Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
(OP)
Folks
This is way outside what I normally do and I know that I need to hire someone. However, the question I have is what criteria should I be looking for in a mechanical/industrial design bid? How do I choose who to hire in order and make sure I have a good contract so that I end up with what I want while being fair to the engineer that I hire?
For those of you that do this frequently, or who are in the mechanical/industrial design business:
What makes up a good statement of work? (How do I write it so I get what I want?)
What criteria should be used to evaluate a bid? (How do I ensure that I will get what is in the statement of work?)
On this site, the advice is frequently to "hire someone!" So I'm asking if people are going to hire someone, but don't have a lot of experience in that area, what should they look for.
The backstory: My sister, a physical therapist has asked for my help in designing a piece of low-tech therapy equipment she needs. She has a clear idea of what she wants and I've done some very preliminary sketches based on what she described. While I could maybe dust off some of my engineering books and do more detailed design, it is outside my field. I also don't have the time to devote to this, and I feel uncomfortable because of potential patient liability. So I told her that she needed to hire someone that knows what they're doing. And if I have no clue on how to hire a good engineer; how is a non-engineer going to be able to do so?
Hence the question. All help appreciated.
Thanks from a totally clueless Nuke.
This is way outside what I normally do and I know that I need to hire someone. However, the question I have is what criteria should I be looking for in a mechanical/industrial design bid? How do I choose who to hire in order and make sure I have a good contract so that I end up with what I want while being fair to the engineer that I hire?
For those of you that do this frequently, or who are in the mechanical/industrial design business:
What makes up a good statement of work? (How do I write it so I get what I want?)
What criteria should be used to evaluate a bid? (How do I ensure that I will get what is in the statement of work?)
On this site, the advice is frequently to "hire someone!" So I'm asking if people are going to hire someone, but don't have a lot of experience in that area, what should they look for.
The backstory: My sister, a physical therapist has asked for my help in designing a piece of low-tech therapy equipment she needs. She has a clear idea of what she wants and I've done some very preliminary sketches based on what she described. While I could maybe dust off some of my engineering books and do more detailed design, it is outside my field. I also don't have the time to devote to this, and I feel uncomfortable because of potential patient liability. So I told her that she needed to hire someone that knows what they're doing. And if I have no clue on how to hire a good engineer; how is a non-engineer going to be able to do so?
Hence the question. All help appreciated.
Thanks from a totally clueless Nuke.
Want to know the do's and don'ts of Eng-Tips? Read FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies.
English not your native language? Looking for some help in getting your question across to others or understanding their answers? Go to forum1529: Translation Assistance for Engineers.





RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
I'd start out with a summary of technical requirements for the device, then a list of the deliverables and only then any intangible type stuff not directly tied to an actual deliverable.
Keep it a bit simpler and briefer than we used to in aerospace and than you probably do in Nuke work but make sure the important stuff is in there. Also make sure to give them any information they require that you have.
As to compliance, well you can ask that their bid demonstrate compliance with the SOW. You could even state that payment will be made against submittable & approval of the deliverable's etc.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
Of course, most proposals are basically vaporware, given the pressure to produce a sufficiently low cost bid to overcome any marginalities in the technical proposal. In aerospace, it's not unusual for the cost bid to be 30% below the original bottoms-up bid, which means that for a cost-plus contract, you'll need to have sufficient margin to cover the inevitable overrun.
Ideally, you should have some form of vetting for the costs, preferrably with your own design and cost history. Cost realism used to be a big deal in defense, where the customer would essentially do their own bid and place upticks and downticks on proposers' bids to even out the playing field.
TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Need help writing a question or understanding a reply? forum1529: Translation Assistance for Engineers
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
While working as a Manufacturing Engineer for too many years I had to get gizmos and machinery designed and built. Over the years I developed a spec style that seemed to work well enough for the chaotic madness that was my life in manufacturing. I simplified it to the concept of a Communications Tool to the Vendor. It went sort of like this:
SCOPE
Defines "which ballpark" you are playing in. Sets the "Vendor expectations" of what they will read in the spec.
DEFINITIONS
If any.
Sketches or pictures may be useful.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Sometimes is useful to provide context into why this gizmo is needed.
Patent or liability information for awareness.
Your gizmo's working environment.
DESCRIPTION (of need, of product requirements, etc)
This is where all the details are.
Configuration.
Loads, rates, other quantifiable indices.
This requires the most work of the writer, to define in quantitative terms what it is that they need. Most non-techies fail at this.
PROGRAM MANAGEMENT
In later years I tried to communicate my need for a real project plan of the design & build. I wanted it so I could monitor project progress, but rarely got it.
Quoting Period.
Evaluation Period.
Vendor Selection.
Release of Purchase Order.
Kickoff Meeting.
Preliminary Design Review Milestone.
(other prelim design reviews as reqd)
Final Design Review Milestone
(other "final" design reviews as reqd)
Build.
Vendor Trial & Acceptance.
Shipping Milestone.
Customer Trial & Acceptance.
TRIAL & ACCEPTANCE
Defines quantitative measures of how trials will be conducted and how acceptance will be granted.
Defines steps taken if trials fail.
CUSTOMER RESPONSIBILITIES
Defines what the customer must do, need not do.
Provide plans & parts in timely manner to support schedule.
Be available for design reviews.
VENDOR RESPONSIBILITIES
Meet project milestones.
Meet design & function requirements.
Trials, acceptance.
Release / ownership of design documents.
PAYMENT
Defines how money is transferred between Customer & Vendor.
No matter all of these spec requirements in writing and agreed to in Purchase Orders, it was usually a very fluid project and many of the administrative requirements never got met. The sales team that pushed for and accepted the PO seemed to never communicate admin requirements to the design team. A lot of follow-up & monitoring was required. Many times project schedules weren't met, and that was usually OK in the manufacturing environment because it was so chaotic & flexible.
TygerDawg
Blue Technik LLC
Virtuoso Robotics Engineering
www.bluetechnik.com
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
Any hints on selecting the best (or at least a reasonable) firm? After years of working for an unnamed entity that always goes for the lowest bidder, I'm leery of using cost as the sole criteria.
Want to know the do's and don'ts of Eng-Tips? Read FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies.
English not your native language? Looking for some help in getting your question across to others or understanding their answers? Go to forum1529: Translation Assistance for Engineers.
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
Trying to get a warm feeling just from SOW & Bid can be tricky.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
Set up your categories by which you will judge the vendors, set up a scoring method, apply a "importance to me" weighting factor to each category. Evaluate, score, and tally. Usually (not always) the most preferred choice will result in the highest score.
TygerDawg
Blue Technik LLC
Virtuoso Robotics Engineering
www.bluetechnik.com
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
Cheers
Greg Locock
New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm?
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
Thanks
Energy Mix.
Want to know the do's and don'ts of Eng-Tips? Read FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies.
English not your native language? Looking for some help in getting your question across to others or understanding their answers? Go to forum1529: Translation Assistance for Engineers.
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
I don't know the kind of device your sister has in mind but I can say that designing medical electronics is a very documentation and testing heavy process. By starting with a "feasibility" phase you can explore the design concept without being subject to all the quality requirements of the FDA. This will allow you to create a proof of concept prototype to see if it is possible to meet the design goals and cost targets without spending too much effort on documentation early on only to find there is no business case for the product.
Most product development firms are very willing to work with you to define the scope and deliverables for a project, they will then explicitly state what is included in their proposal to you. Expect to spend a lot of quality time on the phone/email with whoever you contact for the proposals.
Doug
RE: Evaluating Mechanical/Industrial Design Bids
Want to know the do's and don'ts of Eng-Tips? Read FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies.
English not your native language? Looking for some help in getting your question across to others or understanding their answers? Go to forum1529: Translation Assistance for Engineers.