×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

(OP)
I'm curious who does wood building seismic design.

Also, the real reason I'm asking, is how do you do it? Do you do it by hand or with a program?

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

By hand.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

By spreadsheets written 20 years ago and updated as code changes.

The sooner you write your own, the longer you can use them. Mine do wind/seismic at the same time.

LonnieP

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

this can't be a real question...

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

(OP)
It's real. This isn't asking for advice, it's more of a survey.

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

I'm sure I will be the odd man out here...

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

I get the loads from spreadsheets and look the diaphragm up in the NDS table. I never check seismic though, wind governs where I live.

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

I don't because wood floors and roofs are usually very light, maybe only 1/10th of a concrete floor. So when the numbers crunch out wind is normally the governing criteria.

This is my experience.

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

Could we assume asixth that your location is in a non seismic area.

http://www.nceng.com.au/
"Programming today is a race between software engineers striving to build bigger and better idiot-proof programs, and the Universe trying to produce bigger and better idiots. So far, the Universe is winning."

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

I do mine by hand, but do not have to check seismic very often.

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

(OP)
I guess I should modify the question then. I am in a high seismic area so that tends to be all I think of, but wind or seismic makes no difference to me. For lateral design of wood diaphragms and wood shear walls, do you use a program, a spreadsheet, or do calcs by hand?

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

I do it by hand for each case, wind or seismic, and I have to do both for each structure where I am.

However, I do have formatted hand fill-in sheets for both wind and seismic that I use with the equations and code references listed for the plans checker. Works for me.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

I use a combination of WoodWorks, spreadsheets, and hand calculations.

I think that the "who does it" question has some merit as a discussion point. I've worked for some prominent firms in the past and have never seen anyone do what I would consider to be a complete seismic design on any but the simplest light frame wood buildings. I think that this is because:

1) Light frame wood buildings are often rather complex with regard to the lateral load path.
2) The fee just isn't ever there to support the effort. Ethics would lead us to believe this is irrelevant, of course.

On the sketchy side of things, I've seen designers sum up the applied shear loads, compare then to the lengths of plywood / gypsum walls available, and call it a day. No tie downs, no explicit chords, no transfer diaphragms...

At the other end of the spectrum is the material that I've been reading in a book called "The Analysis of Irregular Shaped Structures: Diaphragms and Shear Walls". It's excellent, tedious, and all about wood lateral. It gives me hope in that the methods prescribed are very detailed and rigorous. I just truly don't know how I could ever squeeze enough fee out of a light frame wood project to make a go of it. And, even if I could, the guy down the street would probably just undercut me by $2K and buy a new boat with all of the fee he didn't spend looking into light frame wood lateral.

Yes, I'm jaded on this particular topic.

The greatest trick that bond stress ever pulled was convincing the world it didn't exist.

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

Here in seismic SoCal, on light frame construction I at least compute the seismic base shear to verify that wind controls. If wind controls, no further seismic is done. Except you still have to do seismic detailing as required by the seismic Category. The local building departments get whiney when you don't show some reference to seismic.

I love that USGS site that figures out the basics for you!

Distributing seismic forces up and down and back and forth (to the LFRS) is a pain.

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

(OP)
How do you do it buggar? By hand, spreadsheet, or with a program?

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

I assume you are referring to the seismic forces? pipe

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

(OP)
Argh my brain. I meant to ask how do you design the LFRS, whether it's wind or seismic?

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

JVVSE
I generally do seismic by hand. Most of my structures are unusual and when I write a spreadsheet, it's not adaptable to other seismic problems.

I used to program all my seismic and wind calcs in Basic since that emulated my hand methods. Is Basic still around?

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

>>>Here in seismic SoCal, on light frame construction I at least compute the seismic base shear to verify that wind controls<<<

Wow, Buggar, that's a surprise to me. Are you saying that in Southern California wind controls most of your designs?

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

(OP)
ASCE 7 wind loads are ridiculously high (IMHO) and for light-frame structures it can sometimes govern. If he's doing unusual structures then wind can get even higher. Also don't forget So Cal is a big area. Seismic base shear can be as low as 0.1W in the rural/desert areas or as high as 0.4W in LA/SF.

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

Interesting, thanks. And I suppose with a light frame structure the W portion is, well, light. Separately, .4W ... wow ...

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

If you have a rectangular structure - wind may goven in one direction and seismic, the other direction. Gotta check both to keep the plan checker from handing you a surprise.

LonnieP

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

(OP)
KootK, did you edit that post? I swear I never saw it before today. Dunno how it slipped through this conversation.

I was looking for someone else who used WoodWorks! Do you use it for the rigid diaphragm analysis or another reason, instead of just spreadsheets or hand calcs?

Tedious and rigorous do not sound appealing to me. Especially in wood design there is so much redundancy and I guess we can call it complexity with all the construction materials that it's very hard to analyze it accurately. As engineers we are able to make judgments on how to do our analysis. The simplest way is to make conservative judgments to reduce the need for tedious or rigorous analysis because we are definitely not paid enough to do it. They key word being "conservative." I've met engineers that claim collectors don't really exist, and while they are ready to back up their claim I'd rather put in a collector than spend hours proving the need for it.

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

jvvse

I also use woodworks, but just for member design. Wood connections I have a spreadsheet for and diaphragm/shear walls I do by hand. My woodworks package is sizer, shear walls, and connections. I don't like the connection designer as it seems to be wrong in certain instances and I never noticed the shearwall designer til just now lol.

RE: Wood Building Seismic Design - who does it?

+1 on Jvvse's comment

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources