×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

(OP)
Part 1 of AISCM ASD 9th Edition tabulates properties for combined sections.

I know the general practice is to weld the beams to form the combined sections.

However, is there a method, procedure, or calculation, to determine bolt size and spacing for joining two beams so they may be considered a combined sections (i.e their moment of inertia may be combined)?

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

Your standard mechanics of materials text should cover this. The standard equation is q=VQ/I where q is the shear flow required per unit length that must be transferred from one section of a beam to another so they act together.

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

Shear flow will govern in primarily shear and bending loaded members. However, there are also requirements if it's a built up column to control local buckling. I'm assuming they're listed in the AISC code. We've got three or four pages of it in CISC S16.

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

(OP)
Thank you for the replies. Good information.

I found shear flow in my mechanics of material by Beer. Looking forward to doing the math.

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

Depending on how complex your shapes are, the math is really quite simple. Recently I needed to stitch weld a beam to a channel, the calculation took only a few minutes to complete.

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

(OP)
SteelPE, I am finally getting back to this. If I could exploit your expertise again to quickly check my calc below:

Combined Section W12 x 40 on bottom and C15 x 33.9 bolted on top of it (long side of C15 x 39.9 up)

Input

Beam 1: W12 x 40

I1 = 310 in^4
A1 = 11.8 in^2
yc1 = 11.94 in / 2 = 5.97 in

Beam 2: C15 x 33.9

I2 = 315 in^4
A2 = 9.96 in^2
yc2 = yc1 + 15 / 2 = 19.4 in

Shear Load: V = 10.3 kip
Bolts: 5/8” dia. A325 with 30 ksi allowable per AISCM Table I-D

Calculation

The centroid of the combined section is( as measured from the bottom of the W12 x 40):

yc = A1 * yc1 + A2 * yc2 / (A1 + A2) = 12.1 in

Using parallel axis theorem,

Ic1 = I1 + (yc – yc1)^2 * A1 = 310 in^4 + (12.1 – 5.97)^2 * 11.8 in^2 = 759 in^4
Ic2 = I2 + (yc2 – yc)^2 * A2 = 315 in^4 + (19.4 – 12.1)^2 * 9.96 in^2 = 846 in^4

I_comb_sect = Ic1 + Ic2 = 1605 in^4

Q = (yc2 – yc) * A2 = 72.8 in^3

q = V * Q / I_comb_sect = 5.6 kip / ft

Abolt = (PI/4) * dbolt^2 = 0.31 in^2

V_bolt_allow = 30 ksi X 0.31 in^2 = 9204

s_bolt_min = V_bolt_allow / q = 19.7 inch

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

Provide a cross section.

BA

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition


Beam 1: W12 x 40

I1 = 310 in^4
A1 = 11.8 in^2
yc1 = 11.94 in / 2 = 5.97 in

Beam 2: C15 x 33.9

I2 = 315 in^4
A2 = 9.96 in^2
yc2 = yc1 d1 + 15 / 2 = 19.4 okay in

Shear Load: V = 10.3 kip
Bolts: 5/8” dia. A325 with 30 ksi allowable per AISCM Table I-D

Calculation

The centroid of the combined section is( as measured from the bottom of the W12 x 40):

yc = A1 * yc1 + A2 * yc2 / (A1 + A2) = 12.1 in

Using parallel axis theorem,

Ic1 = I1 + (yc – yc1)^2 * A1 = 310 in^4 + (12.1 – 5.97)^2 * 11.8 in^2 = 759 in^4
Ic2 = I2 + (yc2 – yc)^2 * A2 = 315 in^4 + (19.4 – 12.1)^2 * 9.96 in^2 = 846 in^4

I_comb_sect = Ic1 + Ic2 = 1605 in^4

Q = (yc2 – yc) * A2 = 72.8 73.1? in^3

q = V * Q / I_comb_sect = 5.6 kip / ft

Abolt = (PI/4) * dbolt^2 = 0.31 in^2

V_bolt_allow = 30 ksi X 0.31 in^2 = 9204

s_bolt_min = V_bolt_allow / q = 19.7 inch

Looks good to me except as noted.

BA

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

(OP)
Thanks BA, I appreciate it.

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

To prevent buckling, the top flange of the channel will have to be laterally braced. Because of lack of symmetry, it might not hurt to brace the top flange of the WF as well, although it is completely in tension by calculation.

BA

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

(OP)
BA, Thanks, yeah I have been using the formulas in AISCM Chapter F for this. Is this the right way to do this?

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

Don't know. I'm Canadian.

BA

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

You would do well to actually work on understanding your problem in a fundamental way, rather than being a blind follower of some obtuse code which you don’t really understand either. You would also do well to explain the reasons for what you are trying to do with that combined section and insistence on bolting; because without a really good explanation and reason for what you are trying to do, anyone in their right mind would think/say that was the worst combined section they had ever seen. Give us a clue as to what the heck you are trying to do; loading, span length, supports, means of bracing, type of structure which dictates those two sections, etc. etc. Just running a few calcs. which don’t have any major math errors, doesn’t make for good design. BA is a very good teach and mentor, but maybe a little too kind and easy going, on you. The calc. is correct, I have very little doubt about that if he says so, but there are still a dozen details that go unanswered, since you didn’t ask, didn’t even know to ask. How do you intend to brace that combined member? How efficient is that combined member when that little top flange of 15C will be buckling or at Fy, when the rest of the section is working at 15% of Fy? Is there a better way to detail this? Many times two rolled shapes are not the best answer.

RE: Combined Sections in AISCM ASD 9th Edition

(OP)
dhengr,

Thanks for the feedback.

I was not aware the Manual of Steel Construction, Allowable Stress Design, 9th Edition was an obtuse code.

Anyway, the application is assembling a purchased enclosure provided with C Channels onto a skid frame composed of W flange beams. Bolting is preferred so they may be shipped separate. Loading is from lifting which is about eight point loads. The W flange beams on the bottom are sized for the whole lifting load but I wanted a basis for bolt spacing.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources