×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

(OP)
Hello everyone

I have been looking in to the required minimum burial depth of insulated pipes and I have become stuck.
I have read through the attached pdf however I am getting weird values (0.00034mm depth).

I have searched on-line for a while but no joy, there where a few pieces of information but none that fitted my requirements

Does anyone know of a formulae to calculate the minimum burial depth of an insulated pipe to avoid freezing?

Thank you for your time
Josh Man
Beng Mechanical engineering

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

It depends where you are.
You are working in Chapter 12, right?
Someone has supplied you with the soil conditions?
They should also have told you the depth of freezing.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Plymouth Tube

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

(OP)
wow what was a quick reply !!! thanks.

yes i am currently on page 12-14
using X = m(Ig)½ that expands in to using the correction coefficient, my main issue is how to calculate Ig?

The pipe will be buried in London and have to withstand the winter months.

when you say depth of freezing is that frost permeability?

Thanks
Josh

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

It’s a transient analysis problem. You can simplify the problem assuming the soil remains at constant temperature and proceed as follows:

α is the soil thermal diffusivity in [m2/s],
Tsurf is the soil surface temperature [°C],
Ti is the initial soil temperature [°C]
x is the depth of the water pipe [m]
t is the time the soil is exposed at Tsurf [s]
T(x,t) is the temperature at depth x and time t

[T(x,t) –Ti]/[Tsurf – Ti] = erf [x/(2sqrt(αt))]


Where erf is the error function (http://www.miniwebtool.com/error-function-calculat...)

You put T(x,t) = 0 °C and solve for x

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

For more details you can go for:

"Heat transfer a practical approach" by Yunus A. Cengel (2nd edition - McGraw - Hill):
4–3 Transient heat conduction in semi-infinite solids

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

(OP)
ione, thanks for the reply, this formula doesn't take the pipe insulation or is this the soil thermal diffusivity?

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

Joshua,

The value you get with the approach above is conservative as it doesn’t take into account pipe’s insulation.

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

(OP)
ione, again thanks for the response.

http://www.cdeep.iitb.ac.in/nptel/Mechanical/Heat%...

the link above is a similar calculation to yours.

how would I go about incorporating the pipes insulation values in this calculation?

Thanks
Josh

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

JoshuaMan,

There may be a much easier solution. I know that AWWA D100 has a figure which shows the minimum cover over buried pipe to avoid freezing. There may be a similar BS that covers the same material. Alternatively, you could look at weather conditions and select an similar US city and use that value as a starting point.

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

City of London standard drawing W-CS-68 shows that standard minimum depth of cover over water lines is 1.7 m (5.5 feet). Water line bury depth is usually a good indicator of maximum frost depth.
That detail shows the depth can be reduced to as little as 0.6 m (2 feet), when insulated with 3" thick by 4-ft wide insulation.
I'd think you could select annular insulation to allow as little as 2' bury also.

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

If you want to take into account the pipe insulation you could consider the whole scenario as a frost penetration problem in a multilayer medium. Assume just two layers: uniform soil and pipe insulation. It is still a transient problem, much more difficult than the one which considers just uniform soil with step change in temperature and I not aware about the existence of an analytical solution for this problem. Probably a finite element simulation is the way to go, anyway I have taken the liberty of attaching a technical report of the US Army Corps of engineers dated back 1957, where you can find some guidance about the way to approach the frost penetration in multilayer soils.  

File in next post...
 

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

(OP)
it worked this time, thank you.

i will have a read through, it looks very retro.

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

That method of estimating 1-D frost penetration in multi-layer soils is essentially how London came up with those depth of bury/insulation guidelines. Tempered with experience. They account for 2-d effects by varying the insulation width.

There's been a lot of advances since that old Corps paper. Alaska DOT offers a free dos-based program to solve this, called "BERG2". Even that program is 20 or so years old. It is most useful for determining insulation of roadways, doesn't apply well to narrow elements like pipes.

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

Thanks to the Eng Tips staff who have fixed my previous post

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

(OP)
hi guys

thanks for all the responses, I think I have worked it out.....

I have calculated the depth of pipe with no insulation, I have then calculated the temperature of the OD of the pipe and worked out the heat loss with the insulation.

I have then done the same calculation using the thermal diffusion for the insulation and taken the insulation depth from the non insulation depth.

hopefully this is done correctly?

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

If i were you i would go with CarlBs methodology. A city like London has been there for more than a 1000 years, so their standard will most likely be pretty optimised taking everything into account. But then again i cant see that you mentioned whats in the pipes.

RE: Minimum burial depth of insulated pipe to avoid freezing (moving fluid)

(OP)
hi guys

I have used the formulae from the link below, I have then calculated the outer casing temperature and then used this value to calculate the time taken to fully penetrate the PU foam and used the values to calculate the minimum depth after a specified time period - the time taken to penetrate the insulation of the pipe, sorry if I haven't explained this too well.

http://www.cdeep.iitb.ac.in/nptel/Mechanical/Heat%...

attached is my attempt :/ if some one would like to have a quick scan to see if I have made any major mistakes it would be appreciated guys.

Cheers
Josh

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources