×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

(OP)
Hi All,

Here's the situation, I'm planning on installing a strain gauge on a goal post shaped steel beam (dimensions/drawing attached). We'll be applying load at the top of the goal post and reading strains down near the base (half way between the posts and the base actually) and we're trying to understand what kind of stress to strain relationship we can get out of it. Now I'm using Stress = MC/I for this (which may be wrong in itself for this shape of an object) because this is essentially a cantilever beam with a weight on the end..the problem is getting the "I", or second moment of inertia. I've tried using the parallel axis theorem and breaking the part up, but I'm not sure the correct way to do this so I've gotten a bunch of different answers and no way to know which is right.


The axis of rotation is through the center of the bottom of the goal post (where the strain gauge will be placed). A little bit of help to get me pointed in the right direction would be great.


Tyler

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

What direction do you planning on applying the load?

I don't see why Mc/I would be wrong. How I see it is you need to calculate I for each individual sections. For a rectangular plate with b=width d=depth I=bd^3/12. Section modulus (S) = bd^2/6 with stress breaking down to M/S. Be sure to keep your units straight.

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

The stress will be P/A ± My/I in the rectangular cross section above the base. If you are mounting the strain gauge on the surface, then stress is P/A ± M/S where S is the section modulus. For a rectangular section, I = bd3/12 and S = bd2/6. For these derivations, you can consult any strength of materials text.

BA

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

(OP)
Thanks for the input. I know the equations, I'm just not sure which dimensions are b and d. The load will be applied at the top of the goal post (see view 1 in attachment).

Would I have to use the parallel axis theorem to do this, since parts of the beam are further out from the axis of rotation? I'm more confused about how you're supposed to look at the shape when doing this equation...look at it as view 2, or view 3 (I've attached a modified drawing labeling the views).

Thanks again for the help.


Tyler

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

Place the strain gauge as low as possible on the 0.375 x 0.5 member, on the 0.5 face. The strain gauge will read the extreme fiber stress at the surface which will correlate to the moment at that location. For that stress, "f", the equation f=M/S applies, with the "S" being the section modulus of the rectangular section.

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

the load is going to be applied in the two semi-circular grooves, yes?
and applied acting down the leg, yes?
so the vertical leg is in compression, and the horizontal leg is in bending, yes?
the section looks to be 0.5" deep (=d) and 0.375" wide (=b) ... I = bd^3/12, c = d/2 ... yes?

Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

The second attachment shows that the load is applied in the horizontal direction, so it is a cantilever with five different cross sections along its length. Since each cross section is either one or two rectangles the second moment of area is simply given by:

I = bd^3/12

where d is the depth in the direction of the applied force and b is the total width of the rectangle(s).

Doug Jenkins
Interactive Design Services
http://newtonexcelbach.wordpress.com/

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

Is the load on one arm of the goal post or both?

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

so it's bending about the other axis ... b = .5" d = .375",
and as others are saying, the load is the load applied to a leg (so if you have a bar in the groove, loaded horizontally (as shown) then 1/2 the load will be applied to each leg ... yes?

Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

(OP)
All,

Yes the load will be applied in the grooves of the goal post bending it back, so all the stress should be at the bottom (where we're placing the strain gauge). From your answers looks like I've got a couple options:

If it's just the rectangular section the gauge is on that you have to worry about you get I = 1/12 b d^3 = (1/12)*(0.5)*(.375^3) = .00219 in^4

If it's the whole width of the goal posts then I = (1/12)*(4)*(.375^3) = .0176 in^4

If it's each rectangle added together it's another number...

If I have to do the parallel axis theorem it's a whole other answer (a much larger one too).

This is where I'm getting confused...

Tyler

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

1) is one leg supporting the load ? (is the load evenly divided between the two legs, or is more on one side ?)

2) why, oh why, would you think the air between the two legs is reacting the load ?

3) see 1) (i think the load is evenly reacted by both legs, but what do i know)

4) this isn't a parallel axis problem, 'cause the neutral axis of the section is aligned with the bending axis. it's not like there's an area away from the axis ... it's simply bd^3/12

5) yes you are ... very (confused)

Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

(OP)
Yes, it's evenly distributed. There will be a rod sitting across the goal posts that will be applying the load. Stress should be it's highest down near the base. Since I'm measuring stress at the base and you say it's not a parallel axis problem is it just bd^3/12 for the base section and that's it? Just I = (0.5)(.375^3)/12?

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

You should have shown the load on View 3 as well as View 1. Then we wouldn't have to ask how the load was distributed.

If the horizontal force on each upright is F, then the total horizontal force is 2F and the moment at the top of the pile cap is 2F*h where h is the height of the force above the cap. At the top of pile cap, the only section resisting moment is a rectangular section of width 0.5 and depth 0.375, so the stress is 2F*h/S where S is the section modulus, bd2/6.

Parallel axis theorem has nothing to do with the problem. What is this, a homework assignment?

BA

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

Tyler...your analysis is straightforward. It is only the 0.5 x 0.375 section you are concerned with. For the sketch you provided and assuming your section is a solid bar not a tube, then your member stress will be:

f=M/S where S = 1/6 x 0.5 x (0.372^2)
and
M = (distance from center of load application point to strain measurement centerline) x load

If the section is tube instead of a solid bar, the S value will change by subtracting out the hollow part using the hollow dimensions in the same formula.

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

"Just I = (0.5)(.375^3)/12?" ... if you're looking at one leg (carrying 1/2 the load)

you're matching with s/gauge ouput ... make sure you put the gauge on the right face !

Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati

RE: Area Moment of Inertia for Goal Post

Out of curiosity, what will you be doing with this problem?

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources