Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
(OP)
I have a situation where a subcontractor is designing a structure to be attached to our system (a moving vehicle). Per the requirements from our customer, their structure needs to withstand a certain vibration profile (broadband with narrow band spikes). However, we are unable to share the details of the profile with the subcontractor for a variety of reasons. The sub, therefore, wants to provide us with the natural frequencies of their structure. Is there a way to take their natural frequencies and determine if the structure meets the given vibe profile? (My initial thought is "no," but I'm assuming I'm missing something.)
I greatly appreciate any help any of you vibe experts can provide.
I greatly appreciate any help any of you vibe experts can provide.






RE: Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
What are you trying to work out, the worst case deflection?
--
JHG
RE: Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
Normally, I would think I'm working out stresses in the structure caused by the vibrations. If this was my own structure, I'd be running a modal and then a vibration analysis based on the inputs defined in the vibe profile, review the stresses, and compare them to the strength of the material. The customer's spec simply says that the various structures need "to meet their performance requirements when subjected to the given vibe profile"; the only "performance requirements" for the structure while subjected to the vibe profile is the stress safety factor requirement.
Does that help? ('Cause I'm still thoroughly confused.)
RE: Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
So I guess my point is: getting the frequencies of their system may not be enough: the system as a whole (along with the unbalanced forces) must be part of the analysis.
RE: Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
Thank you very much for your response. That's just what I was thinking. Their natural frequency results will just tell me if the applied vibration profile will have a magnification issue like you said. The stresses at other frequencies (steady-state amplitude?) could still be unacceptably high, though, right?
RE: Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
That’s certainly a possibility. But what worries me about any sort of comparison like you are talking is: it may not take into account a localized affect (that’s why I talked about modeling the whole system). Let me give you an example of what I am talking about: recently I modeled a foundation system that had a compressor sitting on it. The entire foundation had a frequency that wasn’t anywhere near the forcing frequency (for any mode). Sounds like it would be ok right? Well, a portion of my foundation was shaking like crazy in the computer model. The reason for that was a portion of the mat that spanned between the piles had a different natural frequency that got pretty close to the forcing frequency.
So although we are talking situations here: I think/hope you catch my drift. Your model needs to be something that can capture every possible motion.
RE: Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
Apart from actually running the vibe profile against the model (which they can't do because they can't have the profile and I can't do (easily) because I don't have the model (and theirs isn't compatible with our FE system, etc.)), I think I'm a bit stuck.
RE: Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
Note also, that no mounting structure is ever infinitely rigid, despite our claiming it. So when this "structure" is attached to the vehicle, how is it going to change its, or the vehicle's, natural frequencies?
TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Need help writing a question or understanding a reply? forum1529: Translation Assistance for Engineers
RE: Vibe "analysis" by natural frequencies only?
And the customer spec is vague regarding "withstanding." It just says that components shall meet their performance requirements when subjected to the vibration profiles given. The only performance requirements I have for the structure is that it must meet a certain safety factor. No "life" requirements, etc.