Bending of beam under pure tension
Bending of beam under pure tension
(OP)
Hi there!
Given a beam/profile like this

With a force applied normally to one end and given no degrees of freedom at the other, the beam is experiencing pure tensile stress.
It should be, anyway.
In reality, what happens is that the beam bends drastically outwards and experiences bending.

Can anyone share some insight into why this happens and how I can avoid it?
I have a gate where the back plate (not exposed to water pressure) is holding the front arced plate (exposed to water pressure) together.
I wanted to stiffen this large plate up with a few bars to avoid it being so flimsy, but it makes the whole back plate bend outwards.

With best regards
Daniel
Given a beam/profile like this

With a force applied normally to one end and given no degrees of freedom at the other, the beam is experiencing pure tensile stress.
It should be, anyway.
In reality, what happens is that the beam bends drastically outwards and experiences bending.

Can anyone share some insight into why this happens and how I can avoid it?
I have a gate where the back plate (not exposed to water pressure) is holding the front arced plate (exposed to water pressure) together.
I wanted to stiffen this large plate up with a few bars to avoid it being so flimsy, but it makes the whole back plate bend outwards.

With best regards
Daniel
---------------------------
I am Norwegian.
I design mechanicals for hydroelectric powerplants.
I use NX 8.0.3.4 and ANSYS 15
----------------------------
Tom you can't knit at these speeds! Nobody can! DON'T BE A GODDAMNED HERO TOM!






RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
In your full model it could also be some moment is generated around the corner due to the continuity.
To avoid this either use a symetric beam/stiffner arrangement so you are loading it through the centroid, or load it through the centroid.
You cannot avoid it deflecting given the full arrangement, how much deflection is acceptable is really a matter of judgement. If the strength is ok, and it still performs the job (in that it wont leak if its retaining water) then what is the problem?
We dont know the scale of the item, but the 18mm deflection could be acceptable if its a few meters wide?
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
Looking at your full model the values given are negative stress i.e.
compression, under that circumstance isn't the back plate under compression and starting to buckle?
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
Agent666: I've been thinking about putting a range of smaller bars on the opposite side of the stiffeners, to even it out, but I think the deflection shown here might be acceptable.
-Daniel
---------------------------
I am Norwegian.
I design mechanicals for hydroelectric powerplants.
I use NX 8.0.3.4 and ANSYS 15
----------------------------
Tom you can't knit at these speeds! Nobody can! DON'T BE A GODDAMNED HERO TOM!
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
If you do then maybe its a modelling issue.
Instead of stiffening it with a flat plate you could use and angle, or channel section which would be stiffer.
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
---------------------------
I am Norwegian.
I design mechanicals for hydroelectric powerplants.
I use NX 8.0.3.4 and ANSYS 15
----------------------------
Tom you can't knit at these speeds! Nobody can! DON'T BE A GODDAMNED HERO TOM!
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
Second order. Look at your diagram showing deformed shape, the load now has moved to the right of center of the fixed end, so it will cause a partial equalizing moment.
Michael.
"Science adjusts its views based on what's observed. Faith is the denial of observation so that belief can be preserved." ~ Tim Minchin
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
the thin plate is bending due to inplane load; plate's don't like this. a question to ask might be "am i deflecting the plate too much ?" if your FEA deflection is bigger than the thickness of the plate you might need to consider membrane forces (simple plate bending assumes no axial load on the centroid, ie no membrane forces).
Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
The plate gives me a nice big area for the stress to be absorbed into (around 50% utilization) as well as the fact that it brings stiffness to the structure as a whole.
Oh, and the width of this whole thing is over 8 metres. The bottom image shows the lower half of the whole gate.
---------------------------
I am Norwegian.
I design mechanicals for hydroelectric powerplants.
I use NX 8.0.3.4 and ANSYS 15
----------------------------
Tom you can't knit at these speeds! Nobody can! DON'T BE A GODDAMNED HERO TOM!
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
Check the magnification factor in your FEA software. FEA grossly exaggerates strain in its displays. Often, it helps to turn this feature off.
--
JHG
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
i'd add stiffeners to the opposite side to balance the plate.
if weight is a concern, cut lightening holes in the plate (away from the stiffeners it's not that effective).
how is the plate attached to the curved wall ? is the curved wall putting moment into the plate ?
Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
Fixed it for you... Oh, and that weld distortion is likely to be in the opposite direction, and thus act as a pre-camber.
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
The deflection on back plate of the gate is about 15 mm. The image shows a magnification factor to the deflection of about 30.
The back plate is some 10-12 mm thick (don't remember at the moment, since I'm not at work).
The plate is connected to the curved wall as well as the curved wall's stiffeners; the latter which may lead to a small amount of moment being transferred.
It shouldn't be much compared to the tension forces though, but then again, they both induce bending in the same direction.
---------------------------
I am Norwegian.
I design mechanicals for hydroelectric powerplants.
I use NX 8.0.3.4 and ANSYS 15
----------------------------
Tom you can't knit at these speeds! Nobody can! DON'T BE A GODDAMNED HERO TOM!
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
support the plate symmetrically.
Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
Will do.
---------------------------
I am Norwegian.
I design mechanicals for hydroelectric powerplants.
I use NX 8.0.3.4 and ANSYS 15
----------------------------
Tom you can't knit at these speeds! Nobody can! DON'T BE A GODDAMNED HERO TOM!
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
How much water head? Remembering back to fluids at university I can't remember if there are additional loads due to the fact that water is moving past the gate. I assume the water side is a more substantial structure than the same thin plate and stiffeners so it doesn't buckle if in compression. If it's 8m across and this is the bottom half the thing must be 20m tall, water pressures would be enormous and I'm having trouble believing relying on just the back plate works for strength?
Given the scale I would be providing far more substantial beams or something than a flat plate + stiffener.
RE: Bending of beam under pure tension
The strength lies in the arced shape of the front plate.
The larger the radius of the front plate, the thinner the structure and the more "stretch" of the back plate under pressure.
The smaller the radius, the closer we are to a "perfect half circle" which leads to less stretching of the back plate, but also makes for a stupidly overall thick and hard-to-handle structure. This also leads to trouble with the flat, pressure-affected top plate, which would have a very large span.
I've got a good compromise with a radius of around 6-6.5 metres. This makes the gate a little under 2 metres thick.
FYI, the gate will only be maneuvered under equalized water pressure (no flow).
---------------------------
I am Norwegian.
I design mechanicals for hydroelectric powerplants.
I use NX 8.0.3.4 and ANSYS 15
----------------------------
Tom you can't knit at these speeds! Nobody can! DON'T BE A GODDAMNED HERO TOM!