×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar
5

ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

(OP)
Is it possible to compress ethane from 21 bar to 120 bar in one compression stage??

More overall, in your thoughts it is better to transport ethane in gas phase or dense phase? which one is more practical and common?
What are the operating pressure and temperature??

Thank you for your time :)

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

Too much ratio for one stage in a recip. You'll run into discharge temperature issues and/or discharge volumetric efficiency problems. Needs two stages.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

Your mass flow should be sufficient to be handled by a centrifugal compressor first. Then consider that very low to low mass flow with centrifugal will lead to poor efficiency and affect the discharge temperature.

Your suction temperature should stay below a certain limit so that you don't get a too high discharge.
At the same time you should have also sufficient margin to dew point before entering the compressor. It depends from the gas composition: is it a pure Ethane, does it contain some heavy hydrocarbons etc. ?

Assuming pure Ethane, dew point temperature at 20 bar suction pressure should be around -10 deg C or so. With an inlet gas temperature to compressor of 10-15 deg C, it maybe doable with one compression (thermodynamic) stage depending on poly-tropic efficiency of the compressor.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

Hope some specialist of pumps will provide feedback and share their experience on ethane transportation in Liquid phase so we have an idea as well of the typical operating conditions (pump inlet temperature and pressure for example).

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

2
1) pure ethane has a critical pressure of about 48.7 Bar.a , at 120 Bar.a you are well above critical point

2) supposing you have to design a pipeline at about ambient temperature (to avoid expensive insulation) and assuming fluid temperature of 15 C (about 288 K) the density of pure ethane at 120 Bar.a and 288 K would be about 422 Kg/M3 (values calculated with PRODE PROPERTIES, extended Peng Robinson model),
that value (422) looks not too different from the density of a liquid phase

3) by solving a single polytropic stage for pure ethane, polytropic efficiency 0.75 and pin 20 Bar.a Tin 270 K, Pout 120 Bar.a the calculated temperature (again with PRODE PROPERTIES and Peng Robinson extended) is about 400 K which makes the single stage design difficult, however there are other equipments as for example screws which perhaps could do the work but you should consult an expert in this field to see if it's a practicable solutiion.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

Quoted
3) by solving a single polytropic stage for pure ethane, polytropic efficiency 0.75 and pin 20 Bar.a Tin 270 K, Pout 120 Bar.a the calculated temperature (again with PRODE PROPERTIES and Peng Robinson extended) is about 400 K which makes the single stage design difficult, however there are other equipments as for example screws which perhaps could do the work but you should consult an expert in this field to see if it's a practicable solutiion.
Unquoted

Assuming 75 % poly efficiency as you did and an inlet temperature of 15 deg C, a discharge temperature of 165-170 deg C is still descent for a centrifugal and therefore a single stage will possible without too much issues.

We need to know if the gas composition contains pure ethane and what is the flow involved.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

(OP)
Dear Apetri
Thank you for your time.

Dear rotaryworld :)
The gas contains about 99% methane and the flow rate is about 400000 tons per year.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

''99% methane''
Is it Methane or Ethane ??

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

Ethene, Ethane, Ethylene???

Independent events are seldomly independent.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

(OP)
Ethane, I'm sorry.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

ok Ethane.
The problem is not your 99% but the remaining 1%.
Heavy hydrocarbon may shift the dew point line.

Assuming (lot of assumptions here) we stay with the pure ethane dew point curve, it should be feasible with a small centrifugal.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

(OP)
The remaining 1 perc is .95 Methane and .05 Propane. The assumptions are right!

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

you may contact Dresser

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

At 15 C the discharge temp will be 203C at 75% polytropic eff. To hot for most compressors, the cost of the special compressor would not justify going to a two stage unit. As for the 1% other, its a nonevent, that 1% won't do anything, even if it were C8.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

dcasto,
out of curiosity, how have you calculated those values ?
for pure ethane,
single polytropic stage with polytropic eff. 75%
tin 15 C pin 20 Bar.a
pout 120 bar.a
I get a tout of about 149 C
(about 50 C less)

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

Prode (with Peng Robinson) calculates 149 C as tout
(Pin 20 Bar.a tin 15 C , Pout 120 Bar.a)

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar


quoted
As for the 1% other, its a nonevent, that 1% won't do anything, even if it were C8.
Unquoted

not agree..

running 1% with and without heavy hydrocarbon here
http://www2.questconsult.com/cgi-bin/jrm_dewbub

6 = Isopentane, C5H12 0.3%
7 = n-Pentane, C5H12 0.3%
8 = n-Hexane, C6H14 0.3%

Calculating dew point temperature at 2000.0 kPa absolute.
The dew point temperature is 284.3 degrees Kelvin.

6 = Isopentane, C5H12 0.0%
7 = n-Pentane, C5H12 0.0%
8 = n-Hexane, C6H14 0.0%


Calculating dew point temperature at 2000.0 kPa absolute.
The dew point temperature is 265.9 degrees Kelvin.


enough delta to compromise single stage option
I don't want to try in the commercial software, I know it be the same outcome

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

the mixture given by mamed

C2 0.99
C1 0.0095
C3 0.0005

shows little difference at 20 Bar.a from bubble (-8.895) to dew (-7.408 C) lines
in this case the impact of light components (C1, C3) is limited.

Of course if you add small fractions of heavy components as C7 and above thinks would be different.

However in some cases it could be acceptable to have a very limited amount of liquid
entering the compressor providing it doesn't generate mechanical problems
(one should ask the manufacturer for a specific simulation),

we have had a compressor working with very small liquid fractions without problems.

from process simulation point of view,
you can solve polytropic stages with any amount of liquid
(polytropic stage with phase equilibria),
I have used this option (available in PRODE) to model screw compressors,
you can even solve a pump (liquid in, liquid out) as polytropic stage.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

Yes the composition is in our hand and the impact is limited. Clear.
But something posted above seems to mean that 1% will not matter "Anyhow". We know now that this is not true.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

I used peng Robinson

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

dcasto,
I woonder why there is that large difference in results, about 12% (203-150)/(150+273) or 50 C in calculated temperatures,
where 150 C has been calculated with Peng Robinson and Huntigton method,
are you using the simplified GPSA equation ?

Tout = Tin*(Pout / Pin)**(k-1)/k

that may give those values.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

No I'm using a process simulator with a variable efficiency gossip has an ideal efficiency . The value you calculate more closely matches a water cool reciprocating compressor with very low ratios.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

dcasto,
since you do not explain how you calculate that temperature I can only presume that you utilize some custom procedure and that result should, in my opinion, be validated,

actually 50 C difference can have a large impact on selection,

in these cases I prefer as first step use a standard procedure (rigorous polytropic stage with 75-80% efficiency) and then ask the manufacturer to include all the specific operating parameters (which may show large differences in different compressors)

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

apereti, I am not using a custom equation, you are using a custom equation from the GPA. That formula closely matches in real life a water cooled cylinder.

In real life, I'd guess that the screw compressor discharge temperature will be exactly 180 F. Trust me on that one.

When you use the GPA equation, which K do you use, there are 10 million different K's.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

your previous value was "At 15 C the discharge temp will be 203 C at 75% polytropic eff."
in the last post temperature has been reduced to 82 C (180 F),
I would call this a big change.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

oil flooded screws have internal cooling of the process.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

Now I really do not understand anything to this discussion.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar


>Now I really do not understand anything to this discussion.

I think dcasto likes to create a bit of confusion smile
but don't care for that,
the correct answer was given in previous posts.

RE: ethane compression from 21 to 120 bar

Now I'm confused. Is this a engineering forum or a theoretical class discussion. The OP was all over the place on composition and not clear on what is the exact compressor in use or proposed. So how can anyone answer 100%? I'm not here to give free engineering, I'm here to make others think and learn so leading people to an answer is how this is suppose to work IMHO.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources