×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Threaded connections for Automatic air vent and Pressure Relief valves for Jet fuel service

Threaded connections for Automatic air vent and Pressure Relief valves for Jet fuel service

Threaded connections for Automatic air vent and Pressure Relief valves for Jet fuel service

(OP)
I have the filter water separator and the Filter monitor vessels for the Jet fuel service and they have the threaded connections at the top of these vessels for air vent and the Pressure relief valves. Our client is having a concern that for the jet fuel service we need to avoid the threaded connections and also while removing the air vent valve for any maintenance and fixing back the threads may get damaged and insisting to give flanged connections.

Vendor refuses to comply with this as this is their standard design and cannot change it. I have also checked all other suppliers of similar aviation fuel service filters and monitors and there also it is threaded connection only.

The vendor is not able to give any technical reason why it should be threaded connection and my query is why all the vendors have such air vent valves in threaded connection?

Thanks to reason it out and reply

RE: Threaded connections for Automatic air vent and Pressure Relief valves for Jet fuel service

Add a threaded flange to the relief valve, which is the only part you'll be disassembling frequently. Add a threaded nipple and flange to the vessel at the connection point. What's the big problem?

Avoiding threaded connections is one thing, and eliminating them entirely is quite another.

NPT threaded joints at sizes 2" and smaller, when used within their reasonable limits of temperature/pressure and when used with the right thread sealant, are not unsafe. I would have no problem using threaded connections on small connections at moderate pressure and ambient temperature in a chemical plant. Whether there is an absolute prohibition against using them in jetfuel service in accordance with some fuels regulation in your region is totally unknown to me.

That other vendors also use threads should tell you something. It tells me that this is NORMAL in that particular industry and that your client's absolute prohibition of threaded connections is not normal.

If for some reason your client wants to eliminate the threaded connections entirely, they'll need to either not use the vendor's standard component, or to modify it after receiving it (if that's even possible) by welding and then hydrotesting the welds. If the part is aluminum, I wouldn't mess with welding personally. None of this is the vendor's problem, unless they promised you no threads before you ordered the part and then tried to give you less than what you ordered.

RE: Threaded connections for Automatic air vent and Pressure Relief valves for Jet fuel service

(OP)
Thanks sir for your reply . Sometimes some may not go through the topics not interested to them. That is why i double posted. I will avoid it in future.

RE: Threaded connections for Automatic air vent and Pressure Relief valves for Jet fuel service

Are the threads straight ("parallel") or tapered pipe threads?
The less common "straight" pipe threads require an additional feature (o-ring) to seal.

As others said, are the housings aluminum, inviting easier thread damage?

When working with hydraulic systems (100s or 1000s of psi) over the past few years there seemed to be some tendency for US manufacturers to use tapered pipe threads on relatively small fittings ( under 1/2 inch NPT or so), and flanges on larger fittings. European suppliers seemed to adopt flanged, o-ring joints much more often. I never dug deep into the various ISO standards even though I expected to see something was spelled out there.

Gotta think a tapped hole is a lot quicker/easier/cheaper than a fabricated and welded flange.

Would your specification allow an "adapter" fitting as suggested by MoltenMetal? Although that would introduce 2 of the dreaded threaded connections.

RE: Threaded connections for Automatic air vent and Pressure Relief valves for Jet fuel service

Would it not be a safety issue? Usually this is where I get the resistance.

NPT forms are particularly weak in shear, any side load, wanted or unwanted, would snap the relief valve off at the stem. This would have a tremendous amount of safety concerns given your medium is a jet fuel. Often the NPT stem is supported against shear, the resulting geometry looking more flange like in nature. So I suspect buddy simply wants usage of a flange and be done with it.

The other reason is as mentioned by MoltenMetal. If you are to inspect the component often, then that means unfastening it from the pressure vessel. NPT are good for about two or three fits, then the interference threading starts to gall and is proned to pickup. You could over torque the piece during mating, again, safety issue about stripping threads. This is not saying that the technician is not competent which is usually the interpretation, just saying that a flange style assembly offers considerable benefits should something unintended happen.

I bring up these two points as I have often encountered them from third party inspectors in oilfield valve systems for mainline block and bleed ball and gate valves. NPT are typically points for discussion during design review meetings.

Hope this helps or at least clarifies some of your concerns.

Regards,
Cockroach

RE: Threaded connections for Automatic air vent and Pressure Relief valves for Jet fuel service

(OP)
Thanks all of you sirs for the wonderful reply .

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources