×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Welding steel cable?

Welding steel cable?

Welding steel cable?

(OP)
I have to go look at a job tomorrow where a client just had a horizontal cable rail installed on his deck. He stepped on one of the cables (I have no idea why) and it broke. He doesn't have confidence in the system anymore and he us bringing me in to look at it. He is saying that the ends of the cable are welded to a nut at each end and I'm wondering if welding steel cable like this is even possible w/o causing a problem? I know they make special adjustable ends for these systems, why one was not used i do not know.

FYI, I did not design the original system and I am being brought in after the face.

RE: Welding steel cable?

Wire rope is not intended to be melted or welded.

Old school termination involves threading the rope end through a steel cone, spreading the wires, and pouring molten zinc into the conical cavity.

New school termination, industrial style, involves folding the rope over a thimble and securing the bitter end to the standing part with, typically, two wire rope clips. The thimble is then secured to a shackle or other end fitting.
The assembly is always ugly.

New school termination, sailboat style, involves swaging or threading some sort of end fitting over the bitter end. The wires may or may not be spread during assembly. You will probably want to visit a sailboat rigging shop to see what is possible for a residential installation.

You might consider including some very stiff compression springs in your cable assemblies, to allow enough deflection to limit the force applied by the next adult who steps on the rope.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Welding steel cable?

Either that, or allow the stupid adult to kill himself. Problem, the adult, solved.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Welding steel cable?

MikeH is correct. Wire rope is connected mechanically, not by welding.

RE: Welding steel cable?

Looks like fixing it will not look so good. Chances are the wires are rusted inside and really not worth using any more. Why not look to plastic coated or galvanized chain, say with links about 3/16" size. Are there any local codes that should be followed?

RE: Welding steel cable?

If I stepped on it and it broke, I would not have any confidence in it either.
I'd call that a reality check, and the wire failed under a small load.

RE: Welding steel cable?

(OP)
I did not design this job. I was just asked to look at the system after it was installed. Everything I can find says that there should be mechanical connectors. I am going to find out in about 2 hours what the installer did.

I understand the customers concerns, however, these systems are not meant to be stepped on. The Building Code requires infill parts of railings to support 50# over a 1 square foot area (not 50psf) with the infill not spaced greater than 4" o.c. My interpretation of this is that the wire can not spread more than 4" apart under a 5# load on a 4" dia sphere. If we were to put springs on the end to allow for flex of the cable we wold be in violation of the building code.

RE: Welding steel cable?

SteelPE:
Some building depts. do not allow these types of railing systems, although they do look sexy. The thinking being... instead of providing a safe, properly spaced (balusters), adequately strong railing system; they actually provide the rungs of a ladder for children to climb on, and over the top. You’ll find that when a 200# man stands on one of these cables, he is imparted a far greater (than his weight) tension in the cable, and getting large cable deflections too. When all the cables are properly tensioned, it is almost impossible to design the end posts to take the tension from all of the cables. Then you should also include the code req’rd. loadings on the posts, plus the potential loading your guy applied by stepping on the cable. I believe that most serious installers of these types of cable railing systems, do have swagging equipment as part of their tool kit. They cut the cable to length, thread it through the posts, and apply the last piece of tensioning hardware by swagging it onto the cable.

RE: Welding steel cable?

I'm talking about die springs, not screen door springs. ... so it would take a lot more than 5# of force to push a ball through.

But, given your customer's experience, it's probably better to just install some seriously fat cables.


Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Welding steel cable?

To MikeHolloran's reply "Old school termination involves threading the rope end through a steel cone, spreading the wires, and pouring molten zinc into the conical cavity.", this is not an old school termination since it is used on winding drum and traction type elevators. The thing to keep in mind is when you heat the Babbitt to a molten state so that it can be poured in the socket, you must also heat up the socket otherwise the molten babbitt will chill. Efficiency of such termination is 100%.

RE: Welding steel cable?

(OP)
dhengr,

I am being brought in to look at the existing conditions, whether or not the system is allowed is up to the architect.

The existing system used 1/4" dia bolts that were welded to the cable. The bolts were threaded through the steel angle with a cap nut applied to the finish end. Not much room for adjustment. Plus the cable/weld was ground smooth to fit through the hole in the steel angle. It took minimal effort to pass a softball through the cables. In fact you would easily pull two cables together with on hand. No effort had been made to pretension the cable properly. By my calculations, you would need a pretension force of 300#/cable in order for the system to work properly. Then there is the matter of the support posts which probably do not work.

Now I need to write a report with my findings.

RE: Welding steel cable?

Chicoppe's notation as to modern day usage of molten zinc etc is definitely true.. When I enter a cage at the top of a 4 or 6000 foot deep shaft , you better believe I have 100% confidence in the methods the rope is attached to the shaft conveyance. I believe epoxy resins are now replacing the use of zinc, and Crosby clamps still have their place.

RE: Welding steel cable?

SteelPE:
It sounds/looks like you have some sort of a home made system which is supposed to look something like the several, more well developed and tested, cable systems which are on the market. If you used a regular nut first, on the bolt, and then cut the bolt a little long, once the tensioning was achieved, you could still put the cap nut on as a finish and locking device. Of course, you can melt a bolt and some cable together with a welding rod, there is just no way to assure the quality of that bonding (weld?). I have seen the ends of cables welded, or fused together by flame cutting, but this was primarily to prevent them from un-raveling. I would never trust these welds structurally. Neither material is particularly amenable to welding, and you have no way of knowing if you have properly fused each cable wire or just made a stress raiser on it with the welding process.

RE: Welding steel cable?

That is completely unacceptable for any load carrying use whatsoever. That sort of termination, even if done well, probably has a UTS of about 3 of the strands (think about it). That level of workmanship probably isn't even that good.

This is one acceptable solution, http://www.bosunsupplies.com/Machine-Swage-Fitting... but you do need to get your wire lengths right. That is most easily done on site, you'd need someone who can operate one of these correctly http://www.steelwirerope.com/WireRopeEquipment/Ove...

which will not be cheap.

An alternative would be a thimble and then either a crimped swage or a couple of U bolts, aesthetically not a patch on the long ferrules.

Cheers

Greg Locock


New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm?

RE: Welding steel cable?

I would guess that a significant part of the strength of the cable wires come from it being cold-drawn or something similar, where just heating it up to near melting and cooling back off probably vastly reduces the strength, regardless of how the details are worked.

RE: Welding steel cable?

(OP)
I sent the final report to the owner of the property saying that the existing system is not in compliance with the building code or accepted engineering practices. That is the end of my contract. I'm sure the installer is not going to be happy because this may hold up his final payment.

The systems I was looking at was produced by feeney and can be found at this link: http://www.feeneyinc.com/Architectural/CableRail-S... there are plenty of others out there for purchase. I don't know why the installer didn't bother doing any research into the subject.

RE: Welding steel cable?

I would bet that more than likely the contractor DID do the research and saw how much those connectors are! I priced some out for a buddy doing a renovation on his home. The fittings were the push in kind, where the cable would mechanically be bound as you pushed the cable into the fitting, I am not sure if that is how all of these systems work, but I digress. For ONE of these parts for a 3/16" steel cable was upwards of $35US. The contractor probably thought he could create an equal substitution for way less dollars than that.

RE: Welding steel cable?

The homeowner or contractor went the cheap route and did not use one of the available proprietary systems for cable rail.
You get what you pay for.

RE: Welding steel cable?

I suspect also that the "protesting" engineer (not a "testing engineer") stepped on the lower cable and bounced a few times.

Also, it is possible (probable) that the cable was over-tightened to appear straight, rather than only tightened enough. At low angles of deflection, you need a lot of pre-tension to be straight under load. But above comments are correct, you really do need to start with a reputable "cable-handrail" supplier first.

RE: Welding steel cable?

Suggest you follow up and make sure it is removed and the contractor does not just provide a 'deduct' for it. Due diligence / safety of the public. Just email them until you get confirmation it has been changed.

ZCP
www.phoenix-engineer.com

RE: Welding steel cable?

(OP)
The items are in the process of being removed and the client would like me to make another visit to the site once everything is complete but..... How can I be held responsible if I was only asked to give my opinion on the existing cables? I provided my report saying that the cables did not meet code and they needed to make accommodations to correct the issues. I was not asked to come up with a repair. I gave my report to the owner, if the owner decided to do nothing I would think he would be held responsible as he did not follow the direction of the engineered he hired to review the item.

As a side note, I spoke to the owners rep the other day and they were granted occupancy by the city (a very large city) with the cables in their existing condition. Don't know why the city inspector didn't say anything.

RE: Welding steel cable?

You turn it into the next phase of work with a scope/schedule/cost to handle new design and coming out to see if it was installed per the design!

ZCP
www.phoenix-engineer.com

RE: Welding steel cable?

SteelPE:
I don’t usually carry the water for the local building officials or code officials, but if it doesn’t look like an absolute piece of junk, they might overlook it, if they don’t have the negative inclinations about these systems that I mentioned in my earlier post. It looked about like the typical installation of this type of product, and that’s as far as they took it. They probably don’t test every connection to just short of failure; they probably don’t check the dia. of all the nails in the building, or the thickness of all the plumbing fittings etc., either. I’m more upset with them, that they think they should have my every calculation, design sketch and project note for their files. Two thirds of those people can’t interpret or understand them anyway, and I’m not in the business of giving plan checkers a short course in Structural Engineering and then answering their questions on minutia; but now they are their in the public domain for some hungry attorney to check and see if I dotted my I’s and crossed my tees, never mind the general correctness and completeness of my design. They don’t have a right to my inter-office memos, e-mails and love letters during the duration of that project either. Most of the time (many times) the project problem is the fault of someone other than the EOR, and it shouldn’t be so easy to fault the engineers because he left a calc. step out during his design, despite the fact that the calc. is basically correct. They are damn sure to keep us (P.E.s) responsible, we are the easiest target, they know they can get something out of our insurance. Other designers get off with a ‘please quit doing that kind of work and getting caught doing it.’ This poor product, intentional deception, should fall right back on the builder and the railing installer. If they provide a cheap product or system which doesn’t work, it is their fault, not mine, not your’s, because I happened to walk by the site one day, and I’m a P.E.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources