×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.
5

Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

(OP)
I am carrying out a research project into new methods for separating oil and water, as found in machinery space bilges on board ships.

I am currently researching technologies used shore-side and evaluating their potential for use at sea. I am particularly interested in ozonation, UV exposure, biotechnologies, electrocoagulation, chemical additives, ultrafiltration and dissolved air flotation.

If anybody has any information or experience with any of these, or any other technologies, and would be willing to answer a few specific questions in this area, could you please let me know by replying to this thread.

Many thanks,

Lisa Wooderson.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

I have experience with ultrafiltration (UF) and biological treatment.

UF - Need to know MW of oil, may be good option

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

(OP)
The problem we seem to have with current separating techniques is that they cannot process all the different types of contaminant and also the fact that the blige water often forms a stable suspension.

The sort of contaminant we usually find are monocyclic hydrocarbons, low and high MW polycyclic hydrocarbons and also low and high MW petroleum hydros (by the way, I am not really chemically minded and got these ...cyclic names from a colleague who is - I just know we use various fuel and lube oils and this is what they break down into, according to him). Combined with this there are sometimes traces of metal from wear and corrosion and also, often sewage and cleaning agents (the detergents in these chemicals and oils are causing the emulsions and hence poor gravimetric separation).

With regards to UF, I am not sure of the effect of sewage and chemical attack on the membranes...do you know if anything like this has been investigated? I presume it has but am failing to find any data on it - I have read several papers detailing tests but never anything that is appropriate to ship board waste water..have you come across anything like this?

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

(OP)
Almost forgot...

You mentioned that you have knowledge/experience with bio-treatments:

I have been reading up a lot about this today and what I have managed to ascertain so far is that some treatments work in 2 stages - initially breaking down oil into smaller globules and then dispersing the molecules to be broken down into CO2 and H2O. I assume that this is effective for surface oil, but what would be the effect on emulsified oils? Would the emulsion need to be broken first or will bio-treatments do this as well?

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

UF membranes came be made from a variety of materials that can be resistant to oils and certain chemicals although solvents might hurt them.
UF performance would not be affected by emulsification.
Also, biological performance is improved the more emulsified/dissolved the food (oil in this case) is dissolved in the water.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Centrifugation?  Reclaim oil and resell at port?

Activated Carbon Adsorption?  Unload used carbon for custom regeneration and reload with freshly activated carbon?

Just some ideas.  There must be well established technologies with application history?  eg:  cruise ships in sensitive environments like Alaska Glacier Bay or the Gallapago's or the Caribiean, etc?  Maybe EPA or a marine organization has more info.

Interesting.  Good luck!

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

(OP)
rbcoulter - thanks for that it is most useful and has really set things into motion this end now!!

DeltaCascade - thanks for your ideas too. I don't know what your specialisation is but just in case you are interested in what we do...The reason we don't use centrifugal separation is really a case of volume: where for removing water from fuel or lube oil centrifuges are extremely effective and efficient because of the small quantity of water removed from the oil, when dealing with bilge water, the opposite is true. There is a large volume of water and small globules and quantities (sometimes emulsified) of oil to be removed. It is for this reason centrifugal separation is not deemed to be particularly appropriate for this application ON SHIPS...but I think it may be shore side.
All ships are governed by the same regulations and the ppm oil in water that we are allowed to pump over the side does vary depending on area. These regs are becoming more stringent and are up for review again in 2003. The current technology is based around coalescing plates and gravimetric separation, although some companies are starting to experiment with ceramic UF systems..The main problems associated with the common shipboard OWS (coalescers and gravity based) are that they cannot break emulsions (resulting in oil passing overboard) and they are adversely affected by solvents and sewage.
I work on cruise ships myself and have worked with a combination of plate coalescers, coalescing beds and gravity tanks. Such OWSs often struggle to produce an effluent of less than 15ppm (majority of areas require this) and, with more stringent rules coming in, we are trying to develop systems to take the oil content down to <1ppm.
Regarding carbon adsorption, I do not really know how effective that is in these cases...but I am about to go find out now that you have mentioned it!! Thanks again and I hope you found this interesting!!!

Lisa.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

I used to work in the area of separations (centrifuges). I recall that the navy was working on a system that involved a strainer (to get the chunks out), followed by a 10 to 30 micron filter (there was debate on what was good enough), then a liquid centrifuge (to get the contamination down to 75 to 300 ppm and remove any "free" hydrocarbons) and then a polish step. The polish material could either be throw-aways like filters or carbon or re-newable membrane systems. The system configuration could be tailored to ship size and tour duration. For example, a coast gaurd vessel with short tours might use only throw away filters, but a carrier might use the full system with a membrane because they wanted to reduce consumables.

Hope that helps.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Yeah.  Also, crushed walnut shells are used as media for water filtration in the oil industry quite successfully ... down to 1-2 ppm oil in produced water.  The media is intermittently backwashed and oil is separated in backwash tank; more economical than "throw-away" cartridge filters for large applications, but likely less economical in marine vs land applications.  Likely similarly, for pre-coat filters.

Searching EPA's web site for "bilge" came up with what appears to be a state of the art process that is being developed, or at least trialed.  Excerpts follow:

Combined Centrifugal Separator/Membrane Ultrafiltration System for Shipboard Treatment of Bilge and Ballast Water
(Project Amount: $225,000)

The objective of this project is to develop a bilge water treatment process by combining a centrifugal separator pretreatment step to remove solids and large oil droplets, and a novel, fouling-resistant composite ultrafiltration membrane-polishing step to remove the remaining emulsified and dissolved oil and produce dischargeable water that meets the new regulations.

...Further reading at EPA's site shows discussion of the new ceramic membranes that you mentioned.

You are probaly also aware of dissolved air flotation.  Bio-digestion processes don't seem to be there yet, even with imnmobilized bacteria?...

Best of luck with your project  

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

(OP)
Thanks both of you for all this info! I have also come across a lot of info about this ceramic membrane system that the RN and USN trialled...it looks pretty good but I am wondering if they found any shipboard vibration problems with the inherent fragility of the ceramics..I read that they were planning to continue ship board trials for this purpose but no amount of digging has so far revealed any results of this...have you come across anything?

I also have a local contact working for a membrane technology firm now so I am hoping to find out some more details from him shortly..keep you posted!!

Thanks again!!

Lis.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

I used to work several years in the marine OWS field.
As you mention the currently used separation technic is based on gravity separation followed by coalescence.
These machines have to produce an effluent with less than 15 ppm oil, while the influent which is bilge water is a complex mixture and might contain (sea water, heavy fuel oil, IFO, gas oil, lubricants, detergents, particulatte matter etc).

Specifications, as well as testing procedures for this type of equipment are issued by the International Maritime Organization (IMO). To my knoweledje revised specifications are expedted in the next few years, but I don't think that the limit of 15 ppm is going to change.
The flowrate of this equipment is generally from 1 to 10 m3/h.
Activated Carbon filtration could be a good option for final treatment.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

We have recently introduced a coalescing media that is performing with outstanding results in difficult oil/water separation applications www.lantecp.com

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

The regs for OWSs are changing from 2005.  The 15 ppm limit will remain but all new OWSs fitted will require emulsion breaking capabilities as well as heavy fuel oil removal capabilities.  The price of these as well as running costs will be substantially more than the current industry norm.

In some other forum, biotreatment was mentioned.  This is really a no go area on board a ship, although, technically possible.  Mostly due to retention periods and complex nature of bilge water.



 

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

You consistantly mention emulsions causing problems.  Hence to remove any oil you have to increase the droplet size.  Currently there are two types of fibrous coalescing media available which may assist you here.

One is PECT-F by www.cyclotech.com which is usually installed upstream of any hydrocyclones while the other is The Mare's Tail (http://www.owtc.co.uk/engineering).  If you want I can e-mail you a recent paper on The Mare's Tail.

If you are pumping this bilge water overboard then there may be enough pressure to allow effective operation of hydrocyclones.  These units can handle large volumes of water but require at least 3barg driving pressure (more if available).  Since the water is already emulsified I'd have no problems pumping the water up to pressure then passing it through PECT-F/Mare's Tail and a hydrocyclone.  However since the regulations are circa 15ppm you may require some further treatment, probably your membranes or ultrafiltration may be suitable.

Hydrocyclones typically produce a reject stream of 3-5% volume of the inlet i.e. Q(reject) = 0.03 x Q(Inlet).  This stream will not be entirely oil, so you'll have to have an idea of how to deal with this concentrated stream - maybe blending it in with the centrifuge feed for the fuel oil.

One further issue that I'd raise is that the tests for overboard water do not always exclude dissolved hydrocarbons.  Consequently any mechanical separation (platepack, centrifuges, hydrocyclones) may be working at their optimum but you still do not achieve 15ppm overboard.  They will only remove dispersed oil.

I hope that this is of use to you.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

I forgot to mention that several companies/institutions are researching the use of ultrasonics to increase oil droplet size and break emulsions.  

Cyclotech (www.cyclotech.com)
Merpro (www.merpro.com)
Case Western Reserve University (http://www.aiche.org/conferences/techprogram/paperdetail.asp?PaperID=1170&DSN=annual02)

Neither Cyclotech or Merpro have details of ultrasonic separation on their website, but if you contact them they may provide you with further information.  

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

The engineers on our vessels are having trouble with adequately maintaining the 15ppm via the coalescer type OWS, although it is only 3 years old. I have sailed for 30 years and had the same problems. Has anyone had any experience with ULTRAFILTRATION onboard ships? If so, any contacts please?

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

I do quite alot of OWS units. You can get <10ppm, even with high levels of emulsified oils from plate separators, followed by coalescing media, floowed by GAC absorbtion.

You need to exceed API 421 by 2-3 to get the plates to work at all well when there's a lot of emulsion present.

Seán

www.expertise-limited.co.uk

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Lis, a combination of organo-clay and activated carbon is commonly used to remove oils from water.  The clay can break emulsions if they are formed as a result of mechanical action. In fact organo-clay has been used by the Navy for use on submarines. E-mail biomininc.com for further information.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Dear Ms. Lisa Wooderson,

I am a former Naval Officer and chief engineer.  If you are still searching for a solution for treating bilge water, ballast water, etc., please email me.  I will forward a few white papers to you that may give you some insight into treating low flowrates, such as pumping the bilges and very high flowrates such as ballast water.

Sincerly,
Todd

toddforet@usa.net

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Lis,

Ozonation and hydrogen peroxide treatments , followed by filtration have been found effective in oxidizing both single, double and triple bonds H-C including aromatic hydrocarbon.  As long as bromate formation is not a problem they are good treatment solutions.  They are use to disinfect ballast water in ships before dumping into sea.

209larry

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Dear Ms. Lisa Wooderson,

WOW - you sure have collected a lot of high technology solutions to solve the problem - and a few can be simply ruled out due to space limitations and others to cost and still others for the use of strong oxidants - I for one would not like to work in a confined space where the risk of exposure to Ozone (OSHA PEL†: TWA 0.1 ppm (0.2 mg/m3)).

One point that is not made clear is that the "oils" are a combination of many different type - an unfortunate  fact is that fuel oil is blended for calorific value and not for beauty, hence it can contain both mineral and vegetable oils and it is the latter which create the environmental problem.

I have never given the problem much thought, but a suitable (and low cost) technology would be to treat the oily water with a suitable surfactant (to break the emulsion) and then process it with an approved separator. There are some excellent oil/water separators available – the “Bilge Master ®” is one such unit worth considering - it works on the coalescing principle - with auto backwash operation(  made somewhere in the USA).

Absorption (activated carbons and the like) will quickly clog (ave. available area is about 1300 to 1800 m2/g)but is micro pored and the media closest to the inflow will fill and render it U/S.

If you would like additional information please feel free to contact me direct at engineering@envirocontrol.com

Best Regards with your technology research - Allen

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

If you're interested in a system that someone else has already put into service, have a look at www.hydroxyl.com .  They can offer entire packages plus information about the advanced oxidation options you were originally considering.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Lis,

I was pointed to this site by friend Tony.

I have been involved in the design Marine & Industrial Oily Water Separators ( gravity and Membrane)since the early eighties and have had good success using membranes with pre-filtration ahead of them.

What is it specifically that you want to know and why?

ATB,

Alan Russell

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

To save some work for your separation equipment and increase overall separating efficiency, you might want to consider a tank skimming device, like the sludgebuoy: http://www.sludgebuoy.com/html/
They also deliver computerized loggers that can be set up to log from a lot of different equipment.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

I have only just come across this thread so please forgive a rather late contribution.

UK company Flight Refuelling Ltd - Fluid Systems manufacture a ceramic membrane bilge water separator system certified to MEPC.107(49)

While the MEPC stipulates 15ppm, the system is consistently operated at better than 5ppm. There are no chemical additives or disposable filter elements or stockings to rewind, so no contact between operator and fluid - no dermatitis claims.

Equipment is supplied to UK Royal Navy for new build Type 45 frigates and also as retro fit on Type 23 destroyers currently undergoing refit program. This system is currently military and so is shock and vibration qualified, EMC, etc.

A commercial marine adaptation of this system is currently being manufactured.

A larger shoreside adaptation has also been installed at Faslane, Scotland, to process bilge water from shore side storage - clean water discharged straight to sea and concentrated oils retained.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Dear All,
I just join with this discussion and I would like to ask regarding the ceramic membrane as Netherhay mention.
Could you tell me how is the membrane characteristic you said produce 5 ppm ? Do you have the website of that company or someone that I could contact?

I have other request for Nosey. Would yu like to send me also the paper from Mare's Tail ? By the way I can not find the application of ultrasonic in the website of Cyclotech (www.cyclotech.com) and Merpro (www.merpro.com). Do you have some contacts also which I can get more information ?

Best regards,
Sumihar
 

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Orelis (Novasep group) produce ceramic and organic membrane used for oil/water separation
Ceramic membrane are already used on ferry for bilge water treatment - Orelis organic membrane are installed on cruise liner QM2
Feel free to contact me if you need information
Best regards
Herve PRADELLE

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Sumihar,

You can contact the company via the website:

www.flight-refuelling.com

You need the Fluid Systems Division at Factory 3, recently integrated into the company but not represented on the site as yet - persistance may be required!

In the most basic terms, the bilge water is circulated around a loop that contains a cermaic membrane. Clean water permeates through the ceramic membrane and is discharged overboard. The contaminated water is retained in the loop and, when a sufficient concentration of oil has been reached, is diverted to a sullage tank.

The equipment is fully certified by Lloyds to MEPC.107(49), the latest and most stringent MARPOL standard, and is operated by the Royal Navy at a maximum overboard discharge of 5ppm.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

I read separion of oli and water by CPI that is corrugated plate interceptor. This is very effective method where oil separates at top which can be scimmed off and oil free water can be further treated by bilogical treatment method.
   The oliy water to CPI comes from underflow-overflow arrangements where due to differences in densities, most of the oil can be separated.

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

Lis,
suggest you contact Ed Gardyne at Environmental Processes Ltd in Scotland (edgardyne@environmentalprocesses.com) - they've been doing work for Petrofac/Shell/Bp on oil-water seperation for some months now - supercoagualting the oil for removal for refining, then reduction of the remaining THc/Aromatics for direct discharge to the ocean - meeting EU 2007-2009 standards. No secondary waste stream to handle - small units for oil platforms, barges, barge washout, etc.
Tell him Dave at Aquatic Technologies sent you - they've beaten out several major competitors for this type of treatment - lower O&M, lower capitol cost, etc. -

Dave

RE: Oily Water Separation On Board Ships.

My understanding is that the bilgewater problem has already been solved by a small American company through the use of an oil extractor and polishing filters that brings the IMO cocktail down to below 5 ppm's. They have found a way to increase the oil droplets and break the emulsion. I don't believe the unit is very widely known at this time. I do know that the inventor was Hal Alper. I will research more and post again.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources