×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

I am currently watching a DOT press conference.

Here is what has been said:

A double hammerhead pier settled about 28".

The pier is supported on 40 piles.

It will be interesting to see what happened--how can a pier supported on piles settle???

DaveAtkins

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Sink Hole or an old cavern below? Geotechs will tell us...

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Only took 30+ years to start settling

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Kinda like the economy, huh?

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

This also seems like drastic settlement to be any less than a sinkhole. 28" in under 24 hours? Especially after that many years in service.

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

"The bridge is not in any danger of collapse," state Department of Transportation Secretary . . . .

The department needs to determine what happened, determine if any other part of the bridge is at risk . . . .

Hmmmmm.

It is better to have enough ideas for some of them to be wrong, than to be always right by having no ideas at all.

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

I found that comment about no danger of collapse funny as well. If that kind of movement isn't predicating collapse I don't know what is.

We had a bridge pier fail here in however it was due to riverbank slope failure and the shearing of pre-cast hex piles. The government wasn't stupid enough to make comments like that in our case though.

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Thanks for the link imminentcollapse.

I'm on the other side of the world but I like to see these things when they happen. It does seem strange to have such an instant settlement occur so quickly. I'm not intimate with the details but I would raise punching shear of the pier cap. Glad that no-one was hurt.

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

They showed the top of the pile cap on local TV (I live in Green Bay), and there was no evidence of piles punching up through the pile cap. The soil on the side of the pile cap looked like a perfect vertical wall of clay.

DaveAtkins

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

I've been thinking about going to a Packer or Cheesehead joke here, but none comes to mind.

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Does anyone know if the piles were end bearing or friction? If end bearing, what type of rock is common in this area? Is it soluble?

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Maybe they found Jimmy Hoffa's grave?

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

OK, I'll bite.

What are the special structural considerations of a foundation involving bearing on Karst?

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Karst = sinkholes and caverns. Karst landscape normally has lots of conical depressions.

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Makes a lot of sense here...

Thanks Hokie...

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

I think with Karst... the only way to check is to drill down to a depth you are comfortable with to see if there is a 'hole'... I don't know if GPR is good enough for deep foundations...

Dik

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Also Karst can get worse with time. The rock dissolves and the cavities get larger.

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Sounds like a large cavity. Time to call in a Dentist.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

The bedrock in SW Wisconsin is a group called Sinippee or similar name. The upper part formation is called Platteville Dolomite. Many problems with the rock there.

This map shows that same rock is under the Green Bay area. In my experience in souith-west Wisconsin we have drilled a bunch of quarry holes at the bottom of significant foundations (such as water towers) to look for weak stuff below. Sometimes, under pretty good rock there are cavities and crevices filled with soft clay, sometimes the end product of weathering. A few caves have been found. Apparently the steel piles were founded on bedrock, but it is unlikely any test hole was drilled at that pier, at least into rock any distance. Apparently rock is 100 feet down.

http://wisconsingeologicalsurvey.org/bdrk.htm

I'll betcha many a core drill hole is coming up, up and down the alignment.

Now let's cogitate about what to do with the questionable areas? Flush out the clay and grout? Jack the pile cap back up and test each pile? Gosh what a discussion can be had on this fix?

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

If one went bad, the others must be checked as well. Considering the cost of a replacement structure where the same thing would have to be done, they might as well do exploratory drilling at each and every existing pier.

Then comes the fun stuff. Questions:

Could the pier be raised hydraulically by pressurized grouting? Probably not...

Stabilize the pier for gravity forces, jack up the bridge to the original level, and add a new metal structure to the top of the pier?

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Jed: Soft limestone may be to blame, soft like the Packers' defense thus far, which results in a bend but don't break philosophy. They need to get Raaji and Mathews to lift up the pile via deadlift while pressure grouting under the pile.

msquared: They may be able to use pressure grouting to get some lift, it is what we use to remediate sinkhole activity in Florida and does a good job of sealing off cavities in the limestone and filling and compacting any loose sandy soils. At a minimum, I would not be surprised if they did this to at least fill any cavities or loose zones that may have caused the failure. Lift would depend on the grout pressure they could develop versus the resistance of the pile (bridge load, skin friction, etc). Grout may just blow out laterally or vertically prior to developing enough pressure to get any appreciable uplift. These are my guesses, I don't have specific grouting under piles knowledge but I think in theory it could work. They may just have to grout to seal and stabilize the bottom of the pile and then fix the structure on the top side...

Hokie:
My boss is a PhD geologist and said that the type of dolomite, shale and limestone in that part of Wisconsin is VERY old and usually very weathered, hard and dense, and is not normally subject to dissolution and weakening mechanisms the way it occurs with Florida's limestone (we are a Florida based geology and engineering company). BUT- it is possible there was a cavity or soft zone in the rock, and they will obviously have to confirm with testing.





RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

If the people in the area are inconvenienced now by the bridge closure, wait until that pipeline gets shut down and fuel becomes scarce.

Several years ago a pipeline into Phoenix broke and it became a nightmare to fill up until it was repaired.

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

Quote (orgerynusk)

"The bridge is not in any danger of collapse," state Department of Transportation Secretary . . . .

Sure, the bridge is fine-- if you're the Duke Brothers.

"We shape our buildings, thereafter they shape us." -WSC

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

“This does not indicate the rest of the bridge is in danger of collapse,” he said. “These foundations, these piles, have huge safety factors on them so if one pile fails there are 39 others to support the bridge.”

So I take it that each of the 51 or so piers has 40 pile supporting it? With a failure of this magnitude, across the whole pier line, it appears to me that all 40 pile collapsed within a few hours, not just one. Where is this guy coming from?

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

According to the article posted above, the culprit may be foundry sand.

I wonder if all of this will make us rethink how we design pile supported foundations. The corrosion and buckling of 40 steel piles all at once is something I never dreamed could happen. Probably corrosion had already compromised many of the piles, and collapse occurred when the last few remaining piles corroded.

DaveAtkins

RE: I-43/Fox River Bridge Green Bay

As of today (Saturday the 5th) a couple of recent TV videos are on line. Looks like a soil scientist is involved as to chemistry. I hope they also look at roadway de-icing that probably results in that salty water at each pier near a scupper outlet.

http://www.fox11online.com/

As to ground conditions and corrosion, highway design engineers (not the bridge section designers) know about that problem and pave the inverts of corrugated culverts in peaty areas. In my experience at the WiDOT years ago, there were obvious waterproof walls between various sections, such as maintenance, bridge, construction, etc. Little kingdoms develop and it is difficult to get any changes or to have any one even listen. For instance, what bridge design manual covers the pH of soil as something to look at? Who ever from construction division goes back and checks for corrosion . Maintenance guys struggle with what is dealt them in many ways from bridges to roadways. Farming design work out to consultants can be even more difficult for down the road checking of performance getting back to designers.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources