×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

(OP)
Question: I am wondering why the bases of the large wind turbines I toured recently had something like 64 large, "left hand" thread bolts in the base. The tour guide did not know, but he did say they were torqued to something like 2000 lbs. Why the '"left hand threads?
Thanks,
George

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

Well, you made me curious, but I didn't find an answer either.

I find some threaded rebars are available in left/right threads so you can match two end-to-end and thread a coupler on them without rotating the bar. But if they're available in both orientations, I can't think why you'd use left-handed for anchors.

I found one link that mentioned certain bars were threaded left-hand so they could be screwed into soil or rock and were apparently threaded left-handed to match other equipment used, "together with a lefthand thread for standard rotary percussive drilling".

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

(OP)
Interesting. But, I thought it might have something to do with the yaw controls or something twisting the tower and they were this way to resist it.

Maybe its just as simple as you suggested.

"When you go looking for problems, you will find them... They may not be the problems you went looking for!"

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

I find a Dayton Superior product brochure of wind-turbine products, and in it, they have all-threaded rebar for use as anchor bolts, and they're all left-hand thread, but it doesn't say why:
"Dayton Superior offers anchor bolts in Grade 75 (W6), Grade 95 (W9) and 150 ksi (W3) strengths ...Bolts are available in #6 to #24 sizes...All bars have left-hand thread. Bars are fully threaded and available in any length up to 60 feet."

The threads in question are not a conventional bolt-thread pattern.

I just now sent an inquiry in to them to ask, see if we get a response!

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

(OP)
Thanks!

"When you go looking for problems, you will find them... They may not be the problems you went looking for!"

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

Very interesting topic. I found this on wikipedia and think it may be the reason why:

In a situation where neither threaded pipe end can be rotated to tighten/loosen the joint, e.g. in traditional heating pipes running through multiple rooms in a building. In such a case, the coupling will have one right-handed and one left-handed thread

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screw_thread

I just don't know exactly how they make the rest of that connection.

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

(OP)
Maybe BigTomHanks is on to something. I looked up a couple wind turbine base patents, and the ~64 large left hand bolts pass through a massive base of concrete, to a ring on the bottom side of the base. Can't tell if the other end of the re-bar is right hand thread. But, one of the stated purposes of the patents is to provide compression. Maybe its also helpful during assembly, and during service to resist the wind forces blowing the tower from all directions better? The link BigTomHanks gave also has another link with an interesting animation:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precession_%28mechani...

"When you go looking for problems, you will find them... They may not be the problems you went looking for!"

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

Vandalism resistiant?

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

it'll be interesting to find out why ...

i can't see it myself ... why not RH threads with a locking feature (if there is some loosening effect from loads)

but it is a tricky design ... how to make sure they don't strip the buried thread ...

Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

I assume these are post-tensioned anchors? From a search on "left hand threads in post-tensioned anchors" I find many references to LH threads used because of the grout pumped into the center of the tendons. LH threads allow disconnecting the grout connection without loosening other components. I'm not a civil, so take a look for youselves...

https://www.google.com/search?q=post-tensioned+anc...

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

As Greg says, my experience is that when strange non-standard designs are used where "standard" items could be used, it is to prevent the use of "standard" items. This could be for safety reasons so someone cannot install the wrong grade of nut, for example. Sometimes it is just to force customers to buy parts from the OEM at inflated prices. The left-hand thread is a very obvious signal that "this is not standard".

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

I think that Compositepro's statement "...This could be for safety reasons so someone cannot install the wrong grade of nut,..." may have some merit.

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

(OP)
These are post tensioned anchors. But after a bit more research myself, I think there is little doubt RossABQ has provided the answer.
Never having been present at the building of such a base, I cvisualize how the process is actually performed.

"When you go looking for problems, you will find them... But they may not be the problems you went looking for!"

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

I'm still not seeing a reason why they would be left-handed. In doing the search for "left hand threads in post-tensioned anchors", I'm finding left-handed bars available, but they seem to be equally or more available in right-hand. One of the references is talking about a coupling, not a rod, that is left-hand-threaded. Of course, regular nuts and bolts are available to some extent in left-handed-thread, but you don't normally use them without some specific reason.

Note that none of these bars are furnished in left-right stud-type configuration, where one end is threaded one way, the other end the other way. It's one direction or the other the full length. The threads are already a non-standard configuration, it would seem, so little issue of a nut mix-up.

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

(OP)
Like I said, I cant visualize how its actually done, maybe its "just the way it was patented" or something obscure like that?

"When you go looking for problems, you will find them... But they may not be the problems you went looking for!"

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

As a few others have stated, I believe it is just for safety reasons. Prevents other nuts/couplers/rods on the construction site from being used.

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

Compisiepro had it right.

ASTM F1554
I believe there are three grades, and the washers and nuts also have to meet the grades... thus .....

"ASTM F1554 is the newest construction fastener specification developed by the American Society for Testing and Materials and covers steel anchor bolts intended for anchoring structural supports to concrete foundations. Chemical requirements, mechanical properties, and dimensional tolerances are all covered under the F1554 specification"

Charlie
www.facsco.com

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

ASTM F1554 uses Unified Coarse Thread series, Class 1A or 2A fit, or 8-thread series. This is per the -07 version. I don't see any mention of left or right hand in the standard. Note that it applies to anchor bolts, not to threaded rebar.

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

Also, RossABQ is right IF they are hollow self drilling anchors, however I am almost positive they wouldn't be.

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

(OP)
Being an electrical guy, these civil and mechanical concepts are tough for me to wrap my mind around.

Here is one explanation I have been able to find.

http://www.pat2pdf.org/patents/pat20090044482.pdf Link

"When you go looking for problems, you will find them... But they may not be the problems you went looking for!"

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

Someone mentioned to me that meeting that standard is insured by using left hand fasteners. An anchor with right hand thread would be a warning...
But someone else just mentioned that you can tighten the bolt without it coming loose in the resin used to secure the anchors in the cage. So maybe I don't know.


"The "Kelislipped" Anchor is installed in the usual manner. The nut can be wrench tightened by hand without risk of rotating the anchor within the cured resin."

I'll just read then, but it's a fun post

Charlie
www.facsco.com

RE: Simple question, not so simple to find answer?

I see left-hand threads wherever turnbuckles are involved. Any such beasts or two-threaded mechanisms used in concrete foundations? Either in the foundation itself or tooling that installs the anchor bolts?
I think I get the post-tensioning principle, but I've no experience in the civil sector. Just guessing that the tooling that actually installs it is standardized to have the RH thread in the machine, and the LH thread on the anchor. Then just drive the anchor nut and everything gets tighter as you go...
So, how do the post-tensioning machines work anyway?

STF

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources