×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

(OP)
Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)


Hello All,

I am trying to determine the best method to analyze an existing metal connected wood truss to determine if there is any additional capacity left for rooftop installations. Are there any publications out there outline this analysis?

In most cases I won’t have any truss manufacturer specs or drawings.

I was considering just modeling the truss, applying DL’s and anticipated live loads (as per local code), determining reactions, and member forces. Once I have that I can determine stress in the material, but I know that there are other factors to consider other than just member stress,

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

That's how I do it, calculate the tension in the chord and make sure it's less than the capacity. Compression of the chords have a bit more capacity as long as they are restrained. Calculate the deflections and probably add 10% to allow for the nail slip. Check the shear transfer thru the metal side plates as well.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

I recently spoke with one of the author of the NDS Specification about this same topic. His response was that since these products are proprietary (the metal plates) , there is no way of knowing its capacity. He said the only way to properly evaluate this type of structure is to go through the manufacturer. I would check out the Truss Plate Institute and see if they have any recommendations. Goodluck!

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

Good luck with that. Any design drawing will likely be unrecoverable. And most tech's working for Truss manufacturer's will not be engineers despite the fact that the are generating design documents and workshop drawings without understanding the engineering principles that go with them.

In Australia, there are truss manufacturers like Mitek and Pryda that have published capacities for metal side plates so I would have a look at those.

This sounds like a high liability risk application that you are working on. As soon as you rate it for a higher load than the original intended use than you are essentially taking on the responsible for the truss design.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

(OP)
I am trying to determine if we can add about 4-6 psf to the roof. It is def getting frustrating trying to find info. I have purchased a few publications with no luck.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

I don't know how large this truss is or how many of them there are, but you can possibly design another connection (spanning over the current connection) to take just the increase in load. Should be a small connection if the increase is only 6 psf. Seems like a solution that is probably unnecessary, but I can't think of any other approach.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

(OP)
The number and size can vary a bit. Currently I am trying to analyze a Fink truss, 2x4 members, 2ft OC, 24ft span.

When you say to design another connection, what exactly are you thinking by connection?

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

aggie7's detail works.

here we generally just use a square(ish) plywood gusset both sides with clinched nails. Especially for the ~300 lbs total that the truss is going to see, that's like sweet bugger all. 1/2" plywood with a couple nails into each member would cover that.

If it is only a small number of trusses that need reinforcing then this method is what we found to be easiest and cheapest.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

I work with some people who do wood truss analysis/reinforcing and the joints are always the problem (as others have said). The method you describe for analysis is pretty what they do as well. They have managed to secure different metal plate capacities from somewhere. How many "teeth" are engaged and the depth of engagement is critical to the metal plates.

One other source you may want to look at is the IEBC. I believe they allow an increase of 5% in stress before you need to take dramatic members. This may help you eliminate the need to reinforce all of the members/joints in the truss.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

Be careful of mixed fastener connections.

My 2001 NDS (I do not have the later ones here at home)section 10.1.4 states "Methods of analysis and test data for establishing design values for connections made with more than one type of fastener have not been developed. Design values for mixed fastener connections shall be based on tests or other analysis (see 1.1.1.3)"

Usually the critical slip of one type on connector is greater or less than the other so you have the existing or the new connection taking a larger amount of the load than calculated.

Garth Dreger PE - AZ Phoenix area
As EOR's we should take the responsibility to design our structures to support the components we allow in our design per that industry standards.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

I've been there. I feel your pain. I try to do one or more of the following.

Plan A: See if the original Truss Design Drawings are available from the owner or building department.
Plan B: Take photos of the plates, sketch the truss, and see if the Mitek or Alpine engineer's will run an analysis for you. They will recognize their own plates and have been helpful in the past in similar situations.
Plan C: Establish a relationship with a local truss manufacturer and truss technician who can run an analysis for you based on your directions (plate sizes, loads, grade, etc). This will not be an engineered analysis since it will not go back to Mitek HQ for seals but it is still better than running it yourself. Insist on paying them a flat amount or hourly for the analysis time so they don't get tired of you. Join the local WTCA/SBC/TPI chapter and make some friends at the local industry meetings if you will be doing this regularly.
Plan D: Do a 2D analysis of the truss for member forces. Then do a shear check on the plates. This can be reliable for single span trusses. The member forces for multispan trusses are highly dependent on stiffness matrices and loading patterns. I'm not as confident in the results for those conditions.
Plan E: Share the load between nearby trusses with strongbacks or structural curbs until you are satisfied that the stress from the new superimposed load is below a reasonable threshold (5% is pretty conservative).
Plan F: Reinforce the truss with gussets, sistering, etc.

Good Luck

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

In regard to mixed fasteners. I would assume he is designing the new connection for all of the load. Therefore if the existing (already stressed) connector begins to fail, the new connector carries all the load.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

(OP)
Besides manually analyzing these, are there any good, yet cheap, programs out there? I have flirted with buying Engersoll (spelling?) 2D Truss analysis, but is there anything else out there?

I would have to ahve to sit and analyze this stuff by hand.

Thanks again for all of the good info.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

Sorry. That is the link for TRUSS4. I'm not sure what that costs but it looks like it includes a connection plate analysis of some kind.

I am looking at the demo for Truss2D (Engisssol) and it is about $100 for the full program. It is a simple frame/truss analysis app.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

(OP)
Been looking and reading about how to design new connections or analyze existing plates (almost impossible) with little luck.

Any direction on how to go about designing the plate thickness and fastner arrangement?

Right now I am trying to analyze a metal connected truss, but I also come across wood gusset truss connections.

Thanks all

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

It is relatively easy to analyze a determinate truss using a spreadsheet. We re-engineered an entire building-worth of floor and roof trusses with two or three spreadsheets (and lots of data entry, since they were often skewed and varied in length.)

If you have a good contractor, as we did, you can support the truss, peel old plates and install new ones using a field press. On floor trusses, this was an excellent solution to undersized plates. On larger attic trusses, we used square/rectangular plywood gussets (3/4") and bolts. This was required because our experience told us that we would have no luck getting enough nails into the right places without splitting and splintering the members.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

(OP)
Where I am stuck is the methodology behind the design of the gussett. Usually small residential applications.

Need to determine the wood thickness, then number of nails, and then pattern of nailing (or screwing)

Any Ideas how you designed the plates and nailing pattern (that you didn't use)

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

TX - couple of questions in regards to your response:
1. Could you provide some further info on the field press?
2. Why couldn't you use it for the attic trusses?
Thanks!

EIT
www.HowToEngineer.com

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

charliealphabravo - That is a good source of basic information on repairing trusses.

Garth Dreger PE - AZ Phoenix area
As EOR's we should take the responsibility to design our structures to support the components we allow in our design per that industry standards.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

(OP)
Charlie, Thanks for the reference.

I get how he is designing the plywwod gussett, but I can't seem to figure out where he is getting his panel design values of 467 lb/in/pair, and 208 lb/in/pair?

Maybe I'm looking at it wrong somehow? I am stumped? Feel really dumb right now! ha

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

It me sometime to figure this one out when I came across it as well so don't feel bad.
Here is my shot at it:

Download APA's 2008 Panel Design Spec (aka Form D510C I believe).

1. If you look at table 5 for 1/2" sheathing you can get 24/0, 24/16 and 32/16 Rated panels.
2. Look at table 4A -> Panel Axial Tension Ft -> for 32/16 rated the allowable is 2800 lb per foot of panel width
3. Convert that to lb per in of panel width -> 2800/12 = 233.33 lb per in of panel
4. multiply by 2 for each side -> 2*233 = 467 lb per in per pair.

Now how we were suppose to know to use 32/16 rated sheathing I'm not sure as it was not stated but it is the only one that works.

EIT
www.HowToEngineer.com

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

If you look at figure 5: Finalized repair, in the article, it states the grade of the plywood.

Garth Dreger PE - AZ Phoenix area
As EOR's we should take the responsibility to design our structures to support the components we allow in our design per that industry standards.

RE: Analyzing an existing wood truss (metal plate)

(OP)
Thanks guys. I focused so much on trying to do teh math that I didn't even really read the specs on figure 5!

Thanks again.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources