×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

oil and vapour come out from roof legs

oil and vapour come out from roof legs

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

Your photos were taken looking into the sun; can not tell if the oil is from the leg or a leak at the base of the sleeve for the leg.

If it is from the leg, you are getting hot fumes condensing and dripping down the sleeve. The 'fix' would be to add a wiper seal to the sleeve. Is the oil in the tank hotter than the air temperature?

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

(OP)
Dear Duwe6,

No thing with the base of sleeve it is coming out throw legs

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

Try putting a 'wiper' collar inside the sleeves to seal off the legs. Use foam material similar to what is used for secondary seals on internal floating roofs. They should have been sealed during construction, but maybe they were not actually sealed.

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

Picture 1 shows a lot of liquid, looks like too much for vapor condensing unless over a long but the oil does not look old. The whole sleeve is wet, this looks like liquid coming up out of the sleeve.

Picture 2 shows the same - same leg?

Picture 3 is different - the sleeve is not stained, this could be a small leak at the repad?

Picture 4 is similar to pictures 1 and 2

If these are the only legs that have this issue, are they above the fill line and could the fill condition be turbulent enough to splash liquid up through these sleeves? If not the liquid fill, are you pigging into the tank, which could cause similar turbulence?

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

(OP)
Dear Duwe6,
Is that wiper as a seal accepted by API 650 BECUSE OUR TANK IS API650>??

Dear IFRs:
your answer really interesting we do some times pigging in the pipeline to the tank. I have attached new photos they may give you all complete picture.

Cold you explain to me more what do you mean by "are they above the fill line and could the fill condition be turbulent enough to splash liquid up through these sleeves?"

is there any relation if the current crude in the tank has lower or higher API??

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

API 650 does not regulate emissions. You need to review your EPA permit to see if controls on the legs are required.

To the extent that thinner liquid can flow easier, or splash through thinn places, yes, the API of the liquid is a factor.

If you have a liquid only diffuser and you bring gas into the tank through that line, there may be turbulence, it can be dramatic and it can create enough action to bring liquid up through sleeves. If the legs in question are in one area omly, see if they are in line with or above the fill pipe.

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

Can you make a quick sketch showing in plan all the legs, and those that are leaking, we need to look for patterns. Include the shell nozzles and internal piping locations, rolling laddre, gauge poles and other penetrations. What type of rim seals are there? Also, did this oil just appear recently, over a long time, after a severe weather event, after a pigging operation, after a very high fill, after the deck was landed and the tank refilledtc. Gather as much data as you can, even if it does not seem relevant (you never know what is relevant), etc.

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

(OP)
Dear IFRs,

I will pass to you all information you requested within today. Please keep in tuch

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

Sorry for the random nature of this paragraph.

This looks like a typical external double deck floating roof with a pantograph shoe seal and secondary compression plate seal. These types seldom have buoyancy or strength issues unless there was serious erection quality issues.

If the roof drains were closed and deck was overloaded with water from a storm, I would think that more legs would show oil and you would have widespread staining.

Since it is a double deck style, bad welds around the leg sleeves are an unlikely issue and since only a few legs are showing this, severely leaking compartments are not likely either.

It is hard for it to be vapors since the underside of the floating roof is normally in full contact with the liquid and while there could be some, you'd need a lot to condense into that much liquid, particularly in the hot summer months.

The sleeves are very tall and getting the floating roof that low in the liquid is quite unlikely.

I'm liking the idea that there was a turbulent fill event that splashed liquid up through these few sleeves, perhaps pigging or butane blending, etc. Bear in mind that getting liquid up through these small spaces in the leg sleeves is not easy, it would have to be quite turbulent.

If the rolling ladder froze up and held the floating roof down, I'd expect to see more and widespread liquid staining in other areas.

Question: do you have fill and suction pipe drawings?

Question: were the legs changed from low to high and position and back recently? If you pull a leg up, it may hold some liquid which might spill out.

Question: please help me understand what items 21 on page 9 of 12 of the tank drawings set are used for ( spherical caps )

Question: what does the floating roof company say?

Question: Were these legs always pinned in the low position or could the pins have been missing allowing the legs to telescope up and down as the floater came down to low liquid level, possibly bringing liquid up through, then they were "found" and "fixed"?

It's hard to find the cause without being there, getting a complete operational history, talking to those on site, etc. I'm basically shooting in the dark hoping to hit something. I am likely way off base and it will turn out to be something completely different.

Good luck, keep your ears and eyes open and let us know what happens!



RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

(OP)
Question: do you have fill and suction pipe drawings? I will check

Question: were the legs changed from low to high and position and back recently? If you pull a leg up, it may hold some liquid which might spill out.
no but even if this happen you a mouse hole in the bottom of the leg unless is blogged by sludge[/color] 

Question: please help me understand what items 21 on page 9 of 12 of the tank drawings set are used for ( spherical caps )

 Question: what does the floating roof company say? we have not called them yet, and you can not trust them especially if there is a mistake in design of the tank. [pre] 


Question: Were these legs always pinned in the low position or could the pins have been missing allowing the legs to telescope up and down as the floater came down to low liquid level, possibly bringing liquid up through, then they were "found" and "fixed"? [color #EF2929]no one touch the legs for seven years
 

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

(OP)
Question: please help me understand what items 21 on page 9 of 12 of the tank drawings set are used for ( spherical caps)....I think that is the bottom end of the leg where there is a mouse hole

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

Mustafa - that is a big tank. My guess is that if the roof was grounded or got very close to the bottom, those legs may be hitting some debris or flex in the tank floor and therefore slightly bending the roof. Depending on how fast you filled the tank??, it may not simply have been possible for all the air / vapour to travel to the vent before finding a way out via the leg holes. The upstands seem quite low - if you want to fix it I would simply increase the length of the outer sleeve, maybe even using a screwed connector to avoid welding in the tank to increase the height by say 500mm

It doesn't look like it is a constant thing, but a one off event caused by air / vapour sliding around the top of the fluid / tank. I couldn't actually tell where your vents were or how many as the pdf drawings in red and yellow were very difficult to read.

My motto: Learn something new every day

Also: There's usually a good reason why everyone does it that way

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

LittleInch - I printed his documents to PDF using "make all color black" then they were readable. Making a pdf out of a pdf, as it were. Bending the roof might leave evidence such as wrinkling, etc. The thickness of the roof at the legs is substantial - it would have to bend a long way. Some legs with puddles are close to the rim, we did not see evidence of the rim bending...

To increase the sleeve length, we would have to block the pin holes and make longer legs.

Mustafa - the drawings show mouse holes and spherical caps - you don't use both. Probably not a big deal, I was just curious.

There are rubber devices available that can be retrofitted on the legs to reduce emissions, these will also serve to minimize splash up through.

If this was a one-time event, clean it off, monitor operations and observe the deck for more oil.

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

On such a big roof, the bending wouldn't have to be very much or even just flexed when sitting on the legs to corner a small amount of vapour in a spot where it wouldn't travel to the the vents. It's clear the oil leakage is just a fairly small spurt, so I think trying to solve it remotely and without 50% of the information especially the operations immediately preceding it is a bit of a wild goose chase. I was talking about just extending the sleeve by either screwing on a connector - there is some room between the pin and the top, or welding on an extra sleeve, or simply pushing on a plastic tube. There is no pressure involved here, just a bit more head to stop any fluid spurting out.

If the tank has been there 7 years and it's only happened once then it's not a systemic problem and might not happen again. It probably hasn't been cleaned or entered since going into service so who knows what the inside floor now looks like.

My motto: Learn something new every day

Also: There's usually a good reason why everyone does it that way

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

(OP)
Dears
I am really appreciated your reply.

IFRs,
Could you please send me more information regarding rubber devices

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

(OP)
Dear IFRs,
Thank for your kind reply.

in another case we have a single roof deck damaged completely because the pontoons get punctures although the tank is only 10 years old.

Any way, I have proposed the DOME ALUMINUM with AIFR because our product is light product "condensate". My company agree , but I have still some concerns below:-

1- Frangible roof is not possible . The frangible roof specified by API 650 is a valuable explosion
and over pressure protection, it is not known how the Aluminum domed roof will perform under
similar over pressure situations.

2-The quality of the Aluminum dome weather-tight design will vary by manufacturer.

3-Aluminum's lower resistance to turbulence (lower mass) shall be considered on tank stability
checking.

4-Modification to the existing facilities such like as structural , mechanical, piping, instrumentation &
controls, fire fighting , and fire and gas detection systems are a big concern in this retrofit project.

5-Galvanic corrosion which is the most common cause for Aluminum corrosion is a very real
concern in and near to coastal applications. Higher initial cost when compare to steel EFRT.


Please your help

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

1- Frangible roof is not possible .
This is not an issue because the circulation vent area that is present with any internal floating roof is enough to provide emergency venting.

2-The quality of the Aluminum dome weather-tight design will vary by manufacturer.
This is an issue - buy a quality dome roof, not the least expensive one.

3-Aluminum's lower resistance to turbulence (lower mass) shall be considered on tank stability
checking.
This is true but tank stability can be checked mathematically. If the tank was stable as an open-top tank then adding a dome will not change that. If the tank currently has a steel cone roof, why change to a dome?

4-Modification to the existing facilities such like as structural , mechanical, piping, instrumentation &
controls, fire fighting , and fire and gas detection systems are a big concern in this retrofit project.
I think the only issue will be fire fighting - the aluminum IFR may require full-surface foam protection per NFPA or whatever code your live by in your country. Piping should not change, detection systems may change (but can usually be improved). You may find that you have more capacity because the AIFR can have a lower profile ( certain vendors and especially their seals ).

5-Galvanic corrosion which is the most common cause for Aluminum corrosion is a very real
concern in and near to coastal applications. Higher initial cost when compare to steel EFRT.
A marine environment can be an issue but galvanic should not because the steel tank to dome interface is via Teflon bearing pads under the dome structural connections ( or should be ). The internal floating roof should not care but you can get marine type alloys ( 52xx series ) from some vendors.

If you have the budget, you may want to consider upgrading to a more expensive aluminum floating roof for strength, emissions and safety reasons. At least one is made that is designed for the same load as a steel floating roof and several that are nearly as good.

Note: Among other things, I have worked with aluminum floating roof companies for 37 years and am not unbiased.

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

(OP)
Dear IFRs,

Regarding point Nr.3 our existing tank is single deck floating external roof.

Point 4 we are following NFPA THE VENDOR WILL UPGRADE AS NFPA 11.

regarding the expensive aluminum floating roof for strength, we have receive an offer from CTS , Is this company okay with domes with AIFR (is there any other best company)??Moreover, could you send me any reference regarding ALLOY(52xx) for more information

I have PICTERS THE OFFER could you send me your mail address please to pass to you all things

RE: oil and vapour come out from roof legs

A single deck floating roof does not normally have pontoons - could it be a bulkhead or pontoon style?

NFPA-11 allows only a limited few type of IFRs to have rim protection, all others require full-surface foam. You may already have full-surface protection, it is worth finding out.

For info on 5052 alloy, see these and many others:
http://www.metalsuppliersonline.com/Research/Prope...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_alloy#Marin...

It would be better to go off-line to discus specific dome vendor's products.

There is only one aluminum internal floating roof that I know of that is designed for the same loads as a steel floating roof, there are some that are lower priced but still high quality and there are still more that are average quality and even lower priced. As is common throughout the world, to some extent you get what you pay for...

Click my name, there should be more information about me there.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources