×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Thermal management on roots type supercharger
3

Thermal management on roots type supercharger

Thermal management on roots type supercharger

(OP)
Many of my customers run 4AGZE engines that run an old Ogura two lobe roots supercharger.

Many people are running these well outside their original design parameters. At a certain point the lobes hit the housing and it wrecks the supercharger. Whenever I can I try to talk people into going a different direction and use something designed for higher pressure ratios but sometimes people just want to get as much as they can out of the stock unit.
Most discussion is usually focused on cooling the compressor housing but I started wondering if cooling the outside may actually do more harm than good. The temp of the housing will have very little effect on the temp of the lobes. On the other hand if the lobes heat up and expand a lot and the housing is cool and expands less it will be more likely for the lobes to hit each other or the housing. This has me wondering if it may actually be better to coat the housing with a ceramic thermal barrier which would help keep the housing temp more even and closer to the temp of the lobes. If everything heats and expands a similar amount then the gap between the lobes themselves and the lobes and housing should stay closer to nominal shouldn't it?
I know it would be more ideal to work out a way to cool the lobes but that's not going to be a viable option.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

In the old days dragsters adapted GMC blowers/superchargers and soon were overdriving them.
http://cacklefest.com/images/Picture-151.jpg

I seem to recall magazine articles about modifying the rotors for desired clearances, teflon wear strips, and hard coatings before they evolved to manufacturing specialty rotors and then complete superchargers.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

I agree with your reasoning that cooling the casing might be a bad idea. Plus, it will not be very effective for cooling the compressed air.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

SMALL amount of water/methanol injection before the blower should keep temps down, and increase volumetric efficiency.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

I believe that these Toyota chargers are not rebuildable, so coating the rotors is going to be difficult!
As Gibson said, water/meth injection could be the best way to go.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

(OP)
They are not rebuildable but you can get to the rotors. You are right that they aren't rebuildable. Actually that's not even true. There are no bearings available in the aftermarket that will fit the unique size they used on the lobe bearings. With custom bearings or customizing the housing for different bearings it is fully rebuildable. It just puts it out of the range of practicality for an old inefficient roots blower.
Above I wasn't talking about coating the rotors though. I was talking about coating the SC housing to try to keep heat in and more evenly distributed. The only downside is that then you are introducing more heat into the oil and bearings but I don't imagine the temps should be drastically different.
Really I am just wondering what I should coat it with. I do plan on ceramic coating it to make it look nice but I have three options. I could use heat dissipation coating, Thermal barrier coating or a regular coating that wouldn't have a significant impact on heat dissipation. Just trying to decide which would be best.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

The exit air temperature will go up exponentially with the pressure ratio, and I suspect the internal and casing temperatures will track the exit temperature to some extent.

"Schiefgehen will, was schiefgehen kann" - das Murphygesetz

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

yoshimitsuspeed, IMHO even a thin thermal blanket will be much more effective than a coating, but both together should give you what you want.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

Any way to quantify, at least a little bit, the "certain point the lobes hit the housing and it wrecks the supercharger" ?

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

(OP)
140Airpower
I don't plan on doing or suggesting doing more than a coating. I wouldn't be surprised if it made a huge difference one way or the other but I just thought I would ask since as often happens my logic and understanding of things contradicts the standard beliefs and so I always want to try to wrap my head around all possibilities as much as possible. The last thing I want to do is make the SC able to take 10% more heat without tapping the rotors in trade for dying 5 times faster due to overheating bearings. I doubt that's going to happen but these are the things I am trying to weigh out before settling on a decision.

Tmoose
There would be a lot of variables to fill in to come close to predicting this. Ultimately it all comes down to CTE. Theoretically if the whole supercharger heated up evenly it should be able to get incredibly hot without anything hitting. The case is aluminum, the lobe structure is aluminum which is coated with some form of Teflon coating. Since the housing and the lobes are the same material if they heat up evenly and expand evenly then they should maintain near nominal tolerances. This is why I think that when the supercharger blows up due to too much heat that it must be that the housing is not heating up as much or as fast as the lobes. If the lobes heat up and grow more faster then they will get closer to the housing and eventually touch.
You could work this all out on paper pretty accurately but it would take a good bit of work and filling in many variables to get close.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

yoshimitsuspeed, Interesting concern, bearing life. Keep in mind that this thing is air cooled. That may sound funny when the air is hot, but the assembly can't get significantly hotter than the compressed air..., unless the bearings themselves or the rotor/housing contact make a lot of heat and then the airflow through it still puts a limit on the temperature.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

Keep in mind that aluminum loses strength very fast above 300F. Heat treatment temperatures are as low as 350F.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

(OP)
Unfortunately roots blowers are horribly inefficient. Fortunately the housing shouldn't get anywhere near the temp of the air coming out. at 16 PSI boost and 45% adiabatic efficiency on a hot day you could see outlet temps in excess of 400f. Fortunately enough the SC only sees that for a fraction of the time. Half the SC housing is getting a constant flow of ambient air flowing past. The lobe spend half their time exposed to ambient air and half their time the warmer compressed air. This incoming ambient air will keep the SC much cooler than outlet temps. Unfortunately that does mean the outlet side of the compressor will tend to be much hotter than the inlet side.
I could get real fancy and coat the inlet half of the housing in thermal barrier and the outlet half in heat transfer hehe.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

Actually, the rotors will always be much hotter than the part of the housing they run in. The bore region of the housing will tend not to track rotor temp very well because inlet air is cool and the housing is directly heated only at the bottom.
I have not heard of blowers suffering loss of strength due to temperature even though the compressed air reaches 400F or so. Note that piston tops and air cooled cylinder heads get much hotter and survive heavy service.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

(OP)
The concern is not structural integrity. It's about the rotors expanding enough to contact the housing.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

That Rootes device creates increased manifold pressure by forcing a volume of air into the intake space that is larger than the engine naturally wants to flow. This compresses the manifold air volume constrained between the rotor lobes and the intake valves. The efficiency of a two-lobed Rootes device is normally fairly modest. The main source of efficiency loss with a Rootes blower is leakage past the rotor tips and sides. Sometimes tip seals or sacrificial coatings are applied to the tips to reduce leakage.

With regards to operating temperatures and thermal expansion of the rotors and housing, if both are made of similar materials they should have similar thermal expansion rates. However, with a Rootes blower the discharge side of the housing will be exposed to higher air temperatures than the intake side, while the spinning rotors will have a fairly uniform exposure to the low/high air temps at the intake and discharge ports.

The main problem I can see with higher boost levels in this supercharger is that the higher air temperatures created at the discharge side will result in more thermal distortion in the housing than it was designed for. Most likely, this will increase leakage past the rotor tips and reduce efficiency.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

(OP)
Roots blowers are actually one of the least efficient ways you can compress air.
I'm not at liberty to show the Ogura maps I have but the compressor above is slightly less efficient than a comparable Eaton M62. The Ogura charger is only rated to a pressure ratio of 1.8:1 and has slightly lower efficiencies at 1.8 than the M62 does at 2:1. As you can see, with a roots blower it's quite easy to get into the mid to low 50s in efficiency especially in small displacement motors that require high pressure ratios to make power.

As I already tried to explain several times including the post directly above yours, the issue is not increased leakage or air gaps but quite the opposite. The rotor will tend to heat up more and faster than the housing. This causes the rotor blades to hit the housing.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

A Rootes device can be made to give good efficiency, but it requires close tolerance tip clearances, twisted multi-lobed rotors, etc. I also would not accept that the two lobed rotor in the design noted would experience higher operating temperatures than the discharge end of the housing. While the rotor lobes are more thermally isolated than the housing structure, the rotor lobe surfaces are also constantly exposed to alternating low air temperatures on the intake side and higher temperatures on the discharge side. As for the housing, the discharge side is constantly exposed to higher air temperatures.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

Hi Yoshimitsuspeed,

" The rotor will tend to heat up more and faster than the housing. This causes the rotor blades to hit the housing. "

Have you been able to examine or better yet autopsy any failed superchargers? I'd be interested to see the wear patterns on the rotors and housing, especially some in the early stages of failure. I envision Scuffing of the inner contours of the rotors could be the result of phasing type errors, or rotor-to-rotir clearance set by the center-to-center spacing of the rotors.
Warming up the housing might help maintain rotor-to-case clearance, but not have so much effect on rotor-to-rotor clearance.

I assume greater boost is achieved by speeding up the supercharger.
What is the max rpm of the supercharger in OEM use? How high are the ones that fail revving?

My earlier question about the certain point that failure may ensue should have been more specific.
Are there Boost levels or supercharger rpm that are related to failure probability?
Do the failures happen shortly after high boost is applied, or only after a full minute at full boost?
The higher pressure that exists on "one side" of the rotors would tend to bow the rotors (perhaps insignificantly) and also bias the rotors in their available bearing clearance, although the gear reaction forces may be more significant. 15 psi applied over 32 square inches is about 500 lbs of force.

The folks that build GMC blowers for more severe use talk about being concerned with stuff like securing the rotors to the shafts, and end clearance adjustments that (due to the helical drive gears) change the rotor phasing and thus the rotor-to-rotor operating clearance.

Those same GMC folks talk about using different rotor/case clearances depending on whether fuel is passing thru the rotor mesh. This may support the water injection remedy, in addition to the detonation suppression benefit.
( GMC rotor to case clearance is adjusted by moving the rotor bearing housings up or down in the case, not with manufacturing tolerances )

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

tbuelna, ...The main source of efficiency loss with a Rootes blower is leakage past the rotor tips and sides....

The main inefficiency, even in a perfect Roots blower, is that the compression of air is a turbulent process. There is NO compression in the blower itself. The compression occurs with two turbulent flows, -first a burst flow from the pressurized manifold back into the atmospheric pressure volume between the lobe and housing as the lobe opens up to the pressurized manifold. Then, the two lobes mesh to squeeze air from the lobe space and pack it into the manifold, which is done without the benefit of an aerodynamic diffuser. Leakage adds inefficiency on top of this.
In contrast a centrifugal compressor can reach efficiencies in the high 80% range even without compressor to housing sealing because some compression occurs smoothly in the compressor itself while the remaining compression occurs smoothly in a well designed diffuser that converts gas velocity into static pressure.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

Talking about failure from rotor to case contact, how sensitive are these to mounting face flatness, bolt torque, and tightening sequence? On an eaton M90 you can lock the rotors up (or at least cause them to drag) with a cold blower being spun by hand if any of those things is a problem.

You might find it difficult to attribute that type of failure to only high temperatures. Is there room to fit water/air intercoolers on these? If so, more variables.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

(OP)
Tmoose you bring up some good points.
I some more pressing things to take care of but will post up in more detail when I get some time.
You bring up a great point about inspecting wear marks and it so happens that the SC I am working on right now does have more wear than most I have opened up. It also has significantly deeper scoring on the intake side supporting the theory that it has a lot to do with temps.
I have had probably 5 blowers apart. All still functional but all have had some scoring on the lobes and housing.

tbuelna

if you think about surface area the lobes will be exposed to ambient roughtly half the time or half the surface area at any given time.
The housing on the other hand has the entire exterior surface exposed to ambient temps and roughly half the interior surface. On top of that the sides of the lobes and inside the lobes will have some average between inlet and outlet temps. The SC housing will have both sides outside and half the side insides exposed to ambient. This means significantly more than 3/4s of the housing is exposed to ambient temps. This means that the housing will dissapate much more heat than the lobes will. The housing also has significantly more thermal mass so it will take longer to get up to it's peak temp.
These things all support the real world experiences of rotors contacting the housing.

I'll post up some pics and any new findings when I get some time.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

yoshimitsuspeed,

In your OP, you brought up the issue of the two-lobed Rootes type supercharger shown in the picture experiencing contact between the rotor tips and inner housing surface when operated to produce higher manifold pressure levels than it was originally designed for. In my opinion, the rotor tip/housing contact is likely caused by greater distortions in both the rotors and housing due to a combination of increased heat transfer rates and higher pressure loading.

With regards to simple TE changes due to higher charge air temps, what matters is the increase in temperature difference between the rotor and housing. If both components are constructed of a similar metal they should have similar linear TE rates, and if simple TE is causing the rotor to grow more than the housing ID then it would be logical to assume the rotor temp is rising more than the housing temp.

However, with distortion/shape changes in the rotor and housing due to temperature there are other important factors to consider, such as uneven temperatures within the part body and how the part is structurally constrained. The situation with the rotor is fairly straightforward. The rotating rotor faces are constantly exposed to alternating high/low air temps so the rotor body should have a uniform temperature. The rotor body also has only one structural constraint at its axis of rotation, so the part body is free to expand with temp increases and does not experience strain distortions. On the other hand, the housing has an uneven temperature distribution between the inlet and discharge faces. The housing is also more structurally constrained (mounting points, seal interfaces, etc), which can add to distortions in the housing from thermal expansion strain.

Lastly, there is the issue of greater structural deflections caused by higher pressure forces on the housing and rotors faces. The situation with a two-lobed Rootes rotor at high pressure delta can be tricky. Consider just how much net pressure force there is acting on the rotor. Even a medium displacement rotor at 1.5bar boost levels can experience close to half a ton of bending force. The increased pressure loads can also cause serious problems with the bearings supporting the rotors.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

(OP)
tbuelna
That is why I have been wondering about insulating the outside of the housing. This should keep more heat in and keep it more evenly distributed throughout the housing.
These blowers have a gap on the outlet side where the lobe gets further away from the compressor housing just before the lobe passes the port. The only reason I can think of this is to allow the pressure a little more time to equalize before it opens completely to the port. This also means there is enough room for a coating here without concern of interference so I have definitely decided I will coat this area with thermal barrier. This will reduce the amount of heat going into the hottest area of the housing.
I think I will do this as well as thermal barrier on the outside of the housing. These two things combined should help even out the temp throughout the housing and hopefully keep the housing temps more even as well as increasing the gap between the lobes and the housing.
I will also apply a dry film lubricant to the inside of the housing and the lobes to give it a little more gall and gouge resistance.

Beyond that I definitely agree that pre compressor injection will be the best solution for longevity.
My buddy was running his twincharged with the turbo feeding the SC and the SC running a pretty high pressure ratio with no intercooler between the turbo and SC but he was running Methanol pre SC and his housing and lobes looked great when I inspected them.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

(OP)
I'm curious where you get your numbers for the forces applied to the SC.
These rotors are probably about 25 square in across the broad face. At say 15 PSIG even when the rotor is straight up and down taking the majority of the force that would still only equate to 375 lbs of force being applied to it. As the rotors spin they will alternate between that and much less load when they are in different areas of their rotation.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

yoshimitsuspeed-

I have no idea what the projected area (LxD) of your Rootes supercharger rotor is, nor do I know what the pressure delta across the rotor is. I was simply providing an example of the influence of bending force created by the pressure delta across the rotor.

One other issue I would point out with regards to TE of the rotors causing contact with the housing ID surface due to higher operating temps, you should also see contact between the tips of each rotor and the root surface of the mating rotor, since the radial clearance between these surfaces should be similar to that between the rotor tips and inner housing surface.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

I have had Roots blown cars for many years. My current streetrod is a 41 Willys with a SBC 355 cu in with a 6-71 GMC blower. this car has over 25k miles on it now. It has been driven n weather from -5 F to 103 F (record high for the year). Needless t say that heat and AC were on full as required.

In building this one I looked at various coatings for the blower as well as the typical highly polished variants. I saw 3 polished blowers fail due to insufficient end clearance at the rear of the rotors and one fail due to case to rotor clearance. This prompted me to try to measure at least outside case temps. Very few of us have manifold temp gages so I'm lacking on this. Even the typical heat gun is not very accurate however at least it indicates considerable difference in temp from polished to natural finish. I elected to build my 6-71 with a sandblast finish and just live with the scruffy looks. You can't see it anyway unless I open the hood. Only the scoop shows. I've seen almost 100 degrees difference in case temp between mine and similar blower cars at some of the events I've attended. 2 750 carbs flush plenty of fuel thru it but I still get 14-15 mpg cruising.

Last summer I removed the blower to replace intake gaskets and inspected the inside of the blower. There are no marks anywhere that were not there on the original build. The blower is quite loose and is quite easily spun by hand. It will give 8 psi boost at very low rpm. About 3000 rpm. The water/alcohol injection seems to work very well controlling detonation. You can only step on this one about 5-6 seconds before vastly exceeding the highest speed limits so it is just an image car. I can't afford a ticket so I'm pretty careful with it. I drive it daily in all weather 3 seasons here in Minn.

You may just forgo coating the outside of the case and just sandblast it.

As a side note I tested my headers before and after Jet HOT coating. 850+ uncoated and 350 coated. It made a huge difference in under hood temps. A real plus is the headers do not rust at all.

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

BW2 - My buddy calls IR guns "random number generators" for a reason! You will not get a good number from a polished/plated surface unless it can be recalibrated for the proper emissivity. One trick around this is to put a piece of tape on the part - then you will be reading the tape's temp which should be almost the same. Rubber and painted surfaces are fine with the default calibration unless you have metal flake. ISZ

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

Hi IceStationZebra,

"My buddy calls IR guns "random number generators" ". That's pretty good. May I use it in future? I'll try to remember to give credit ech time.

Dan T

RE: Thermal management on roots type supercharger

Water/methanol injection ahead of the blower is the best of all worlds- even for an extreme-output port-fuel-injected engine. And there are now a few systems on the market which make installation seamless- with sophisticated control and metering based on load/temperature/RPM.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources