Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
(OP)
Hello,
I'm detailing some parts to send out for fabrication. A lot of the parts are shaped like plates and have symmetric features. Because of this, I tend to set up my datum reference frame using the longest surface as my A datum and my B and C datums as center-planes. I was told at my first job that if you call out a center-plane datum and put in a center-line to show this plane, you can dimension features with the symmetry implied. Follow the link for an example:
http://imgur.com/GBRELWa
Have I been doing this correctly or do I need to include extra dimensioning to fully define the features?
Thanks,
Justin
I'm detailing some parts to send out for fabrication. A lot of the parts are shaped like plates and have symmetric features. Because of this, I tend to set up my datum reference frame using the longest surface as my A datum and my B and C datums as center-planes. I was told at my first job that if you call out a center-plane datum and put in a center-line to show this plane, you can dimension features with the symmetry implied. Follow the link for an example:
http://imgur.com/GBRELWa
Have I been doing this correctly or do I need to include extra dimensioning to fully define the features?
Thanks,
Justin





RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
Now someone may invoke 1.1.4 and claim the main point of that figure isn't about the dimensioning scheme... but it's good enough for me.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
Here's a Tec-Ease video explaining it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hCAfVgAMCA
Also, do you guys also know if center-plane datums are burdensome to machinists? I feel like machinists would always prefer edge plane datums as they are much easier to zero their machines to.
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
For some reason I always remember the movie “National Treasure” where FBI agent played by Harvey Keitel keeps repeating the phrase: “Somebody has to go to jail”.
Somebody will always be burdened by something.
You dimension part from the edge, machinist takes one edge as reference, QC flips the part over and rejects it because holes are too far from the edge. Then you apply unnecessarily tight tolerance to maintain the edges, and the part cost goes up.
This is why we say dimensions have to be functional.
You want your part to be symmetrical? Somebody has to take care of that.
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
I see nowhere in ASME Y14.5-2009 that explicitly indicates symmetry implied with center plane (line). ASMY Y14.5 does mention symmetry symbol that can be used for this purpose.
Best regards,
Alex
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
I hate to kick a dead horse here but this is an important concept. KENAT and CH speak wisely. The drawing is to generally show function first and foremost. How the part is made is normally not a consideration in how the part should be dimensioned. The dimensioning should be functional dimensioning. If that agrees with your drawing I won't know unless I understood your application.
Tunalover
RE: Question about dimensioning with center-plane datums
Look at section 1.4(k). That fundamental rule states what's being discussed here.
John Acosta, GDTP S-0731
Engineering Technician
Inventor 2013
Mastercam X6
Smartcam 11.1
SSG, U.S. Army
Taji, Iraq OIF II