×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Designing a greenhouse

Designing a greenhouse

Designing a greenhouse

(OP)
Has anyone designed a large greenhouse? I am looking at designing a 50'x96' one. I would like to get some feedback from someone that has designed one before.

Thanks,

CJC

RE: Designing a greenhouse

If you want a dome style, there are lots of DIY books out there, or you could contact Growing Spaces in Colorado...

RE: Designing a greenhouse

Why wouldn't your client just buy a greenhouse kit from a Mfr? There are plenty of them out there..... and I'm not sure I would want to design these systems as they have light structural member running everywhere.

RE: Designing a greenhouse

(OP)
Client is required to purchase an engineered design per the local jurisdiction. According to client, the greenhouse kit company wants to charge $25k for the stamped set. I am going to look into other companies for the client, but I also wanted to know if anyone else has designed one of these. I figure it would have to be steel moment frames and glass/polycarbonate cladding sheets. The client wants a traditional greenhouse with side walls and pitched roof.

RE: Designing a greenhouse

Too bad - the domes are sweet to look at and very strong. Most of the chicken coop rectangular sloped roofed ones I have seen utilize specialized and custom extrusions or shapes to deal with the expansion / contraction and corrosive issues in combination with the sealing and ease of replacing glazing. I would not want to reinvent the wheel for $25k.

RE: Designing a greenhouse

I live in big heavy snow country, and our greenhouse put a few pre-manufactured greehouses that look really really weak. But the heat keeps the snow sliding and he's never had an issue. I'd never stamp it. But it works just fine.

_________________________
TKE

RE: Designing a greenhouse

Something is fishy.... 25k to stamp their drawings? They don't have anyone that can do it for them who works for them? These things must be engineered by someone. My parents have 3 hoop greenhouses.... The oldest being 30 years old. Never had a problem with snow as long as you take care of them.

RE: Designing a greenhouse

More likely there is $25K to upgrade the structure so that an engineer can stamp it.

_________________________
TKE

RE: Designing a greenhouse

>>>These things must be engineered by someone.<<<

Not necessarily...wink

RE: Designing a greenhouse

(OP)
I thought the same thing. They are horribly underengineered. I did some sleuthing online. There are companies that specialize in greenhouse engineering. One is Rough Brothers. Their designs are much stouter than the light tin ones I have seen. They actually use steel trusses and purlins. I don't have a problem designing/stamping a set of drawings as long as I do the design.

RE: Designing a greenhouse

I work as a structural consultant for a greenhouse company who produces code approved greenhouses. In fact, I finished a 50' wide system a few weeks ago. The framing system consists of steel trusses, purlins, and girts. I can tell you that the structure we design follows the code to the letter - no more, no less. I can also tell you that not every greenhouse produced follows the code because many of them are rural and do not have a building code adopted.

Greenhouse systems are highly specialized with a tight profit margin. Every member is optimized to be exactly the size that it needs to be. Because of this, I suspect that a custom greenhouse will be even more costly. Additionally, TopKnot is probably correct - the 25k is to upgrade components of the greenhouse to be code compliant.

RE: Designing a greenhouse

I have never designed a large greenhouse, and probably never will, but I painted my little Fred Meyer greenhouse red.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Designing a greenhouse

Schwandon,

Thanks for the info.

RE: Designing a greenhouse

(OP)
I figured out what the additional cost was: He wanted to take several separate greenhouses and combine them into one. This would obviously drive up the cost.

Schwandon,

Thanks for your help. What is the MWFRS in a greenhouse? I am guessing that cables or x-bracing is used for the lateral bracing. Could you elaborate?

Thanks,

Cody

RE: Designing a greenhouse

In the transverse direction, the MWFRS consists of cantilevered columns and knee braces. In the longitudinal direction, the MWFRS consists of x-bracing (although the columns are cantilevered in that direction also).

RE: Designing a greenhouse

(OP)
Schwandon,

I found a structural design manual online for greenhouses. It is put out by NGMA. I am sure you have seen it. Pretty generic, but an attempt to codify these things.

Cody

RE: Designing a greenhouse

Actually, I have not seen that design manual. We simply design them like we would design any other building. We run all of the loads, taking advantage of every code nuance, and then apply the loading to a RISA model. The structural analysis is really not complicated; the complication is putting together an efficient, economical solution. Much of the design boils down to using (or working around) greenhouse specific items (vents, gutters, purlins, etc) to perform structural purposes, thereby producing a comprehensive system.

I hope that helps.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources