×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

(OP)
If I were to design a steel joist. And by this I mean structurally design the joist, not lay them out for a building, but actually designing the top chord, web and bottom chord. What would be the code checks to follow from the AISC code book?

For a K series joist I want to use the following:

Top Chord: Double Angles (Equal lengths)36 Ksi
Web: Single Angle (Uncrimped-First analysis, Crimped-Second Analysis)36 Ksi
Bottom Chord: Double Angles (Equal lengths) 36 KSI
Rods at each ends from bottom chord to top chord.

The Vulcraft Manual states the bottom chord to be checked in axial tension only, web in compression, and top chord in axial compression ONLY if panels are less than 24" apart.

I've used Chapters D,E,and F.
D2
E3 & E4
F9

When I asked my boss about this he said we would never design our own joists for a client, we would just assign proper loads for someone like Vulcraft to meet our specifications. The reason I want to learn to do this is that this summer, for my masters program, I will be taking Advanced Strength of Materials and Advanced Structural Analysis. For both these classes we must do a project. I would like to make this one of my projects. However, with my checks on my progress so far I certainly feel their are many other checks I am missing. Any guidance is appreciated.

Thanks,

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

K Series Joists are made with 50 Ksi Steel.

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

I would suggest contacting a manufacturer's representative. Often their engineer's are very helpful. If you explain you are a student, they might help you with some design guides they use or sample calcs they run.

Just a thought.


RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

Don't they design steel joist to the SJI Specifications, not AISC?

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

(OP)
I don't have their manual (SJI). But the excerpts I've caught online don't show design process. I will start calling manufacturers tomorrow. Also, I did read on the Vulcraft manual that they use both 36KSI and 50KSI for their designs. I was reviewing and using 36 KSI because the AISC manual shows it as the preferred yield stress for angles.

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

What is the purpose of the exercise? You would design the joist just like you design a truss, only using smaller members.

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

As Jed said they use the SJI manual.
I talked to one of the Vulcraft Engineers recently who said it would be very difficult to replicate their their numbers without SJI because of a number of issues, including:

To minimize member sizes, they don't use K=1.0 for compression analysis. The actual K they use is based on the size, shape, and welds for that member and will often be less than 1.
Their calculations include eccentricity in the joints, ie - what if the truss isnt perfectly coplanar? I believe they assume 1" eccentricity.
Their calculations include eccentricity at the joints, ie - the web members may not meet at a theoretical perfect point due to manufacturing tolerances.

If you're trying to replicate the design for an existing joist, or existing calculations - good luck.
If you're doing it as an academic excercise, maybe these points can be ignored and you can proceed with the design via AISC.

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

Done lots of these way back when... for preliminary, determine moment at mid span (for UDL) using wl^2/8 and using a depth = 0.9*actual depth... determine chord forces and double angle size required... Iused to use compression force on chord panel point distance*.9 due to 'fixity'. Web members are designed based on shear at supports... welding follows... remember to design the connection at the chord panel poins for the horizontal difference in the forces in the web members... It's a place to start and will give you a pretty good approx for what will follow.

Dik

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

The extension of the top chord at each end for bearing will cause bending to be induced into the top chord. This may require a change in panel point spacing toward the end to control the stresses in the top chord.

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

Like SteelPE said, there is nothing magical about joists (trusses). I have designed them "from scratch" for a steel fabricator client before and hardly needed anything from SJI other than some bracing guidelines.

If you do this for your project, one trick is roof joists in uplift have bottom chord compression so you have to have permanent continuous lateral bracing of the bottom chord.

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

For a master's Degree project I'd not use the usual sections. I'd try to come up with something different that may be more economical, perhaps tubing, Maybe aluminum, who knows. You might even develop something useful and of value. How about prefabed sections of roof along with the joists? Then in the process get a manufacturer to try it.

RE: Starting from scratch in designing a steel joist...

The Steel Joist Institute's Catalog of Standard Specifications And Load and Weight Tables for Steel Joists And Joist Girders can be downloaded for free after registering on there website. See http://steeljoist.org/free-download-form. I think the same specification is printed in Vulcraft's catalog.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources