×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?
2

Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

(OP)
Hey all,

I am putting a closure plate at the top of a HSS column. I would like to make it water tight - thus seal welded. I am reading mixed opinions on seal weld strength here. The structure has roof deck and the closure plate need to be able to hold down the roof deck - the max un-factored load is approx. 2 k. Will a seal weld do? Here is how I have it right now. Should I specify the size of the seal weld? Really any size will do for this. What symbol should I use?

Also, I am curious - for a practical standpoint, how does the shop person get the closure plate inside the HSS column perfect and weld?

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

If noting can load it higher than that that, seal weld is a designation, but not a specification.

To illustrate, my welder walks back in at 11:45 and tells me he had "seal welded" the plate. Do I tell him to go add more metal, or do I tell him to go do the other column plate in the afternoon? How much weld is a "seal weld" ?

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

A "seal weld" is generally considered to be non-structural. If you want the weld to take load, then design a properly profiled weld. You might consider beveling the top of the HSS tube and placing the closure plate on top of that. You would then have a single bevel, complete or partial penetration structural weld around the entire perimeter of the plate and a flat surface upon which you could attach whatever you want for roof uplift.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

From the sketch, it appears the HSS column might be an open section beam rather than a tube. Is this correct, or is the HSS column a tube? If the HSS column is a tube, and you want the 1/4" plate closure to be flush with the top edge of the column, then you'll need to inset the plate and use a bevel weld around the perimeter. The tricky part is making sure the bevels on the tube and plate edges will permit a satisfactory weld given the apparent difference in section thickness.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

If possible, make it a cap plate, overlapping the column enough to provide your design fillet weld all around.

Michael.
"Science adjusts its views based on what's observed. Faith is the denial of observation so that belief can be preserved." ~ Tim Minchin

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

Most secure is to bevel the edge of the 1/4 inch flat plate at 45 with a 1/16 nominal flat left, then specify a fillet weld all around the top of the vertical tube steel.

If you do not a perfectly flat top, then do NOT require the top be ground flat. That will save a lot of time on each vertical tube steel joint.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

The weld size for either a fillet weld or a partial joint penetration weld must meet the size limitation of AWS D1.1.D1.1M if the structure is in the US. The required weld size is the larger of that required to transmit the applied load or the minimum size required by the appropriate tables found in D1.1 or the AISC Steel Construction Manual.

Best regards - Al

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

(OP)
Hey everyone! Thanks for the responses. They were very helpful. I think I will specify a closure plate the same size as the HSS's outer dimension - I will specify a bevel weld.

Question, will the bevel weld give a good seal? My primary concern is to avoid getting moisture in the column. Can I specify the bevel weld a seal weld?

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

If you bevel the plate, the normal default decision, you will have to shape it at the corners: better bevel the tube instead.

Michael.
"Science adjusts its views based on what's observed. Faith is the denial of observation so that belief can be preserved." ~ Tim Minchin

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

Nah. Beveling the simple plate - yes, at the corners too, is easy and cheap. It is simpler to bevel (run a grinder) around the outside of a flat plate than inside a tube steel rectangle.

Well, a weld will give a good seal. A bevel weld will give you an easier weld. Just to prevent water vapor entry a 1/8 or 3/16 or 1/4 weld is more than adequate.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

The bevel would be on the outside of the tube unless you want to leave a welder inside.

Michael.
"Science adjusts its views based on what's observed. Faith is the denial of observation so that belief can be preserved." ~ Tim Minchin

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

Michael...you beat me to it!

Bevel the tube. This will give you the full thickness of the closure plate to prevent burning off the edges of the plate and having a crappy looking edge.

Yes...the bevel weld will provide a good "seal".

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

Hmmmn.

Well, what is drawn places the cover plate "inside" the end of the rounded-corner tube steel, right?

So, it will be easier to bevel the pate than the inside wall of the tube steel.

True - IF you were placing the cover plate over the end of the vertical tube, then I'd agree with you about beveling the tube steel walls. But as-drawn? By the way, the originalposter is going to have trouble getting the corners of the coverplate cut exactly and rounded off anyway - fitting a plate inside the end of the tube is very difficult.

Better/cheaper/faster. MOVE the cover plate so it is placed on top of the HSS piece. (The cover plate will need to be 1/2 bigger all around since the HSS walls are 1/4 thick. Then, after tacking the cover plate, the welder/fitter can grind off the corners of the cover plate to smooth the edges.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

racookpe1978...exactly. Not easy to do as drawn. Too much fitup req'd.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

There was another entire thread on this recently- do a search.

If all you want is a seal but little structural strength, you set the cap into the HSS, leave a root gap all the way around (using TIG wire to provide the space), use a magnetic fixture to hold the part until it's tacked, then simply buzz a MIG pass around the joint to provide the seal, grinding flush if necessary to make it pretty.

If you want structural strength, the simplest option is to set the plate in and deposit a FILLET around the ID. The plate will not be flush, but that may not matter.

If the plate needs to be flush and structural strength is required, then you're stuck with bevelling. Bevelling the ID of the HSS is very difficult- don't do it. Bevel either the OD and set the plate on, or bevel the plate. Which is more likely to be labour efficient and to give a good quality weld depends on what orientation the piece will be in during welding.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

(OP)
Thanks everyone! The HSS member is 20 ft long and it would be very difficult to fillet around the ID. (Even I knows that!) I have revised my sketch and asked a PJP @ the OD of the HSS member. The PJP I specified is 1/8". The plate will have the same size as the HSS OD and will be 1/4" thick. So the HSS will be 1/4" shorter than what I originally drew. I really appreciate everyone's input on this. Have a good Friday and a good weekend!

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

Umm, "set the plate in" means set it BELOW FLUSH from the end of the HSS, such that there's a place on the ID of the HSS to land the fillet...I'm not stupid enough to think you can find a tiny welder to climb into the HSS and fillet it from the inside...

The 1/8" gap PJP is fine as long as all you want is a seal, and if you can't tolerate the cap being below flush, i.e. on the top of a vertical column with exposed top where you don't want water to pond.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

The way I've seen this done, is the end plate is slightly larger than the inside dimensions of the tube, the welder places it by hand and provides a couple of tack welds and then produces a fillet weld all around effectively sealing the opening.

Dik

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

(OP)
Hi dik,

I didn't want a larger plate because I wanted flush edges and didn't want to cope the beam just to accommodate the plate. I would be curious though, from a labor standpoint, whether a fabricator would prefer to 1) fillet weld a larger plate and cope the beam top flange or 2) PJP a HSS-OD-shaped plate and install the beam as usual.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

(OP)
Hi Moltenmetal,

Ah ha on the "set the plate in". Thanks. The reason I wanted it to be flush is because I have roof deck to be attached to the top of column.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

The plate is slightly larger than the interior of the HSS and smaller than the outside of the HSS. This allows the plate to sit on the HSS and not 'fall in' and gives enough space for a small fillet weld to attach the plate to the HSS.

Dik

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

Looking this over, after the conversation, why not sit the beam on the cap plate? Any perpendicular beams can frame in to this beam, or vice versa. This, to me, is the normal way to frame it.

Michael.
"Science adjusts its views based on what's observed. Faith is the denial of observation so that belief can be preserved." ~ Tim Minchin

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

Yeah, but then you have to oversize (make thicker!) the cap plate nd the cap plate weld so it IS strong enough o hold the twisting and moment forces.

But that has to be a field weld. Here, he is doing a shop joint (I hope!) on the bolting plate; followed by a field bolted joint of flat plate to horizontal beam.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

(OP)
Hi paddingtongreen - at a few locations I also have a bracing connection, where I will a gusset plate to the beam. It is easier to detail the way it is. Also, yes, avoiding field weld was one of my priorities too.

RE: Closure Plate for HSS Column, Seal Welded? Strength?

(OP)
Hi Dik, I am so sorry I misunderstood you! The HSS column is only 1/2" (HSS 10x10x1/2) - which means realistically we only have 0.465" or so wall thickness because of HSS tolerances. I wonder whether it gives us enough space to fillet weld a plate that is cut just larger than the inside dimension? Your idea is very simple, practical and neat otherwise.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources