×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame
14

4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

(OP)
Has anyone ever designed concrete on metal decks bearing on wood frame construction. The architect seems to think its OK?? Any tips will be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

As long as its designed for the load, whats it matter what the support is? A column designed to hold 1000 lbs will do it as good as a column designed to hold 1000 lbs. Note I left out the materials.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

(OP)
The building code is silent on this combination.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

There have been other discussions on the subject here.

I do not like to do it. but if it needs to be, I would consider a glulam beam that you couls camber for the dead load of the concrete.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
http://mmcengineering.tripod.com

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

(OP)
These are load bearing wood walls supporting 4 concrete metal deck floors

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

What is the load at the lowest level? What would the walls need to be to support? If the design, servicability, and code works, why the issue? If you cant get a design to work, then there is your out.

As a structural engineer we are to take the loads, review the code, design the members, and then report that its ok, If its not ok, then suggest a different material to the Arch.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

(OP)
Only in the talking phase. Architect is trying to have high ceilings with no joists. Deck would span wall to wall.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

Precast hollow core slabs supported on wood framing are commonly used in some Canadian cities for three and four story apartments. I don't care for it and have not seen it used in my area but it seems to be quite popular in Winnipeg, Manitoba.

BA

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

So the arch wants to use wood bearing walls with steel decking and concrete to act as a floor?

I understand your situation. It's something you haven't necessarily seen before so you don't know if there is some obscure part of the code that prohibits this form of construction. To tell you the truth... I don't know if there is. Please inform us if you find something.

Something you might be concerned with...... how is the construction process going to go? In a normal platform construction you would construct your walls, floor joists, decking and then begin the process again until you reached the top. In this instance you would have to construct the walls, put down the decking, pour concrete, wait for it to harden and then start over again. It almost appears as if you have multiple trades (I'm not sure the wood guys would do the decking and pour the concrete). Seems like a great way to slow the construction process.

local bending of the top plates may be a concern as well. Normally the joists line up with the studs eliminating plate bending..... you may have to check that here.

Good luck.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

IBC 2009 2304.12 - refers to NDS for long-term load deflection issues

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

There will be a lot of weight falling down on the firemen when the thing catches fire.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

Down under we have white ants (protective measures are more like prevention, one can never guarantee), so it is a no no to have masonry let alone concrete floors supported on timber stud walls... fire would also ensure a swift collapse.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

Does it make any sense to use load bearing light gage metal stud walls instead of wood? That may help some long-term creep issues and just "feels better."

"We shape our buildings, thereafter they shape us." -WSC

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

I hear a lot of 'don't like it' which I can understand. I guess my question (with out trying to hijack the thread) is why?
I see fire issue and slow construction but say the beams/posts met/surpassed the fire requirements, are there other concerns?

EIT
www.HowToEngineer.com

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

Why!? Because at the lowest level you will end up with a 2X6 @ 3" o.c bearing walls! There is a reason why its called 'light framed construction', because its light! A metal deck/slab will need to be around 9" for an assumed 20 foot span. A 14” wood truss or a 12” Hambro composite joist on metal stud load bearing are much better options for that span. Its not worth the extra cost (foundations, seismic lateral, shoring) to increase the DL by 100 PSF for 3”-5” of extra ceiling height. Additionally, now you have space in the joists or trusses to run MEP.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

In part, because wood tends to creep, crush, rot, and deflect under heavy weight, which concrete transmits, and concrete does not do well with deflecting supports, causing a lot more cracking in the concrete, and allowing penetration of water to deteriorate the wood support for the concrete.

Kind of a can of worms you might say...

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
http://mmcengineering.tripod.com

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

Biggest issues I can think of is
1) make sure you check bearing.
2) Limit thermal bridging to prevent condensation
3) use P.T. wood in contact with the floor deck.

I think the code is usually clear that any wood in contact with concrete or masonry need to be P.T. Note that sometimes a P.T. wood plate is bigger than it's cousin, the non treated stud because it is still wet or is stored outside. This sometimes causes issues...

______________
MAP

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

Use wood framing with wood floors, or LB-metal studs will work with your concrete-on-deck floor.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

Some municipalities do not allow wood construction over a certain height / number of stories. Give your local building inspector a phone call.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

If it's on the talking phase, then it is time to talk the architect on the nonsense of this combination. Concrete or masonry on wood is on the no-fly list of my ventures.

RE: 4 Story Building w/ Metal Deck on Wood Frame

If the Architect want's thin floor and roof lines on top of wood framing, suggest CLT (cross-laminated timber) panels. The first ever US design specs just came out and are free to download at the Wood Council: http://www.awc.org/

They are essentially two-way gluelam "slabs".

In Russia building design you!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources