×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

460V equipment, 208V supply
8

460V equipment, 208V supply

460V equipment, 208V supply

(OP)
Our machinery normally uses 460V, 3-phase supply. We have come across an instance where customer only has 208V, 3-phase, and not a hope of changing. I am in the process of converting the equipment. Someone suggested wiring the 460V motors in the delta configuration. Any advice?

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

Quote (QGeek)

Someone suggested wiring the 460V motors in the delta configuration. Any advice?
Spurious advice, pay no heed to it. Likely came from someone who has no idea what they are talking about.

Either use 208V components in your machine, as it appears you are doing, or provide your customer with a transformer large enough to run your standard machine. If your equipment list is complicated and/or specialized, you may find that to be less expensive in the long run by the way.

"Will work for (the memory of) salami"

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

(OP)
That is a great suggestion, thank-you! Any hangups I should look for in a step-up transformer? Interference issues stepping up from the 208V supply and then (for part of the equipment) stepping down to 120V inside the equipment, etc.?

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

I wouldn't expect any complications in using a step-up transformer.

Keep voltage regulation in mind. A transformer might drop 5-6% voltage from no-load to full load. This will be in addition to the voltage drop to the service entrance, which could be up to 5%. This could be an issue if you use a marginally sized transformer and feeder cables.

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

One potential "gotcha" now is that if your state has adopted the 2014 NEC, 450.11 (B) now says that you required to use a transformer that is specifically identified as being suitable for "reverse wiring" by the transformer manufacturer. No further description of how that would be any different, only a requirement that it actually be labeled for use like this. This is brand new, and many states (such as here in california) are always a few years behind on adoption of the current NEC, so YMMV.

.

"Will work for (the memory of) salami"

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

(OP)
Ah! Thanks. The transformer I spec'd does say that it is suitable for "reverse wiring," which brings up a question I have had. What is it about transformers that would make them suitable for only one way? Would one need to look for a step-up vs a step-down transformer?

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

I don't know the justification for that code change, but I've seen multiple occasions where someone with a 208V service and needing to hook up something at 480V went and got the most readily available transformer with those two voltages and hooked it up. That then created a grounded wye/delta connection that was likely in violation of the NEC, was certainly in violation of the utility service requirements, and resulted in damage to the customer's facility. I hope those transformers never get a "reverse wiring" label.

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

Jeff,

I'll have to look that one up - hadn't run into that change. I'm curious as to the original reason for the change - but not quite curious enough to look through all of the commentary.

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

Possibly due to turns ratio: in step down mode the ratio will be chosen so that the LV bus runs slightly higher than nominal at no-load to allow for drop under load. In reverse that ratio would make the HV bus voltage low under no-load conditions and even lower when under load.

Just a thought. smile

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

Sometimes, 460V motors are dual voltage 9-lead motors so you can wire them to be 230V or 460V rated. But, that still gives you a 230V motor running on a 208V supply so you're running the motor on a nominal 10% low voltage. You might get away with it if the motor doesn't run at full load but not if the motor is fully loaded.

I agree with David, you typically want to use a delta:wye connected transformer so you ground the neutral of the wye connections since code requires a 480V service to be grounded. This is rather hard to do if you connect the transformer backwards. I also understand that transformers typically have the primary winding wound first or closer around the core. Apparently, it reduces the inrush transients and losses.

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

With the motor reconnected for 230 Volts, an auto-transformer boost will be a good option.
I prefer the two transformer 'Open delta auto-transformer boost' circuit.
Another option is the three transformer 'Wye auto-transformer boost' circuit.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

I don't know how easy it is to get an autotransformer in your part of the World. I usually have to order one specially wound. That takes some time and is rather costly. So, I use single phase transformers fed from the ingoming voltage and then connect the secondaries in series with incoming grid. In boost direction (or buck, if needed. The rated power is no more than one third of total power times the deltaV/V fraction. If the load is, say, 30 kVA and you need to up the voltage around 10 percent, then each transformer needs to be around 1 kVA. That is three rather small standard transformers (24 V secondary is common) instead of one special unit.

If you are lucky, you can get a center tap on the secondary, then you have a coarse voltage adjustment possibility.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
Half full - Half empty? I don't mind. It's what in it that counts.

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

Yes, Gunnar, those are very commonly available here too. Stand alone they are sold as "signal" or "bell" transformers, because of the 24V secondary. But the exact same transformer is then also sold as a "buck-boost" transformer, with a wiring diagram that instructs you on how to connect them as autotransformers in exactly the way you describe.

All of this would be predicated on the motors being reconfigurable as 240V of course.

"Will work for (the memory of) salami"

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

Two buck/boost rated transformers rated 240:24 Volts in open delta auto-transformer boost will develop 228.8 Volts. Close enough.
Three buck/boost rated transformers rated 120:12 Volts in auto-transformer wye boost will give 132V x 1.73 = 228.6 Volts. Close enough.
Two buck/boost rated transformers rated 240:32 Volts in open delta auto-transformer boost will develop 235.7 Volts. Better.
Three buck/boost rated transformers rated 120:16 Volts in auto-transformer wye boost will give 136V x 1.73 = 235.6 Volts. Better.
Going up to 240:48 Volts develops 250 Volts. A little too high.
With four useable options the next step is to check availability of voltages and KVA ratings and select the best available compromise.
I should have made it clear in my previous post that I was referring to buck-boost rated transformers as described by Jeff, not dedicated auto-transformers. Sorry.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

A much more complex, much more detailed problem with subtle complexities than I anticipated after reading the original question!

Given those complexities of backfeeding through a "step-down" power transformer, how are the telephone-pole household power transformers handling today's new requirements from the governments to allow backfeeding the household transformer from a house's solar cells? Are those transformers at risk of early failure because of this unexpected backfeeding (step-up) of voltage and power back to the power lines?

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

THAT is 'nother whole story. Not applicable here. The boost transformers don't see any voltage on their secondaries unless there is a solar, wind, hydro, fuel cell car or other power source connected locally. And then, you will not have any voltage induced unless there is a reverse power flow in the secondaries of the transformers.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
Half full - Half empty? I don't mind. It's what in it that counts.

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

The authorities may legislate the use of transformers but they can't change the basic transformer theory. As for distribution transformers, the NEC comes into force at the customers service connection.
Existing installations that have been working for years will continue to work despite the lack of a regulatory label.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

"What is it about transformers that would make them suitable for only one way?"

Been too long to remember much detail and I believe it was ACME Electric's application literature, saying that magnetic core calculations can be somewhat different when using the secondary versus the primary winding for power input. Seems like I recall when using the secondary as the power input, there may not be as much head room with regard to core saturation.

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

(OP)
I feel truly enriched, can't thank you all enough. Plenty to go on (solve the problem), and plenty to look further into. Thanks again.

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

Jeff,
The rule in 450.11(B) does not actually require that the transformer label show that it is suitable for reverse operation. The manufacturer just has to say that it is somewhere in their instructions.
For example ACME says the following on their website:
"Acme dry-type distribution transformers can be reverse connected without a loss of KVA rating, but there are certain limitations."
It would be my opinion that information is a manufacturer's instruction and would permit the reverse operation of thier transformers as long at you complied with the limitations that they specify on their website.

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

Ok, thanks Don, good to know. I don't have a copy of the 2014 NEC yet, I live in California so we will not likely adopt it until 2018 or 2019... I got that information from an internal company review of significant changes coming up that may affect the equipment we build.

racookpe1978,
As I understand it, the utilities do not have to let just anyone willy-nilly connect a grid-tie solar system to their pole pigs anyway. You must apply for, and be granted, a "Net Metering" contract/license/permit (not sure of the vehicle), in which you must show compliance with all the regulatory issues involved in putting power back on the grid. In that process, the utilities must be also evaluating their equipment themselves, because I know of a couple of people who were denied Net Metering because the utility claimed their equipment was incompatible with reverse-feed and would be too expensive for them to replace. Might have just been a straw-man, wouldn't put it past them to do that, but it also might be real.

"Will work for (the memory of) salami"

RE: 460V equipment, 208V supply

racookpe1978
Since the inverter has to have a hot line to start production, inrush from the low side doesn't happen.

In the past, the amount residential solar was very small compared to the capacity of the distribution circuit, so the simple solution was to just have the inverter trip and stay offline during any power system disturbance, thus avoiding the issue of providing a ground path for the high side of the service transformer. As the amount of solar on a feeder increases above 15%, everything gets more complicated.

Voltage regulation at the customer's premises can be an issue. If the utility feeder is at 105% voltage on the medium voltage side and an inverter is backfeeding through the service wire and service transformer, the customer's equipment could be damaged by voltage well above 105% on the 120/240V side.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources