×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

(OP)
Hi all,

I have a steel bridge with 50 m span composed witn 4 beam (2400 m height) bracing together.

The problem is because the weight of the beam is not posible to lift two beam together (with bracing), so we have to lift and install the beams one by one.

If we lift and instal one beam this will failt for Lateral Torsional Buckling.

So we need some bracing only for the installation.

There is any "typical" bracing for this situation? there any book or reference about this?

Hope you can help

Best regards..

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

You might have to put a strong back on the beam if you can't get a larger crane to lift both together.

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

2400 m height?

BA

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Bride?

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

What is the reach of your crane, can it lift at the end of the girder, pixcking up haqlf the weight, and reach across to the embankment?

Can you get a second crane and transfer the one end load halfway across?

Can you add a horizontal truss to the top of the girder to provide the buckling capacity?

Michael.
"Science adjusts its views based on what's observed. Faith is the denial of observation so that belief can be preserved." ~ Tim Minchin

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Can you put a truss-type arrangement using lightweight angles and cable on one or both flanges to increase lateral stability? See attached figure.
If you can support a long slender flexible beam at the top flange (points "A" in the attached figure), it's more stable than if supported on the bottom flange- not sure if any design methods take this into account- but possibly arrange to support it at the top temporarily until otherwise stabilized.
These are ideas, not things I've tried, so you're on your own for details and analysis.

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Other options would include:

- King posting the first girder
- Launching the girders in pairs instead of crane erecting them
- Use of a second crane (either to erect in pairs or one as a "holding crane" - never used the second myself but have heard/read of it being done)
- Temporary shoring of the girders between the bearings

Without knowing site constraints it is tough to say which solution may be most practical

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Just wanted to add to my post above. Launching is probably only worth looking at if the crane you have has the capacity to make it a crane assisted launch and "catch" the girders before they reach the tipping point. If you need to get into fabricating a launch nose and/or counterweighting the girders, it's probably not the best option.

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

(OP)
Thanks for the answer...

BAretired

2400 mm

paddingtongreen

What is the reach of your crane, can it lift at the end of the girder, pixcking up haqlf the weight, and reach across to the embankment?
Can you get a second crane and transfer the one end load halfway across?


We are gonna use two cranes at the same time, nothing else is possible because the cranes available.

JStephen

this is exactly what we need to do. Any document for this calculations?

gwynn

we cant do any of this because the cranes available.

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

I am surprised the unloaded beams would not be stable against their own weight during a crane lift. How were they lifted and assembled? How where they transported?

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Not a trifling question. There are many interesting articles on the internet regarding this subject. The attached link is the U.S. Department of Transportation Highway Administration Handbook on Bracing Design:

http://www.google.ca/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...

I would try to get bigger cranes and tie two girders together on the ground before lifting them into place. Bracing a single girder is not an easy prospect.

BA

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

racookpe1978- the original post doesn't necessarily say they'll fail during the lift- but if "we lift and install". I assume additional pick points along the beam could prevent it failing during the lift, but not when it is set in place.

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

(OP)
Yes,

When is in place will fail.

I was thinking use a horizontal truss to brace the top flange, but i am not sure about how calculate this truss...

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Ingdaniel:
In its crudest form, see if you can find a couple 50' long used steel joists. Lay them horiz. on top of the top flg. of your girder, and weld their web diags. to the top flg. This is all to be scarfed off and cleaned up after you get some bracing to another girder in place. This is much like Jstephen’s sketch. The stiffness of the steel joists (their moment of inertia) is related to their ability to restrain the top flg. buckling or torsional buckling of the girder.

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

dh,

50' won't quite do it. The span is 50 m.

BA

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

BA:
I was actually assuming that two or three steel joists would be spliced/cobbled together end to end to approach the length of the girder. I suspected that 164' long bar joists would be kinda tough to find. I also assume that they can do some serious bracing (kickers, etc.) at the two bearing points. With the almost total lack of meaningful info. provided by the OP’ers. on many of these questions there are probably a bunch of possibilities if we only had a better picture of the problem. More and more of the OP’s, these days, have just been a big guessing game for lack of important basic problem delineation info. If they staged the first two girders for quick consecutive picks, maybe a couple lighter cranes at the third points of the first girder could act to hold the first girder during the second lift. Could some of the cross bracing (a few of the braces) be installed on first girder prior to its lift, so they would immediately be in place when the second girder was lifted?

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

dheng
One possible problem with the truss solution is that most/many jurisdictions will not let you weld to a bridge girder. I hope the OP has looked into this for acceptance before going too far down that path.

I suggested the use of a holding crane above, and was told no.

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

(OP)
We wont weld, will use bolt.

The problem I have now is how estimate the load for design the truss.

Any idea for this load?

Regards

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

It is not a simple problem. Wind forces would need to be considered. Wind deflection would be magnified by compression in the top flange due to gravity load. Unless the bottom flange is braced, wind forces will act eccentric to the bracing causing torsional loading and possible aerodynamic instability.

If a horizontal truss is used, the compression chord must be braced periodically to prevent buckling. If chords consist of cable, they can't take compression, so in effect, only the leeward truss would be effective with the girder acting as the compression chord.

BA

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Your best solution might be to get a bigger crane. If you are over by just the weight of the bracing, maybe there is a way to tack the two together and lift them as a pair. Then after the others are placed, cut the first one loose, lift it, and install the bracing.

RE: Erection Bracing for Steel Beam for Bride

Bigger cranes or more cranes. Four cranes might be needed for the initial placement of two bridge girders braced together as a unit.

BA

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources