×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units
5

Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

(OP)
Achieving the Desired Return Air quantities from occupied spaces.
The HVAC System consists of roof mounted Air Handling units for a single storey building that has many rooms. The system is designed for 20% fresh air and 80% return air that is achieved in the mixing box of the air handler.
The return air from the ceiling diffusers back to the Air Handler is not ducted. A short piece of duct with a bell mouth is extended from the AHU on the roof to the space above the acoustic tile false ceiling to draw air from all the rooms and corridors in the building.
The Supply air in each room is 400 CFM, but the return air quantity measured from the return air diffusers is coming to only 100 CFM.
We could not detect any infiltration of air from the light fixtures or the cracks and crevices in the false ceiling. The measurements from such light fixtures and edges of the false ceiling panels is registering zero on the measuring Hood.
The total return air measured at the bell mouthed duct to the AHU or at the straight piece of duct at the roof before its connection to the machine is as per design quantity. So the AHU is drawing air from somewhere. While we are in the process of checking the point of infiltration, the questions are: 1) What is the acceptable tolerance of return air quantities from the rooms whose type of occupancy is offices? ; 2) Is this achievable in non ducted return air systems?

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

You will never balance a plenum air return properly. If you need to balance accurately, you need return ducts.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

(OP)
I agree willard3, but there must be the practice of the trade or Ashrae/Smacna guidelines about acceptable performance. Is 10% deviation Ok or is even 20% excusable. There has to be a minimum acceptable performance in such cases. Getting only 25% return air compared to supply air appears way too far.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

As long as the plenum is at a negative pressure relative to the space, there should be no problem? Is there a comfort or odor problem you are trying to solve?

You can't specify a tolerance for return air flow if there is no means to adjust it, so there won't be any sort of standard in my opinion. I'm agreeing with Willard3 here, but going a bit farther.


Best to you,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies? Do so now: Forum Policies

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

(OP)
The building is not occupied yet. With so little return, an odor problem would most likely arise. If the plenum is at a negative pressure compared to the space but the return air quantity that is showing up on the hood is very little, that might mean that the rooms will very soon face heavy air. Is it being implied that we need not do air balancing of the return air?
Secondly if there is no problem, then we can always omit a ducted return (if we can afford a little cooling load increase).

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

why would you not open return diffusers to the maximum and measure quantity, as a first step.

open the one closest to ahu, measure, than close it and open the farthest one.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

I was assuming that you do not have adjustable return diffusers. I have never seen adjustable return diffusers in a plenum-return system. Aren't they something like eggcrate panels? If so, you cannot possibly balance return flows. How can you balance the airflow through several holes that don't have dampers?

I don't understand your comment, "...that might mean that the rooms will very soon face heavy air." If you have 400 CFM going into a room, you also have 400 CFM leaving the room. If it's not going up the return grille, it's going into the hallway. Many places have no return grille at all in the rooms, but a single common return in a corridor that is ducted back to the rooftop unit.

Close all the office doors. Light up a cigarette (or spend some money on a smoke candle). Stand in a room farthest away from the rooftop unit. With 400 CFM supply and 100 CFM return Follow your smoke until it makes it to a return grille. It will probably be in the few offices very close to the rooftop unit.

You mentioned 20 percent outside air. How does the relief air exit the building?

Best to you,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies? Do so now: Forum Policies

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

(OP)
DRWeig:
Since 400 CFM are coming in, the same quantity is definitely leaving but not from the return grille and this is the issue. If the door is closed this might even pressurize the room forcing the supply air to go to adjacent rooms. I feel this will somehow destabilize the system and would cause odors in rooms that are not having the same CFM leaving the room. It would also cause a nuisance when the room occupied by a smoker is not getting the smoke pulled out from the ceiling diffuser and it is instead going to the hallway.
The 20% make up of fresh air is due to the 20% being extracted by exhaust fans from the toilets.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

That's great, solidspaces. You are right, odors will go from office to corridor to the other offices. However, this will happen whether the door is open or closed, unless the door is gasketed and sealed well at the floor.

The point is -- you cannot change it unless you install return dampers in each room and balance them.

Try my experiment. Close all the doors. Then start at the last office on the end of the supply duct run. Make some smoke and follow it. See where it goes.

Best to you,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies? Do so now: Forum Policies

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

not sure I fully understand, but did you account for all the air that goes "through" the acoustical ceiling and not through the return grill? An acoustical ceiling with laid-in tiles , fixtures etc. is like a sieve and the air goes path of least resistance.

In addition at such low flow rates your measuring hood isn't accurate. Just measuring adds resistance, diverting more air "through" the ceiling.

Obviously as much air as comes in will leave the room, same for the AHU. If the plenum doesn't have leaks to the outside or restrictions, it probably will be fine unless you experience actual problems.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

(OP)
I am grateful to all who responded. The net result of this discussion is that matching the return air quantities with supply is not as critical as I thought

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

You will find out, after the building occupants complain about humidity, odors and drafts, that there should be return air ducts and the air volumes should be balanced.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

(OP)

Willard3:
I thought the consensus was that it is OK even if the quantities of supply and return do not equal. Different arguments and explanations poured in about this disparity from the sensitivity of measuring hood to the cracks and crevices of the false ceiling panels to the positive and negative pressures to the argument that the air that is coming in must be exiting also, etc.
Your eye opener response goes against all the above consensus and has revived my concerns. So more responses are requested about the final action that is needed in this matter.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

Willard3 is not going against the consensus, he is adding information to it.

I just finished working 15 years in a building with plenum return. Complaints were few and far between. There is no way to tell until 10 occupants all get together for a bean burrito lunch on the same day that another occupant burns popcorn in the microwave and another occupant heats up chicken tikka masala on a hot plate in his office. That happened in our office maybe twice a year.

Ducted return would swoop that stuff back to the AHU to be mixed with OSA before returning to the spaces. It's a chance you take.

Try my suggestion. Let some smoke loose in a room farthest from the RTU. Follow it. When it leaves the hallway and starts entering other offices, imagine that it is "bioeffluent gas" instead of just smoke.

The point is: It's OK to have supply not equal return with a plenum system because you can't do anything about it. It occurs in all systems in which the owner doesn't want to spring for ducted return.

There is nothing you can do to balance the return air, so ignore it. OR, duct the return.

Best to you,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies? Do so now: Forum Policies

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

design conditions: 400 cfm/room, 320cfm of return. 80 cfm of fresh air.
actual conditions: 400 cfm/room, 100 cfm of return, 300 cfm of fresh air.
did you check supply air condition?
what if you close the fresh air inlet then check return flow again?

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

(OP)
317069: Yes we did check the supply air quantities. They are as per design. We could do the experiment that you have suggested of blanking off the supply and check out the return quantities. I am curious about your expectations or predictions about the effect of doing so!

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

Plenum return is fine if you have air tight ceiling void as in office towers with concrete floors. Plenum return is not to be used in buildings with metal deck or similar roof structure that are unlikely to be air tight. By measuring room conditions and the return conditions at AHU inlet, you can establish if there is outside air leaking into the void. An easy way to check if return is all right is to see if the doors are easy to open.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

(OP)
SAK9
All that you say makes sense. I am receiving the Air Balancing work from a subcontractor.
I just need to know if supply is 400 CFM and return is coming at only 100 CFM, can the subcontractor be paid? Will these numbers be approved by the consultant? Or will the company have to do it all over again? No objection was raised about the non ducted return at the time of accepting the Air Balancing Job, so can anyone back track and start raising hue and cry now, that it is not ducted?

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

I didn't mean air quantities, (300 cfm fresh air+100 cfm return air)is a different than (300 cfm return air +100 cfm fresh air) for the same AHU or RTU, may be you have to hire an air balance contractor to balance your system.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

ooops you already have a contractor.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units




The total return air measured at the bell mouthed duct to the AHU or at the straight piece of duct at the roof before its connection to the machine is as per design quantity.

So the disconnect if you can say that, is that the space above the ceiling is providing air from somewhere other than the rooms to the air handler.
Has anybody looked at the point where the deck meets the exterior walls, to see if foam seals are installed?
B.E.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

Best to you,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies? Do so now: Forum Policies

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

Quote (solidspaces)

I just need to know if supply is 400 CFM and return is coming at only 100 CFM, can the subcontractor be paid?

There is no control for return air in a non-ducted system. The contractor cannot make it any different than it is right now. If they balanced the supply air to 400 CFM, they are done. Mission accomplished. The balancing firm did its job.

If you are supplying 400 to the space, sucking 80 of it out the toilet exhaust, measuring design return air flow at the unit intake, and design outdoor air at the unit intake, you have done all that you can do. There is no more that can be done. I would not bother measuring return air in individual rooms. It cannot be balanced in any way, shape, or form.

Sorry for the dead horse above, feel free to red flag it.

Best to you,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies? Do so now: Forum Policies

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

You have not told us whether the AHU inlet conditions were close to design.If it is high there may be outside air leaking into the system.As a matter of due diligence you should highlight it to your consultant.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

(OP)
SAK9: The supply, return and fresh air quantities measured at or near the machine all add up. The only problem is that the return air quantities are a fraction of what they should be when measured by the hood at the ceiling return diffusers.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

Then it looks like most of the return is through light fittings(vented?)and through the gap between lay in tiles and the frame.The hood may not register any air flow when held against the light fitting as it will be well below its measuring range.Try a smoke test if you need to put your mind at rest.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

SAK9,
This thing is getting circular, I believe DRWeig suggested this in his second reply.
And at the risk of him beating me, with the stick instead of the horse. Suspended ceiling tile are notorious for this behavior.
B.E.

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

This is just recursive and somebody should kill this thread.....it's going nowhere.....

RE: Non Ducted Return Air to Air Handling Units

You're right SAK9 and berkshire, no beatings in the offing.

As for the last post by solidspaces,

Quote (solidspaces)

The only problem is that the return air quantities are a fraction of what they should be...

I will again, but more gently, state that there "what they should be" is what they are, unless you have ducted return with balancing dampers. Your return quantities measured at the return diffuser in each room are EXACTLY what they should be.

Best to you,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies? Do so now: Forum Policies

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources