×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

The materials less traveled

The materials less traveled

The materials less traveled

(OP)
I was wondering what were some alternative materials used in engine block construction other than the typical Iron and Aluminum. In particular I was doing research into the TVR Speed Twelve Engine. I am sure TVR utilized Aluminum heads and while the heads would suffer from Galvanization corrosion if they came into contact. I was wondering if the microscopic flakes of steel floating in coolant passages will negatively affect the aluminum heads in the long run. I would also like to know if anyone had tried something similar in developing a Steel alloy engine block like the Speed 12 and if their are anymore information on the engine construction process.

RE: The materials less traveled

The first thing that came to mind was the Crosley CoBra, which was copper- brazed from steel sheet. ... and had corrosion problems, probably not because of the presence of aluminum.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crosley


I recall reading about someone who intended to use the same technology, brazed steel sheet, to make a much larger engine for boat racing. ... but I haven't seen reference to it anywhere in the decades since.

Note that steel is basically just iron with less carbon than cast iron, so it should behave similarly. ... except at the piston bores, where I'd expect a steel block to have severe wear problems absent iron liners or exotic coatings. I didn't find much detail on the TVR engine; I'm guessing it's simply cast steel, not sheet.

Iron blocks with aluminum heads have been used commercially for many years. Most of the problems encountered had to do with head gasket leaks, not corrosion, so if TVR is not too proud to copy technology from Chevrolet, they should be okay on that front.



Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: The materials less traveled

Aren't the NASCAR 'cup' series engines all using composite-something-or-other blocks for a few years now? I know nothing about their cylinder liners.

RE: The materials less traveled

Similar to the Crosley engine the Mercedes Benz M196 engine (from the famous W196 car) had a built up/welded cylinder block and heads on a aluminium crankcase. I think MB changed to a conventional cast block engine later on.

RE: The materials less traveled

I guess I was remembering wrong.
Doing a 'net search, the most recent item I found (2011) was an announcement by Composite Castings LLC of Florida, regarding a carbon-fiber block for an inline four cylinder (Ford?) that's apparently used much in racing. Not finding more-recent posts about the block doesn't lend encouragement for learning that it was successful.

RE: The materials less traveled


I was thinking, trying to remember articles in Car Craft or Hot Rod about plastic engines, maybe back in the '80s, and managed to dredge up Polimotor. Plenty of Google hits for that.

Here is a link to the 1982 Popular Science in which it is said Ford was backing Matty Holtzberg's first venture, Polimotor
http://books.google.com/books/about/Popular_Scienc...

In This Autoweek article Matty says Ford "actually contributed nothing."
http://www.automobilemag.com/green/news/0911_plast...

On page 140 of that issue of Pop Sci the late great Smokey Yunick has an interesting comment about the status of US emission controlled engines, among other things.

RE: The materials less traveled

(OP)
Thanks for the reply guys, I have been looking into alternative materials for engine production particular Steel. However TVR doesn't seem willing to release any information on their V12 engine besides what seems to be the mythical Steel alloy EN14T. I've looked around and can't seem to find any material that matches that besides EN14a.

On a side note the plastic engine is very interesting but I'm skeptical of it's durability in the long run. On Average many car owners don't take as good care of their vehicles as they should. I know I'm guilty of that sometimes. And I'm skeptical of plastic begin durable enough to withstand the type of temperatures needed to live in the automotive combustion zone. In example, if the engine starts to run low on oil, the reinforced plastic conrods are going to have to be able to withstand those temps for possibly 20-40 miles. That's a lot to ask for. However, for such things like oil pans and heads with the metal valve tunnels and such might be doable.

RE: The materials less traveled

I believe cosworth had an engine made of UHMW plastic years back that did quite well?

RE: The materials less traveled

Ceramic engine block?

RE: The materials less traveled

Plastics are creeping into engine design, maybe a few design wins per decade, including I think:
-water pump impellers
-timing sprockets
-valve covers
-valley covers
-vacuum tubing
-belt guards
-external accessory brackets
-radiator fans
-air filter housings
-acoustic covers
-accessory valves, e.g. EGR control valves
-radiator header tanks

Not all applications have been resounding successes, and some have been an embarrassment multiple times.

Indicators include combining parts to eliminate, snap fits for quick assembly, complex shapes as easy to produce as simple ones, chemical resistance.

Contraindicators include heat, cost of tooling and cost of resin.

About the cost of resin, ISTR that Torlon and similar high performance resins are obscenely expensive, but I've never quite understood why they remained so, while being available for decades. Is it that scaling up production is so capital-intensive that nobody will front the money, or is some basic resource limiting, or does the process also produce toxic waste or other costly and unmanageable byproduct, or is the yield of good product just pitiful, or what?

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: The materials less traveled

Plastic has also made it into intake manifolds.

RE: The materials less traveled

Thank you.
Both of my current vehicles have plastic intake manifolds, as do many contemporary vehicles. I'd have to call that a successful application.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: The materials less traveled

When today's cars are antiques, restoring them properly will be impossible because the plastic parts will have rotted away, so craftsmen will be faced with making sand molds for intake manifolds and then finishing the resulting aluminum casting to look like plastic.

... Okay, maybe additive manufacturing will be up to the task by then.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: The materials less traveled

@ Mike, some people are making good money at that already,,

Brian,

RE: The materials less traveled

"When today's cars are antiques, restoring them properly will be impossible"

It may the exact opposite. Your kids' kids will probably be in a world where pretty much every home has a 3D printer; and the CAD files will be open sourced for downloading. Of course, IC cars may be banned completely by then, so restoration is moot winky smile

TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

Need help writing a question or understanding a reply? forum1529: Translation Assistance for Engineers

RE: The materials less traveled

As long as the kids dont turn into screen gazing/touch screen zombies then we will be ok. The movie ''Idiocracy'' seems possible though,

Brian,

RE: The materials less traveled

Mike, can you visualize a rusted hulk of an antique car found in a barn somewhere with the metal parts all corroded away while the plastic parts are as good as new? I think most current plastics are damaged only by UV and chemicals. They have half lives in the 10s or 100ds of thousand years in a normal, but UV protected environment.

RE: The materials less traveled

Really early plastics like Bakelite and celluloid are indeed durable.
Less ancient plastics like nylon and delrin are somewhat less so.
More modern formulations are much less so.

<limited data>
I watched my 1970 Mercedes turn into a rusted hulk in my carport while waiting for the engine to cure itself of a crack. ... never happened, and I never found the actual crack. ... but that's a metal problem. ... well, actually, it's a fluorescently stupid machine design, but that's another issue.

The nylon power brake vacuum tube fractured of its own accord when the car was only five years old. After 30 years, the heater control handles, which looked like molded black Delrin but were a little rubbery, had crumbled to dust, like polyurethane does, at least like it does in SoFla.
</limited data>

Basically, it appears to me that any plastic resin containing an elastomer alloy component, or a plastcizer, or an impact modifier, is going to have a limited useful life; it will get brittle and crack, even absent UV or solvents. Except for urethanes, it will still be identifiable in a landfill, but it will not be capable of performing its intended mission after a few decades.





Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: The materials less traveled

Mike, I think your "limited data" may be a German thing. Porsches, VWs, et al have plastics that seem to be formulated to self-destruct at right around 20 - 25 years, and not just crack, they totally crumble. My visor clips crumbled like cornbread within days of each other. I wonder if it isn't some "green" thing?

On the other hand, my '52 Ford truck still has original plastic knobs and such that have weathered the high desert (ozone- and UV-rich) environment while barely fading. (They aren't bakelite, either) But there is precious little plastic to begin with.

BTW, to the original topic, Ford made V8's in the early '30's that had sheet metal sides on the blocks, riveted on as I recall. Not entirely a successful idea, but I'm sure it made coring the molds a breeze.

RE: The materials less traveled

I believe Germany has a government mandated disassembly/ recycle program that pretty much requires post-consumer content in new cars and also requires labeling individual parts with a type code for the resin.

... but I don't think that's responsible for the crumbling plastics; I think the German engineers just sort of prefer 'high performance' materials of all kinds, and in the case of plastics, that means they're working with essentially no real historical data when they specify the latest/greatest. They need to spend more time in junkyards...



Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: The materials less traveled

I remember a show when I was younger called "Beyond Tomorrow." One of the episodes dealt in part with an engine that was made from ceramic. I distinctly recall the host lugging the engine block onto a table and then talking about it, but it was a long time ago and I don't remember much else. I want to say that it was a big-three prototype, and since we still haven't seen ceramic blocks, it either didn't work or answered a question nobody had asked.

RE: The materials less traveled

Mike, interesting comment about junk yard time. When my one time employer was looking to change master cylinders from cast iron to aluminum, a couple of engineers scoured the junkyards and obtained aluminum master cylinders from the various makes and models. Then we did a lot of analysis to identify the base alloys and protective coatings employed.

RE: The materials less traveled

Re scouring junkyards, learning from someone else's mistakes can be a really good investment.


Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: The materials less traveled

Further to the Merc.W 196 engine being "built up" I have a very good set of photographs of the W196[in a magazine]appears to fabricated but what I thought to ask was the cylinder liners have 1000,s of those little speck "holes" on the running surface, I mistakenly thought those somehow connected with the "Nikrasil" process [spelling] and then saw them again in some Porsche barrels. Purpose?lube retention perhaps? BTY plastic parts in VW cars in sunny RSA not doing too well, seems as said in previous posts that UV or something is causing failure. Seem to recall a soft covered book on how to fabricate an engine, sorry age and therefore memory are fading hope this is not too far off the subject.

RE: The materials less traveled

I remember, back around 1989/90, reading a car magazine article, which demonstrated why the science hitherto known as metallurgy, was being renamed materials science. I suppose it's merely an evolutionary labelling process that began with the shaman, and worked it's way across alchemy.

In addition to the aforementioned Nikasil process, it claimed that Honda were working with various non-metallic additives to their Aluminium blocks. I cannot recall if they specifically pointed to carbon or ceramic "fibers" being an admixture in the casting material.

Best,
B.

RE: The materials less traveled

ceramic blocks or at least ceramic bushing.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources