PhD in Structural Engineering
PhD in Structural Engineering
(OP)
Hi All,
I am a recent MS (non-thesis) graduate in civil/structural engineering. My masters classes were very structurally specialized and that is where my interests lie. I am currently working as an EIT at a smaller firm, but will likely have to move in 4 yrs when my spouse completes her education. I think there is a good chance that I would like to pursue a PhD in structural engineering at a fairly prestigious university (no specific one chosen) after that move, but I am concerned about limiting my job opportunities. My primary motivation for undertaking the degree is interest in the subject material. I found myself very interested in structural mechanics and the math, theory, and computer procedures behind different kinds of structural analysis, and would like to learn more in the area. My professors all mostly thought it would be a great idea for me to get my PhD, but I'm not sure that academia is my end goal. At the bridge engineering firm for which I interned throughout school, there were two PhD's high up in the structural staff, but I know that is not necessarily typical. I would like to retain the flexibility of working mostly anywhere that is a fairly large city in the US, as my location options will most likely be limited to where my spouse can work as well. The money lost in the years of study is unappealing to me, but obviously not a deal-breaker. As far a jobs I would be interested in after graduating go, bridge engineering, building engineering, and more computer-based jobs such as working for a software company are all possibilities. With these goals and concerns, do you guys think the PhD is a good idea, or will it be too difficult to find a good-paying job in the US region of my choosing? Also note that I expect to have a PE and probably not an SE license at the time in question.
-labeattie
I am a recent MS (non-thesis) graduate in civil/structural engineering. My masters classes were very structurally specialized and that is where my interests lie. I am currently working as an EIT at a smaller firm, but will likely have to move in 4 yrs when my spouse completes her education. I think there is a good chance that I would like to pursue a PhD in structural engineering at a fairly prestigious university (no specific one chosen) after that move, but I am concerned about limiting my job opportunities. My primary motivation for undertaking the degree is interest in the subject material. I found myself very interested in structural mechanics and the math, theory, and computer procedures behind different kinds of structural analysis, and would like to learn more in the area. My professors all mostly thought it would be a great idea for me to get my PhD, but I'm not sure that academia is my end goal. At the bridge engineering firm for which I interned throughout school, there were two PhD's high up in the structural staff, but I know that is not necessarily typical. I would like to retain the flexibility of working mostly anywhere that is a fairly large city in the US, as my location options will most likely be limited to where my spouse can work as well. The money lost in the years of study is unappealing to me, but obviously not a deal-breaker. As far a jobs I would be interested in after graduating go, bridge engineering, building engineering, and more computer-based jobs such as working for a software company are all possibilities. With these goals and concerns, do you guys think the PhD is a good idea, or will it be too difficult to find a good-paying job in the US region of my choosing? Also note that I expect to have a PE and probably not an SE license at the time in question.
-labeattie





RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
Good luck!
Please remember: we're not all guys!
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
Thanks for your response. I'm not really sure how I would continue to study what I am interested in without going to school. Textbooks or other technical literature alone lacks any interaction, direction, or collaboration offered by a school course. And there is no opportunity to apply the material, whereas in the graduate degree I would hopefully apply newly learned material to my research. If you are suggesting it would be good to take courses without a degree as an end goal, I think that is a possibility for me, but it just seems like I would want to go ahead and get a degree if I'm putting the coursework effort in already.
Thanks again! I appreciate the input.
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
This statement from you makes me wonder if you have that in you.
"The money lost in the years of study is unappealing to me"
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
On the quiet - pursue your PhD to add to your learning and fill your personal need/passion.
Keep your PhD quiet.
Enjoy a great career in engineering and only use your PhD credentials if you need to - which probably you won't need to.
Check out Eng-Tips Forum's Policies here:
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
JAE: Thank you for the input, and your suggestion is real possibility for me. I'm just surprised and a bit discouraged to see so many engineers who believe that a PhD will not increase earning potential. The cons make sense, but my old professors seemed to think the PhD would be a bigger asset in industry than this community appears to. I probably do have enough passion for the subject to pursue my studies without a future financial reward, but I had certainly hoped I wouldn't have to. I still have a few years to make a decision, but I really appreciate this input early on.
-labeattie
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
This is an interesting approach, if you can read across from usability to engineering (I'm not sure you can) http://www.measuringusability.com/usability-phd.ph...
The curve at the bottom makes the point.
Cheers
Greg Locock
New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm?
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
eg table 11
http://www.graduatecareers.com.au/wp-content/uploa...
$86k for a masters, $71k for a fud. Ouchy.
Cheers
Greg Locock
New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm?
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
I would be hesitant to hire a PhD for consulting engineering due to their generally high specialization.
Also - the PhD in engineering per se doesn't add to the ability to be a good marketing/rainmaker for a firm - or a business manager for that matter.
In fact - a former partner who was a PhD actually brought in work that was always so esoteric that no money was ever made.
Check out Eng-Tips Forum's Policies here:
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
A PhD helps "justify" your visa application to go work overseas in a foreign, but it cannot be the only thing listed.
Your "attitude" in your answers seems to be the key - You "want" the readers here to justify a decision that you (in your mind ?) may have already wanted to make. And, the collective experience of the practicing engineers here - few us academic! - will probably not give you the answer you want.
Sorry about that.
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
However then you say:
This second quote makes it sound like you aren't much of a self starter/self motivated or whatever term you prefer, which I'd think would be a required prerequisite for a typical research PhD.
If you want to learn for learning's sake/for your own interest & edification then maybe you should re consider learning on your own time, picking and choosing courses/subjects of particular interest, MOOC's, participation here on Eng-Tips for your interaction etc.
I'm not a structural guy, nor smart enough to seriously consider getting a PhD of my own so take with a pinch of salt. However, I do work in a company/industry where there are a lot of PhD's (maybe more than Bachelors or Masters in hardware development Engineering) and while some of them are very smart I'm not sure they're generally smarter/more useful than a lot of the Bachelors & Masters. Plus every time I see one our our new PhD's working on a sheet metal box or similar I can't help but wonder if they're a little over qualified - up until a couple of years ago we had designers & interns doing most of that work!
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
First of all, there seems to be a relentless push to make the masters degree an entry point for Structural Engineers. There's talk of making it a requirement for licensure. So if that's the case, a PhD might be a useful differentiator.
But right now, in 2014, I think you'll be severely limiting your options. The company I work for, for instance, does a lot of challenging designs. But our perception is that a PhD would feel unfulfilled doing concrete boxes over and over again. It might either affect their attitude or make them make complicate routine tasks.
There are plenty of jobs out there for PhD's, but there likely in bigger companies and in bigger cities.
As far as your professors advice, don't forget they have a symbiotic relationship with doctoral candidates. The professors provide advanced degrees and you provide cheap labor for their research.
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
So it seems to me that if I really want to get a PhD, that I should go for it. My limited experience with PhDs was most similar to hokie66's. But from what most of you think, I should expect to make about the same amount of money as I did before starting the degree, and should expect to work at a very large firm, or alternatively go into academia. I wanted to hear a more general industry view on the doctorate and I definitely think that is what I'm getting from you all, so thank you.
GregLocock: Thanks for the article, I thought that was a very good read. I know I probably contradicted this at some point, but I guess I knew that a PhD is usually not a good RoI. I just didn't want to get the degree and then come out make less money than I was before I started, or worse, not be able to find a job.
oldestguy: Thank you for the clarification. I understand what you were getting at now. I know a lot of us new engineers tend to forget about the business side of the business or neglect interpersonal skills. I will plan on working at those skills and keep "getting the work" in mind.
KENAT: I didn't think much about companies being afraid PhD's would feel unfilled doing normal design work, so I think that is an interesting perspective. Thanks. Also, I will be following my studies on my own regardless, but I'm sure I can't do that with the speed or comprehension that I would in school. My personal opinion is that there's a lot to be said for having an instructor and peers to learn from. I got a lot more out of undergrad and my MS than I would've reading the textbooks on my own. But learning on your own is much cheaper than undertaking a graduate program. I'll have to keep these points in consideration.
Thanks!
-labeattie
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
http://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=156572
Maui
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
That quote could only have come from someone who has an MBA (i.e. a Massive Brain Aneurysm).
Maui
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
Maui
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
RE: PhD in Structural Engineering
Cheers
Greg Locock
New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm?