×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Concrete Tank Installation

Concrete Tank Installation

Concrete Tank Installation

(OP)

We are currently in the construction phase of a wastewater treatment system. We have a tank being installed that has 7 reinforced concrete sections with vertical joints. At two of the joints the contractor is unable to push it home, leaving roughly a 2 inch gap all the way around. The water depth in this tank will be approximately 7 feet. The manufacturer is acknowledging it is most likely due to cold temperatures, but claiming that because the gasket is fully seated it is a non-issue. They are proposing to finish by filling the gap with a hydraulic cement. Is there anything else I should consider and would this be common practice? Thanks.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Please clarify:
Push what home?
The manufacturer of what? The concrete panels?
What does the contract say the contractor has to do?
Is this a design problem or a "field" problem?
What is the role of the "manufacturer" in this contract? Will the manufacturer "sign off and hold harmless" in this situation. Maybe even post a guarantee bond?

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

(OP)
The male end comes with a gasket around it from the manufacturer of the concrete tank sections. The male end has been inserted into the female end to the point where the gasket is no longer visible, but the male end has not been fully pushed into the female end. The manufacturer of the concrete tanks is saying this is a field problem, but that it is a non-issue. The manufacturer provides a 1 year warranty for their tanks, and the contractor is under a 1 year warranty obligation to the owner. If the tank is leaking after one year, it will be difficult to notice and once it is noticed the owner is stuck with the problem.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Show me (assume I am the owner) that a 2 inch gap is coming from low temperatures.

Hint: Multiply concrete thermal expansion coef x delta T (outside temp - daily average temp) x length of each concrete section. It will not be 2 inches, will it.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

As my kids say, this sounds seriously cray cray.
This sounds like some kind of proprietary tank system. I've seen hundreds of tanks, and never heard of anything like this. Assuming it is round, what resists the hoop stresses? Or if it is rectangular, there's big corner stresses. If it needs a lock between sections and they don't meet up, you've got an issue.
Some prestressed tanks are made of precast walls, but those are tensioned and shotcreted after the panels are put up.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

(OP)
Well the two inches isn't coming from expansion, it's being assumed that with the cold temperatures the gasket is less pliant.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Quote (CBard (Civil/Environmental) (OP))


15 Jan 15 17:02
Well the two inches isn't coming from expansion, it's being assumed that with the cold temperatures the gasket is less pliant.

Well in cold weather the concrete sections will shrink (contract) a bit, which makes the problem worse, but! - that contraction is not 2 inches. Think bridge expansion joints - they are not 2 inches in 50 feet, right?

So, what are the dimensions of this rubber gasket? 4 inches wide? 3 inches wide? Will the weather (once the project gets finished) ever get colder than it is right now?

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Looks like the gasket requires mechanical deformation to seal.
How can hydraulic cement engage the seal fingers?

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Scaling from the plan view of the gasket and seal joint, you can - at most! - allow only 1/2 inch (maybe 5/8 inch) gap to engage both the first and the second lips on the gasket against the second concrete surface. Anything more than 1/2 inch gap means only one lip touches the second concrete face on a flat, smooth compression-proof (leak resistant) surface.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Why not use material containing BENTONITE so that it will expand while wet ?

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

This seems to be a proprietary tank design from a concrete tank manufacturer.

You should contact the manufacturer and follow his instructions. Otherwise, you warranty will be void. Contact the engineering designer at the home office.

The manufacturer should have tolerances for this type of error.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

(OP)
This is the manufacturer saying that the gap isn't an issue and that they will still provide the typical warranty.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Since everyone is saying they think the problem is that it's too cold for the gasket, has anyone tried heating the joint? I would at least require them to try having a propane heater or something onsite to blow hot air in the gap to at least attempt to get things to work properly. You would think that the tank manufacturer would have specific installation procedures for cold weather.

Also, if you were to accept the use of the hydraulic cement, I would require them to use it on both sides of the gap, not only one like you showed in your picture. Also, you might have curing problems if it's too cold.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Would filling the gap with hyd cement pack the wet side void and impact the gasket seal?

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

everyone seems to be convinced there is a problem, either it is too cold to install (not very likely) or that the fabrication or installation procedure is incorrect (more likely).
the drawings do not indicate that a 2 inch gap is within tolerance, so why would you accept some on the fly fix? this is a recipe for disaster. reject it outright and require correct fabrication and installation

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

CBard:
Can you lubricate the bell end of the joint to help with the pressing/fitting action of the tendons? Is the outside of the tank frozen to the ground that it contacts? Is the open joint which is not visible filled with soil from the pushing/fitting process, thus preventing proper fit-up? Build a heating tent, 3'-4' on each side of the joint and completely enclosing the tank walls at the joint. Heat this for a few days to heat the concrete and to warm and soften the gasket. That should prove or disprove the manufacturer’s theory about it being to cold. I’ll bet that part of their sales pitch is that their tanks can be installed in any weather conditions. So now, put-up and shut-up Mr. manuf’er. The transfer of any loads, particularly relative lateral loads btwn. the two tank sections, any differential settlement or soil or hydraulic lateral loads, is dependant upon that joint being fully seated. Otherwise, you are trying to transfer these loads across fairly thin cantilever sections which are now much longer that the original design contemplated. Of course, water tightness is important too. If they can’t pull this together with the tendons, then get some hydraulic jacking equipment to help push on the free end of the last section.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

I have specified many water/wastewater tanks with steel tensioning cables. I see one in the first photo. I don’t see the cable in any details. The prevention of corrosion to these cables has always been of high importance. Consider the many parking decks that have failed or have been condemned. How was/is this being done?
Steve

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

i would bet the gasket is pinched at some locations through the joint and won't look like the "Fix" detail you provided. Tarp the structure, warm it up, and push it home.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

The sketch you provided does not show much bearing surface if you have the 2-Inch gap. It would seems that this is not adequate. It seems that it would make sense to take the panel apart and see what is preventing the joint from closing.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

(OP)
Documentation was submitted by the manufacturer to demonstrate their proposal was sufficient. None of the documentation proved to me it would be adequate to fill the gap with hydraulic cement and the tank will be rejected. Thank you for your help.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Thanks for the update. I hope this put your project too far behind on schedule.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

sometime spellcheck isn't enough zelgar smile

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

I would expect some variations in fabrication tolerances. Have any gaskets "rolled"?

You may need to use some hydraulic or screw jacks to spread the pinch points so the gasket joints will push home.

RE: Concrete Tank Installation

Naw, I'm just a sadist. evil

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources