×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Structure in Canada

Structure in Canada

Structure in Canada

(OP)
We're bidding on structures in Canada that will be fabricated in the U.S. so we will be using U.S. procured steel such as ASTM A36, A992, and A500 Gr B. The minimum temperature at the site is -45C. These will be unheated, sometimes open structures (think pipe racks). I'm concerned these steels won't be suitable for this low of a temperature, so my first questions is have these steels been used successfully at this temperature? Are there supplements we should specify to make them suitable? If we bought steel that met Canadian specs. (whatever is equivalent to ASTM) would that simplify things since I presume low temperature is just a given up there? Are there other structural steels for wide flanges and HSS sections available in the U.S. that would be more suitable?

I know it's a lot of questions. I'm just trying to foresee some options. Thanks.

RE: Structure in Canada

The canadian steel grade standard is CSA G40.

That being said. We often find ourselves using US designated steel due to availability. I cannot see the change in grade being a huge deal as long as the designer is aware prior to fabrication.

We for standard rolled shapes we use 350W steel yield strength 350 MPa, Ultimate strength 450 MPa.

If your designer has accounted for the major temperature swings then I cannot see you having any problems.

RE: Structure in Canada

I'm assuming you're in Fort McMurray or Fort St John if you're doing pipe racks at that temperature.

It depends what your loading looks like. For outdoor industrial structures we'll often use standard grade steel, but you start to see these steels acting in a much more brittle way when you start drifting a bit below freezing. This isn't wonderful in normal service but it becomes critical in fatigue and impact scenarios. Your fatigue service life with normal grade steel drops significantly once you get into these temperature ranges and you run the risk of a brittle fracture under impact loads.

So at a minimum, I'd normally specify a 350WT or other WT grade steel for critical areas of structures that see this kind of loading (including lifting lugs and maybe other members that could see an impact high in their stress range during lifting). It ensures you don't have a material that will see a brittle fracture in cold conditions. Some owners actually have specifications that call for this in all outdoor structures that see below a certain temperature, but that's somewhat rare in my experience.

So depending on whether you're planning on seeing a lot of vibration, or if you've got transient loads you're restraining, or have other similar load conditions there may be areas you want to consider this failure mechanism and maybe look at alternate materials.

Basically, it's a steel that has the normal requirements for a weldable grade structural steel with additional charpy impact test requirements.

RE: Structure in Canada

For outside cold critical stuff TLHS has the material right on... G40.21-350WT is what we would normally use... 350 MPa, aka Grade 50...

Dik

RE: Structure in Canada

(OP)
Lokstr, what do you mean by "all the time"? This is in a region where the record low temperature is -45C, so no, I wouldn't say that is all the time. In other words, it's not some process that is keeping the steel cool but rather ambient conditions. I'm use to designing in the sunny south so I'm not familiar with the Canadian code. Does it provide any guidance when to use tougher steel (like 350WT)?

Thanks for the answers so far. Very helpful. I'm still curious about using steel that conforms to US standards. Anybody use that in Canada?

RE: Structure in Canada

A record low of -45C is comparable to the record low in many of the states "down there".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._state_temperatur...

Note that many record low temperature are below -45C, so there should be some US standards that cover this.

It is not unheard of in Canada to use ASTM to specify material. I think the fabricator should be able to determine which are equivalent.

I'm not familiar with the US codes, but I suspect the difference in final design would be minor/subtle if you did two different designs with the Canadian vs US codes/standards...maybe someone who uses both codes on a regular basis could comment on that.

RE: Structure in Canada

(OP)
Hmm, you make a good point, Caneit. Maybe that was average low in the coldest month.

RE: Structure in Canada

There's nothing wrong with using american steels as long as you've designed for them. I'm sure you can find a charpy tested steel in the states somewhere too if you need it. You will have to design to the Canadian code, so be careful because all the tables and things are calibrated to common Canadian steels. It's pretty similar to the AISC stuff, but there are little differences hiding here and there so you can't just design to AISC and say it's equivalent.

Also, be careful at interfaces where some things are done in the American shop and some are done at the Canadian site. Also, check your contract with the owner and any design specs they have. They may have specs that require Canadian certifications for various things, which could get you into trouble. Remember that if you're doing things like site welding you'll be using Canadian welders with Canadian certifications and materials. If you're doing concrete foundations are you using Canadian or American steel?

On an unrelated note, watch that you leave space for thermal expansion on pipe racks up there. The swing in temperature over the year is easily -40 to +35 Celcius and then unpainted steel can heat up an extra 10 to 15 degrees no problem.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources