×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

(OP)
Hello everyone,

I'm new to structural analysis and design using STAAD Pro. I've been using staad for last 6 months or so. So much to learn eh! I'm somewhat okay with concrete but know nothing about steel, I mean in staad.

I'm trying to analyse and design this long span (30 metres) steel roof truss using staad. Managed to get zero errors and warnings in the analysis report but when it comes to CODE CHECK, members fail! I'm pretty sure that I've done something really wrong (the way members are connected, material choice etc).

I've attached .std file with this post. It's an open structure. Can someone please have a look and guide me to get the perfect analysis and design pointing out the mistakes I've done in staad model.

I'd also like to know how I can add vertical and diagnol members to an arch (staad wouldn't allow)

Thanks in advance :)

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

Node 68 is a roller in X and the members are all pretty much pinned so you get some large rotation of the cantilever structure east of node 68 about node 6. A member between node 6 and 93 might help, or a modified support. Besides that, some of the members fail but I don't see any other major problems. Setting the proper member unbraced length is often the most critical task for truss modeling.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

Just curious. Does no one design trusses by hand anymore?

Kieran

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

I design trusses by hand. It relaxes me.
There's such a thing as doing designs too fast. Anyway, by the time I model a truss in STAAD, debug my model and check the design by hand, it doesn't save that much time.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

JedClampett, I agree, there is such a thing as doing a design too fast. Too many times I have rushed through a project at the request of a client only to have them change something and have to do a bunch of work over again. My old boss used to never worry about deadlines. His excuse would be the job would be done when it was done and that by the time it was done all of the changes would have already taken place.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

SteelPE,
I don't recall you ever working for me.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

(OP)
SethGuthrie.....Thanking you very much for your valuable comment mate. It's really helpfull for a beginner in STAAD/structural anaylsis + design, someone like me :)

And also thanking others for their views and opinion on this.

JedClampett....I agree with you mate. Hand calculations most of the time saves time and hassle free. Sit down, get the members sorted putting to a table format and there we go! All done and dusted eh lolz!!

More advice and help...much appreciated guys

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

Regarding the arch question, you can approximate it (pretty closely) with line segments that follow the desired curve.
Regarding tips in general, the Bentley Be Communities site has a Wiki and a Forum that are pretty popular.
wiki: http://communities.bentley.com/products/structural...
forum: http://communities.bentley.com/products/structural...

But when it comes to Eurocode specific issues I won't be much help.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

(OP)
Hi SethGuthrie. Thanks alot for the reply. Just a qucik question about RAM Structural System. I know few engineers usign RAM SS for analysis + design. Is it like STAAD or more advance (better) than STAAD? Can we use this software to design concrete beams. columns. slabs etc like in STAAD?

Thanks :)

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

Ram Structural System is set up for buildings. It can do a variety of structures, but multi-story steel and concrete buildings are the emphasis. It has some advanced methods for automatic load distribution, composite beam design, steel joist design, lateral load distribution and special seismic provisions to name a few features that separate it from the broader range of general finite element analysis programs. But for this thread and the discussion of an arched truss it's not the best option. A general program like Staad.pro or Ram Elements is better there.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

(OP)
Thank you very much :)

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

There is absolutely no way that you can analyze a truss and perform a code-check manually (by hand) faster than what it takes an experienced Staadpro user (or similar) to model and check the truss with Staadpro (or similar). Don't get me wrong, I understand the necessity of being able to perform such a calculation manaully, but let's get real here.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

(OP)
ANDYSINES...I agree with you. When we have powerful softwares, why would we do it by hand eh!

I'm at the moment getting myself familiar with STAAD Pro and RAM Elements for analysis and design. I also want to get familiar with a good BIM software to work with STAAD and RAM. Which one(Revit, Tekla, RAM SS etc)you guys would recommend me?
A question re Staad..I'm confused with 'concrete design' application within staad. Do we necessarily have to use this application for concrete design or can we just use staad output file report to get the design details.
Thanks!

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

For STAAD users we tend to recommend ProSteel (aka ProStructures for BIM, though we also interface with AECOsim Building Designer, Tekla, and Revit via the Integrated Structural Modeling (ISM) workflow.
http://communities.bentley.com/products/structural...
The RC designer just gives you more options and controls over the basic concrete design.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

I use Staadpro exclusively, and our drafting department uses Tekla for certain applications. I have to admit.......I'm not sold on the integration of design software with BIM software just yet. There's too many wierd "quirks" and too much clean up required at this point. So far, it seems as if it's just faster to have 2 independent models (one with Staadpro, one with Tekla) and let each user have their own model. I'm sure this process will become more refined in the future, but it's not there yet.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

I never said I could do it faster. A lot of us are not an "experienced Staadpro user". We're dabblers who have STAAD and use it when necessary. We've done a lot of trusses and prefer the loss of efficiency compared with the gain in control and feel of doing our own numbers. So to judge that there's no way I can do it faster than an experienced STAADPro user is the wrong measurement. It's whether I could do it faster myself.
And when you're done with your computer analysis, how do you document it? Do you print out every number? Every load case? The model? How many pages is that? How do your reviewers check your work? Show me a system of putting your work on the shelf (hard copy on a shelf, not a server) and recovering it 20 years from now, when STAAD is long gone, and I'll consider it.

RE: How to Design Steel Roof Truss in STAAD

JedClampett - persoanlly, my calculations consist of a combination of the Staadpro report and Word/Excel documents that show the setup data (input and design parameters), design load calculations, connections, etc. The bulk of the analysis and code-check data is contained within the Staadpro report. In some cases, I have a hand calculation (in Word or Excel) that is used for spot-checking purposes to verify the Staadpro results. Yes, it's alot of pages and not as user friendly as a well organized hand calculation.....I can't dispute that. I've never had the priviledge of peer review in my career (12 years) since I've been the lone engineer (structural anyway) at every placed I've worked, but my in my opinion, my calc reports are easy to navigate and contain the data that is necessary for a review. I know what you're getting at though......nothing replaces the old-school manual method. However, after you match your results over & over again with what the computer is telling you, sooner or later you become comfortable in the output and you trust those results more.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources