×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Inductor for low frquency filter

Inductor for low frquency filter

Inductor for low frquency filter

(OP)
I am trying to build a 5KHz passive elliptic LPF for harmonic supression. The problem was that the 1.2mH axial high current inductor caused a severe harmonic distortion. The frequecy response was exactly as it supposed to be designed. But the filter introduced higher harmonics rather than to suppress them.

Do you guys know a better inductor capable for this filter?

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

(OP)
The filter is designed to filter out the harmonics of 5KHz, which are 10KHz and 15KHz. Since the harmonics of 5KHz signal from the synthesized generator are -80 dBc relative to the fundamental, through this filter, the harmonics should be -110 dBc, which should noe be observed by using a spectrum analyzer.

But the problem was through the passive filter the harmonics were "amplified" to just -60dBc. I am pretty sure that the inductor caused the distortion.

I want to find a 1.2mH inductor for this filter not to induce the harmonic distortion. I hope you guys have some experience with this problem.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

why not use active filter ? The inductor can pick up noise
from ext. magnetic field, too. What is your waveform or
spectrum and amplitude ?

<nbucska@pcperipherals.com>

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

(OP)
I have tried all kinds of active filter, like Chebychev, Multi-feedback, GIC, GIC elliptic, etc. Even the distortion performances of some OP AMP can be -120 dB in data sheet, once built in filter, the harmonic distortion can not be better than -80 dBc.

Active device normally be more distortable than passive device. That's why I went to use passive filters.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

Try using 2 inductors in series.  When one "breaks down" (with regards to frequency suppression), the other will still block.

Just a thought (I don't know too much about inductor technology).

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

(OP)
The filter is designed to filter out the harmonics of 5KHz, which are 10KHz and 15KHz. Since the harmonics of 5KHz signal from the synthesized generator are -80 dBc relative to the fundamental, through this filter, the harmonics should be -110 dBc, which should noe be observed by using a spectrum analyzer.

But the problem was through the passive filter the harmonics were "amplified" to just -60dBc. I am pretty sure that the inductor caused the distortion.

I want to find a 1.2mH inductor for this filter not to induce the harmonic distortion. I hope you guys have some experience with this problem.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

Why did you repost the same message?

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

(OP)
Sorry! I thought my post weren't updated.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

It is not easy to get 110 dB attenuation. You can have distortion due to saturation or noise or simply your
output circuit may pick up the noise or radiation
generated by your input circuit. You may need shielding
or more careful layout.

<nbucska@pcperipherals.com>

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

(OP)
You are right. Shielding will help for 110 dB attenuation. But at this frequency it should be very easy to achieve 90 to 100 dB attenuation. It did not gete close to it and the harmonics out of the filter were much higher than the input. Talking with the inductor manufacturer, I know the inductor is not in saturation problemsince the current is 50 times smaller than the saturation current.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

Hi there, If I have understood this thread correctly this is effectively an a "audio" filter. You state that 110dB attenuation should be no problem to achieve at 5kHz, but you use the dBc weighting, i.e. referenced relative to the carrier. What is the actual level of the fundamental signal?
From my experience designing modem filters I think you may find that even at 5kHz you will require very careful layout  - and measurement technique - to achieve a real 110dB attentuation. Have you actually measured the noise spectrum from the filter, because it is very easy to pick up noise at those sort of expected low levels from other test equipment, e.g. PC c.r.t. screens, which can add to the apparent output voltage from the filter.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

(OP)
Right now, the problem is the harmonic distortion. With 1V pk-pk fundamental signal, the harmonics are way way higher than the noise floor. They suppose to be less than the noise floor.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

I gave BRIANG a star for being right : it is not a trivial
task to get -110 dB.

I measured at 1 MHz. -60dB between two 1/4 W resistors
at 6".

You can try to divide the 1.2 mH into two and arrange them
antiparallel, or rotate it to minimum. Try shielding, better grounding scheme, etc.
 

<nbucska@pcperipherals.com>

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

(OP)
I discussed this problem with an enginner from Coilcraft. I thought this distortion might still be caused by the saturation distortion of the inductor. It seemed that the ferrite core used for inductor would not work well at such a low frequency.

I am going to try the inductor built with either air core or iron core, which are used for audio frequency.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

Before you build a 1.2 mH aircore inductor, perhaps it
would help us to know, what you are trying to do and why ?

My experience is that if something is very difficult, often
it is an indication that we picked a  very long shortcut.

<nbucska@pcperipherals.com>

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

You didn't mention what type of inductor you are using, from the symptoms described it sounds like you are using an iron-cored or ferrite inductor, and that the core is saturating.. I would recommend you use a large air core inductor and if you are handling significant power a speaker cross-over inductor would be helpful.. Solen amongst others makes an excellent and inexpensive line of air core inductors.. Check out their website at www.solen.ca
- they sell direct.. Note I have no affiliation with them in any way.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

(OP)
Tnanks! I did try the air core coil used for speaker crossover. The distortion was still bad. Finally I got the idea that the distortion was caused by the 1 uF ceramic chip capacitors used in this filter. It seems that at such a low frequency the dielectric material of the caps has a high voltage coefficient. After changing them to some mylar caps (I think the polypropylene cap will be even better), the filter did achieve -110 dBc harmonic distortion. I may try to use the polypropylene caps in my active filter circuits to see if I could have the same distortion performance.

I appreciate your help very much.

RE: Inductor for low frquency filter

Hi,
Interesting, I have had lots of problems with ceramic caps and distortion in audio circuits.. Note Y5V dielectric is about the worst and X7R isn't much better, anything above 0.1uF should be regarded with suspicion in a ceramic. Unfortunately ceramics are quite microphonic too, and this correlates well to the distortion problem as well. Tantalums are better in terms of distortion and generally non microphonic, still not my first choice. Polypropylene are quite good, however just like large ceramics they can be microphonic, so if this is a problem there are special relatively non-microphonic types available.. (Tighter wrap I believe.)

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources