×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

(OP)
I am designing an earthing grid in a soil with very poor resistivity (~3000 ohm.m), (calculation returns a resistance of 12 ohm) the resistance required shall be <0.5 ohm which seems impossible, I think we will need to use Bentonite but don't know how to calculate the required quantity to achieve such reduction?

any ideas?

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

Hello,

You can add something to the soild, however, you should have in mind the following:

1) Despite adding something to the soil, this will be temporal. I mean, in some time the effect of the added material will have passed and the earth resistance will be againg very high.

2) I understand your soil resistance is extremely high, however, is that the value independently of the deepth?
What I would think is about teh possibility to go deeper in order to find a lower resistance lawyer that allows you a better value.

3) The other point could be:
What are the touch voltages calculated using the 12 Ohms?
Do they keep you on the safe side or not?

I think that the target value (0.5 Ohms) is because of the sensitive equipment, so what I recommend you is to look to extend the grounding grid using as much area as possible because in that way the whole resistance value tends to be reduce.
Also take a look at Ufer Grounding systems, the explanation could be usefull to you

Regards

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

The Bentonite vendor should be able to give the exact quantity of material to be used to achieve a certain desired resistivity.

However, to improve the earth resistance, the better method is to go for the deep-well electrodes. This is a permanent solution. We have been using this in the deserts, where the soil resistivity was 3400Ω-m.

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

(OP)
well, the bad news is that it is about 12 m of compacted industrial (platics) rubbish, deeper than that will be a bedrock that may be slightly better. The SS buildings will be constructed on piles resting on the bedrock, I thought about using the piles but can't risk the corrosion of heavily loaded concrete for earthing.

Since the station is connected by UG cables with sheaths connected to ground at remote ends, I am sure that the ground return fault current won't exceed few hundred Amperes and the total resistance will be very small (about 10 remote ends, all connected in parallel), would this be acceptable? what about sensitive equipment?

the touch voltage with 12 ohm went crazy exceeding 450 kV!!

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

Touch voltage can't ever be higher than the line-line voltage regardless of what fault you manage to contrive. It also has to obey Ohms Law. That should bring things down to a more realistic level.

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

One question:

Is your facility based on NEC code?
If it is, then, what short-circuit current are you taking into account for your calculations?
The one in low voltage or the one in medium?

This could be easier if you have a very clear picture of your grounding system and real needs

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

Quote (the touch voltage with 12 ohm went crazy exceeding 450 kV!!)


We should know what is the system voltage you are talking about and what is the maximum earth fault current. Also please note that if it is an earth mesh, the value looks to be ridicules.

My experience is that for the switchyards or substation having earth mesh, the touch potential and step potentials are not a big issue. By increasing the quantity of grid earthing conductor you can bring it down to the acceptable value. The main problem is with the "Ground Potential Rise GPR)"

SO in my opinion you have to change the way you look at the problem.

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

CODE

well, the bad news is that it is about 12 m of compacted industrial (platics) rubbish, deeper than that will be a bedrock that may be slightly better. The SS buildings will be constructed on piles resting on the bedrock, I thought about using the piles but can't risk the corrosion of heavily loaded concrete for earthing.] 

Please note that the deep well earthing station need not be in the same substation. It can be made in a relatively friendly terrain. Then you should connect the deep well earth station to the new substation ground grid with adequately sized earthig conductor. Sorry, that I am not using the precise terminologies from NEC, as I am now not using the NEC!!!

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

Some utilities up north use at a minimum 20 ft grounding rods to get below the frost depth to get a good ground.

With respect to corrosion, concrete is sometimes used to encase a grounding rod to prevent deterioration of your ground due to corrosion. Maybe, you can use the piles for grounding if you choose the right concrete.

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

If you can't improve easily the ground resistor you can try:
increase the value of the touch voltage by add surface material like washed granite similar to pea gravel,
to take in account the split factor in order to reduce the value of the current in the ground resistor who will allow you to decrease GPR.

RE: How to add bentonite into IEEE 80

Concerning the Bentonite I have heard that in time we are not sure we keep the improvment.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources