×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
Hello,
I'm an EE in the market for a steel storm sheltered to be anchored to my garage floor. I've read the Hilti datasheets/specs (HUS-EX & Kwick Bolt 3) and basically anything with a diameter => 1/2" and a >2" embedment requires a 5"-6" slab, but the standard house is 4". To meet Fema 320 specs you need to be about 3". From all the research I've done, all the storm shelter manufacturers are violating the Hilti datasheets big time, which puts me on edge. I feel like its just a guessing game now if the anchor will hold since they a either completely going through the slab or not leaving any room below the anchor. One prominent company uses 7" anchors which will rust out since they are in the dirt!

Does anyone have any advice? The shelter certification companies have basically told me they don't care, go away.

Thank you

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
....Fema 320 recommends a 3" embedment (not a 3" slab).

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

Do you need the 1/2" anchor? Hilti has a 3/8" diameter anchor using the HVA capsule that has published values for 3 1/2" embedment.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

Quote (OP)

but the standard house is 4".

Given what I've seen of residential construction, I'd be very surprised if it's not more like 2.5" in some places.

Some place, I thought that there was a limitation on expansion anchors stating that they couldn't be embedded more than 2/3 of the depth of the substrate?

Does anybody on the design side of these shelters even check to see that the anchors engage enough SOG mass tor resist uplift? While a shelter is surely a big improvement over no shelter, there may be some design holes to be legitimately concerned about here.

You've obviously got some options available to you if you're willing to demo parts of your garage slab and pour a little concrete. Hopefully it won't come to that. Maybe you could anchor the shelter to concrete blocks that just sit on top of your slab on grade?

The greatest trick that bond stress ever pulled was convincing the world it didn't exist.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
Thank you. I noticed the 3/8" anchor, but since FEMA 320 requires a 1/2", I dont think any shelter company would use a 3/8" anchor. Part of the problem seems to be that no anchor can meet the criteria. (>=1/2" diameter, ~3" embedment, 4" slab, pull out strength ~1800 lbs, made in the USA)

The company I'm considering now uses a 3/4" x 7" Hilti HUS-EZ with only a zinc coating. It will definitely rust in the dirt, I'm just not sure if it will continue to rust once its length has corroded to only the slab thickness of 4".



RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

Yes it would continue to rust. The rate of corrosion may slow once it reaches the concrete however it will still continue.

I don't suggest going that route (even though you are slightly hand-cuffed) although if you do make it a stainless steel anchor. It will last longer than a strictly galvanized anchor would.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
Thanks guys,

Considering that the concrete depth could vary a lot & I might not have enough concrete below the anchor to meet Hilit's specs, what would be the best choice: Epoxy, wedge, or screw anchors (HIT-Z, Kwick Bolt3, HUS-EZ) As I already stated, I'm concerned the zinc HUS-EX will rust. I can get the Kiwck bolt and Hit-Z in galvanized or stainless I think.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

Galvanized or stainless steel anchors won't help. The slab still needs to be thick enough for the anchor. It may be possible to engineer a concrete pad anchored to the top of the garage slab. But, it may be better to demo the existing concrete for the storm shelter anchors.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
Yikes! The idea of finding a competent person to tear through my slab and post tension cables scares me, it would take a lot of time and resources.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

PT cables? That changes things. Have you verified the slab thickness and presence of cables? You probably should.

The greatest trick that bond stress ever pulled was convincing the world it didn't exist.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
I found this table on steel corrsion rates. When the anchor is in the dirt it would corrode faster. Any thoughts?
At this point, I think I'm more likely ot die trying to solve this than I am to get hit by a tornado!


The (uniform) corrosion rate of steel in different atmospheres:

Atmosphere Corrosion Rate (µm/year)
Rural 4 - 60
Urban 30 - 70
Industrial 40 - 160
Marine 60 - 170
Source: Living Steel

http://www.galvanizeit.org/corrosion/corrosion-pro...


If I assume 70um per year, that would only be 0.05" over 20 years; hard to belive it would be that little

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

I am with KootK, not sure what good a shelter is if it can blow away with the slab attached.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

I agree with KootK, are you sure it's PT? seems odd for a residential application.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
My house was built in 1999, so I've been told everying after '95 or so has them. I see steel poking out of the side of the house every few feet, I assumes that was the post tension calbes?

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

If they are requiring a 7" anchor, dont you think they want to get the capacity of a 7" anchor in at least 7" concrete? Having it hang out of the slab does nothing for your capactiy, other than reduce.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

I'm assuming gumbo clay, it would definitely be post tensioned.

your corrosion rates listed are in atmosphere (air), not in water or soil. you would need to test your soil to determine how corrosive it will be.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

While residential PT is rare in the US as a whole, it's quite common in CA and TX. And I have heard of it in LA, where I assume OP is located? Visible slab edge anchors is a good tell.

If it's PT, it'll be thicker than 4", right? As long as the cables aren't damaged, PT may be a boon.

The greatest trick that bond stress ever pulled was convincing the world it didn't exist.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
I live in Texas, we have major foundation issues here because of the clay soil. One local shelter company told me they won't do INGROUND shelters on newer homes in the garage because they dont want to cut the PT cables. Hmm. Wonder how I can get this slab thickness measured?

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

If the PT is for shrinkage and temperature only- 4" is possible. Developers around me like this type of slab because the slab cracking is limited- so they have fewer callbacks.
If it is a structural slab, then it should be thicker.

If the slab is 4" thick, can you use 1/2" diam. Hilti Kwik Bolt TZ anchors with 2" embedment- and tighten up the spacing? Make sure to identify tendon locations before drilling.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
Yall, made a good point about having it measured/checked. Noted! One website said PT slabs are usually 8" (heck if I know). If that is true than I could use just about any anchor and be in good shape. FEMA requires a 4" minimum slab, so I shouldn't blow away! I just didnt want the anchors to be incorrectly installed on slabs they were not intended for. This is a major hole in shelter design right now.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

geauxLSU -

Apparently, the shed is inside a garage (or is it an open carport?).

Do you have a building code that has adopted the FEMA suggestions? If not, FEMA is only a suggested method since has to be adopted by someone to give it some enforcement power. Unfortunately, some standards are not written in "code enforceable language, so that is why they are not adopted by a legal authority. I see this very often sitting on code committees and working with associations that desire incorporation in a recognized code.

If it is not accepted by your code in some way and not up to local code enforcement, it is up to the shed building system company to supply instructions on how it should be installed. If it blows away and is in your garage, you may also have to determine if it covered when they find it along with Dorothy in Kansas.

The details and specific discussed and great technical items, but difficult to relate to a small shed in a garage. The shed manufactured (if he is not installing it) supply sufficient details of attachment and base since that is the only way to have some guarantee.

Dick

Engineer and international traveler interested in construction techniques, problems and proper design.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

I think you need to go the epoxy anchor route for sure as expansions anchors cannot go that deep into a slab without risking spalling out the bottom.
Does not seem to bother car lift manufacturers as they install these all the time in 4" slabs with expansion anchors.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

(OP)
Dick,

Builders/Installers are required by the NSSA and ATSA (storm shleter assiciations) to follow FEMA guidelines and pass a debris impact test at Texas Tech. Interestingly when you look at these documents, there aren't any rules for strictly steel shleters. FEMA 320 specs wooden and concrete shelter. So its a bit of a joke that they advertise meeting FEMA specs. I'm less concerned with the structural strength becasue I've seen so many impact test, including cars driving into them at 50mph.

But, anchoring is still a concern. They may be not be anchored correctly becasue the anchors are design for 6" slabs and most are knowingly using anchors that will rust when exposed to the dirt/moisture underneath.

Everyone tells me I just thave to trust the installers, but if they are violating the specs and using anchors that rust, its hard to get comforatbale with that.

Do yall think anchor threads embeded in concrete could rust if the bottom of the concrete has a hole? I know the anchor will rust, but it seems the rate is slow so the length of the bolt is not a concern, just the threads embedded need to not rust.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

Anchoring doesn't help you if your slab isn't strong enough to actually engage the amount of weight you need to keep your shelter from blowing away. So, while you have to solve that problem it may not be the only one.

You can install whatever anchorage you want, but if the concrete around it rips apart it's not going to help you. If what's being tied to doesn't meet the requirements of the vendor's typical installation, a structural enginer needs to design anchorage and possibly foundation/slab modifications for your specific situation. This may or may not be the vendor's problem, depending on what the agreement you have with them says.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

GeauxLSU:
Read the fine print on the shelter’s manufacturer literature. It likely says they have tested the shelter and it meets FEMA Stds. when it is properly anchored down. And, they may actually have done some testing to back this up, under a standardized protocol. Then they leave that foundation (tie down) design problem to a third party, and if anything goes wrong they will argue that it was not tied down properly by you or your installer. They’ve sold their shelter units, made their money, paid their insurance premiums and will take their chances. When they are mass producing and commoditizing something like this, there are just too many variables in the way of existing soil, foundation, terrain conditions, etc., for them to design the foundation for the shelter. They would be sticking their neck out even further doing that, than the way they are doing it now. We can’t really help much either, for the same reasons, we don’t know enough about the prevailing conditions, and it seems you’re not so sure either. I think you should find a local Structural Engineer to help you with this problem, someone who knows the local soils conditions and can inspect your bldg.

RE: Storm Shelter Concrete Anchors

Much/most of the impact testing that is used is done at Texas Tech the standards for projectile penetration (the largest cause of deaths from tornadoes) are for penetration of a wall assembly in the lab. The vast majority of the accepted walls were reinforced block or reinforced concrete until a wall assembly. After many years a wall assembly using 2x6's (12"oc.) sandwiched with a sheet metal plate and 3/4"" plywood was accepted for FEMA projectile approval. That research is the basis for most FEMA suggestions that are incorporated into a legally enforceable standard. I do know know whether FEMA has done full structure testing for entire structures. They do however, have plans for tornado resistant structures that are reinforced concrete block or reinforced concrete including the roof assembly and the connection to the concrete slab including slab thickness requirements. These are used where structures must have a tornado resistant structure (free-standing, inside a single story home or in a basement. - It is good information. The guys in the labs seemed to have a good time shooting the 2x4s out of an air cannon.

If the steel building company is to be responsible for the hold down of a structure they must build according to whatever standard they claim it will work for. Somehow, the small building suppliers and their sellers do not seem to have a good "handle" the wholes structure below the base, but they are responsible for their suggestions. Your trust in them is based on them being lucky or using a standard that include some sort of code language or if the are self insured.

The bolts should not go through the concrete and into the soil because the corrosion is more severe. that is why there are concrete coverage requirements in codes to prevent corrosion and protection.

Personally, the the only problem is not the shed flying away. There could be some damage on the ground if the shed breaks away somehow if the garage does disappear. Professionally, I would accept better information of just design the connection to the concrete myself since it would be my money.

Dick

Engineer and international traveler interested in construction techniques, problems and proper design.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources