think it’s too basic for a recording.) But the following link caught my eye as a highlight. (Attention! Content may be inappropriate or irritant and contagious for certain NX users.) bigsmile

Link


Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

What has always suprised me over years is how those SW developpers have done that mature product that is so much intuitive in drafting but still based on the same old Parasolid kernel as UG... Great link, thank you.

RE: Smart projection views

I can understand the usefullness of being able to have all views respond when reorienting one, but only to the point at which you start to apply dimensions or specific detail views. In many (if not most) cases those dimensions will no longer be standard compliant (such as dimensioning to hidden features).
As in the drawing board days, us NX users still have to plan ahead when placing views.

"Know the rules well, so you can break them effectively."
-Dalai Lama XIV

RE: Smart projection views

I don't have access to that link here at work, but I am curious... what does happen to existing dimensions, sections and zoomed detailed views when the views are all reoriented? ponder
It would be very interesting if the data that they originally had shown remained without any standards violations.

"Know the rules well, so you can break them effectively."
-Dalai Lama XIV

RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
Let me explain little bit of my situation.

I’ve started to work with designs which have been cloning for years (15years?). Editing, adding or deleting components, Reference Sets; Updating the new and obsolete wave linked pockets through the assembly; what a lengthy process to get the work done. After a design review, have to go through again the same process. For me, this is a waste of resources. If they were made smart in the first place, could have got the work done with few clicks.

In this situation, I started new methods I used in the past. For instance, now when I edit/add/delete a sketch point, then quantity of components and all their pockets and depths in the assembly including threaded holes and information update automatically and smartly. (I found this is a new method to most of the NX users which they haven’t seen before). Stock sizes and drawing detail notes update automatically. (Since these are old designs, I didn't try PDW methods) Basically I’m making the old designs smarter and reducing repetitive manual work and errors/typos.

Now I’m trying to make the drawings smarter.
Ex. In the original design, the rectangular plates’ sketches were not square to their absolute datum. But the drawing views were rotated and aligned with XY and had created the orthogonal views. (= drawing is correct in that base view orientation)

When I open the new cloned and then modified (rotated as required for the new project) model’s drawings; the Base View is at a rotated angle and with the orthogonal projected views corresponding to its side views. Please see the attached sample drawing. My requirement is to rotate the new Base View so that the projected views update smartly. I.e. bringing the new crooked orthogonal views to default views as before.(= dimensions coming back to their original status.)

Some may say that redoing the view is easy, but it is an addition to the work load especially with dimensions with special tolerances, notes and texts attached to them. If I'm not mistaken, in NX must dimension first then have to go back to edit mode to add its tolerances and related notes. Do you guys enjoy this much of work?

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
ewh,
You may find answers to your concerns in the YouTube link I posted. If not give me a your specific problematic scenario and I'll try to show you the behavior.(If you are still curious. dazed)

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
I’m surprised that NX’s “View Alignment” can’t help in this situation.

There should be a way. It’s a very basic requirement.

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

Quote (MFDO)


If I'm not mistaken, in NX must dimension first then have to go back to edit mode to add its tolerances and related notes.

That's not true. Starting with NX 9.0 when you're placing a Dimension if you pause a second or two the 'edit' option appears and if you select it and then select the handle for the text, a pop-up dialog will appear where you can set all of the secondary items for a dimension, including style, tolerance, appended text, decimal places, etc. And of course, you can use this same pop-up when you actually are editing an existing dimension. Note that many people place their initial sets of dimension with just the nominal values set and only later do they come back and add tolerances and appended text and such, so what you say if the ONLY way that NX works is actually the approach that many people take in the first place. However, if you know exactly what you need to 'add' to your dimensions as you create them, you can work that way as well, if you prefer to. NX is flexible in that regard.

John R. Baker, P.E.
Product 'Evangelist'
Product Engineering Software
Siemens PLM Software Inc.
Digital Factory
Cypress, CA
Siemens PLM:
UG/NX Museum:

To an Engineer, the glass is twice as big as it needs to be.

RE: Smart projection views

Even before NX9, you can construct your most of your dimensions "on the fly" as you place them.

"Know the rules well, so you can break them effectively."
-Dalai Lama XIV

RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
We are off the track.

John, thanks for the tip. A Star is given.

But don’t you think it involves too many clicks? As soon as selecting the elements, editor should be available right there immediately to finish the work and place the dimension.

If you see the link I posted, did you notice that the presenter didn’t leave the working area to finish his drawing!

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

Quote (MFDO)

When I open the new cloned and then modified (rotated as required for the new project) model’s drawings; the Base View is at a rotated angle and with the orthogonal projected views corresponding to its side views. Please see the attached sample drawing. My requirement is to rotate the new Base View so that the projected views update smartly. I.e. bringing the new crooked orthogonal views to default views as before.(= dimensions coming back to their original status.)

Did I get it right that your solid is at arbitrary orientation each new design, but you need it to be aligned horizontally/vetically on the drawing?
This can be done using 'Orient view tool'. You pick up normal direction, and direction of X-axis, and regardless of orientation of actual geometry, the view always remains oriented in the same way.

www.cadroad.com

RE: Smart projection views

If you use the master model method, you could use assembly constraints to keep the model oriented correctly in the drawing file.

www.nxjournaling.com

RE: Smart projection views

MFDO,

I am not sure if I am understanding your question, totally. I know that, in NX 9.0, when you do a Projection View, you can determine where the hinge line is. The hinge line in UG means the reference to where to project the view from. So, in theory, you can project from any angle or feature. If that does not do what you call "smart projection view", sorry.

I have used Solidworks, and, I used to like how easy and intuitive it can be at times. But, Solidworks is a newer CAD system, and does not carry the grandfather CAD program and data capabilities that UG has to carry over. Plus, UG is incorporating IDEAs into the system to make it feasible for IDEAs users to use UG easier. Also, with UG, you don't have to start every model with a sketch, like Solidworks and other CAD systems require. UG and CATIA has always been the preferred systems to create A surfaces. Though with Solidworks' surfacing, I heard, is getting better, and that is the only part of the program that is very lacking, to compete against CATIA or UG.

If you look at the major companies in the industries, they still prefer CATIA or UG. I do not like CATIA's GUI system, where UG's GUI is very similar to Windows, which makes it a little easier to adapt to.

Sorry, if I am out of line, in discussing these two systems.

RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
Hey Guys, Thank you for joining the party.2thumbsup

Cowski, I like your workaround method. A star for you too. (Still it’s not the solution) PrintScaffold, thank you for elaborating Cowski’s idea.

These are 15 years old designs and will be very hard to change the internal file handling procedures. I assume 15 years ago NX didn’t offer Master Model Technique (MMT). From the beginning of my NX, I was pushing for MMT. Now I found another reason to show the justification. Also I've done some bench marking work with MMT showing good results.

I guess this is why SWx is using only MMT which has been perfected in every aspect. It has Assembly, Part and Drawing Template/file structure and file properties which work seamlessly. RBM a file in any place, including Windows file explorer, it knows parent child relationship for file management.

When Cloning (a MMT project), NX fails to identify the parents/drawing files. This is where I think it’s not ready yet to be used in projects subjecting to cloning.

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

The MMT, or 'Master Model Technique', was initially developed as part of Unigraphics V10.0, which was released in 1993, but it wasn't really ready for primetime until the release of V11.0, which was in early 1996, so I guess, to be conservative, it's been around for 19 years. Part of the issue is that we needed to be able to support all of the legacy Drawing files which were transitioned from pre-UG V10.0 so we had to make MMT optional, which it still is today. This is an example of some of that 'heritage' that we have to account for whenever we develop new NX functionality, it has to be compatible with data that could have been first created many years ago. For example, I keep, for demo purposes, an old Unigraphics V9.1 Part file, complete with a J-size Drawing sheet, that was last saved in 1991. I can DIRECTLY open that part file in the latest versions of NX and the model and Drawing are still valid and usable. We'll put that up against anyone else in the industry.

John R. Baker, P.E.
Product 'Evangelist'
Product Engineering Software
Siemens PLM Software Inc.
Digital Factory
Cypress, CA
Siemens PLM:
UG/NX Museum:

To an Engineer, the glass is twice as big as it needs to be.

RE: Smart projection views

MFDO, mind that what I and cowski suggested you are two entirely different approaches.

Speaking about NX and competitive products, NX has one crucial advantage which is, oddly enough, often being overlooked. I mean the PRT file format, which is the single format for both part and assembly. This format, along with WAVE geometry linker, makes NX an immensely powerful and flexible platform for implementation of advanced modeling strategies. Here NX has an edge over any other CAD package.

As for mid-range CAD products, there's no surprise that NX finds itself marginally behind in productivity when tested on lightweight tasks. I used Inventor for few years (and still do from time to time), and I readily admit that its interface is much smoother than that of NX, and its tools are more fluent and intuitive. I think I can achieve better productivity when producting models and drawings of small products using Inventor than using NX. But NX is made for heavyweight tasks, and when it comes to really big things and complex geometry, then NX is really up for the job which mid-range CAD packages simply cannot bear.

www.cadroad.com

RE: Smart projection views

This last post is indeed perfectly summarizing the situation and the fact that companies making huge stuff cannot take the risk of using a mid-range system that may start to lose the plot while assemblies get bigger than expected.

One other thing I personnaly like about UG/NX is that they have managed to maintain its legendary stability over time. In fact, I cannot remember having crashed the software within the last 14 years!

RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
It’s totally out of the topic. I’m wondering if I should continue.bugeyed

Here it goes……..roll1

I agree (always) that NX and CATIA are OEM software. They need lots of surfacing tools to produce organic surfaces to satisfy their customer’s eyes. They build their dreams in space, I mean in virtual space.

Like us, there are thousands of manufactures involved in each project of OEMs. We are only given one defined part to produce.
In our products’ only one face needed surfacing (i.e a die cavity) other 5 faces of the block needed only standard CAD work (= 83%). In a total project that will be more than 95% (Cavity area=5% or less in a tool).

My point is, if we could do 95% work faster, effectively and efficiently, we gain lot of extra time to play with remaining 5% of work.

Talking about the other software, it gives well thought CAD tools to work with the defined part. If you master limited surfacing commands which don’t overstep each other’s functionality, can get the work done. (Check my website). Mostly it’s just the lack of knowledge or the blaming game. Surely they are not as fancy as OEM surfacing tools and don’t offer numerous ways to do the same job.

I’m just asking NX to help those thousands of poor manufactures to be efficient in 95% of their work. Like the subject in question.

(Why it has to finish all my threads in this way…..)banghead

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

Quote (MFDO)

I’m just asking NX to help those thousands of poor manufactures to be efficient in 95% of their work. Like the subject in question.
Look, at least two different approaches to solve your problem have been suggested. It's not that hopeless. smile

Don't be so fixated on high-quality surfaces. There are other areas where NX can beats competition hands down in terms of efficiency and productivity. Just today I had to model in NX the assembly where components were insulated over and then put into box filled with lubricant (sorry, no images because they are proprietary). It took me only about ten design features in each of the prt files (one for insulation, one for lubricant) to fully model the case and get 100% perfect geometry with correct weight. Hats off to PRT and WAVE.

www.cadroad.com

RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
PS, It was in general and for all the above postings.

Still I don't get Cowski's method. (Sorry for giving a star for the wrong post. I'm unable to move it to your posing so I gave you one too.)

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

If you use the master model method, the orientation of the model in the drawing file is independent of the orientation of the model in the geometry file. You can use assembly constraints to orient your model to the desired front view (or top view, right view, take your pick). As you edit your model, the assembly constraints will automatically reorient the component in the drawing file, keeping the desired view(s).

Attached is a super simple example (NX 9). In the drawing file, the component is constrained so that the front view is normal to the trimmed face of the block. In the model file, try changing the angle of the datum plane to see what affect it has on the drawing (you may need to update the drawing views after the model edit).

model
drawing

www.nxjournaling.com

RE: Smart projection views

The method is the following (see the attached archive): since with master model approach the drawing is the parent assembly file and plate - the drawing of which we are going to create - is the component in that assembly, we simply constrain plate against drawing's CSYS is in any other assembly. Any change of orientation of plate solid won't be reflected in the drawing, because assembly contraints will always orient it in a certain way.

www.cadroad.com

RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
Thanks for the support to find workarounds.

It’s unfortunate that NX’s Cloning process don’t recognise MMT drawing’s parent child relationship to accept your workarounds as solutions.

According to John MMT had been introduced long ago, but doesn’t seems to have evolved or matured enough.

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


RE: Smart projection views

MFDO, please take note that using Orient View tool you don't need to use MMT, it can be done in a same file.

www.cadroad.com

RE: Smart projection views

As for the cloning process, feel feee to pick up drawing in the clone tool, and it will be cloned along with the componen part. If you need many drawings to clone, collect them into the auxiliary assembly and pick it in the clone tool - there are companies doing exactly that. NX works.

www.cadroad.com

RE: Smart projection views

<MMT had been introduced long ago, but doesn’t seems to have evolved or matured enough>

Now that Siemens is on the wheel and seen the wide range of their home product - from an electronic single part to a huge turbine system - I am pretty confident the old UG dog is on the way to the real resurrection. Isn't Scott planning for a Blade Runner sequel after all ?! Yes, he is.

RE: Smart projection views

(OP)
PrintScaffold, I don't want to carryover unused or unnecessary drawings and parts to the new project. It would be nice if the system could handle this association.

Attached is a short clip of my NX parametric designing process which I described earlier. I posted this in NX Forum to show my rookie working process (that is how one NX EXPERT described it).

I would like to see if you guys have a better or smarter way to do this.

Michael Fernando (CSWE)
www.solidCADworks.com
Tool and Die Designer
Siemens NX V9.0 + PDW
SWX 2013 SP3.0 X64
PDMWorks 2013
Logopress3
FastForm Advance
FormatWorks


Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources