×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Help with potential energy quandry
3

Help with potential energy quandry

Help with potential energy quandry

(OP)
Hi everyone, I have a problem to solve, imagine your standing on a platform 7 ft in the air and the only way to get to the ground is a stair stringer that raises and lowers in front of you rotating on an axis on the end of the platform on which you are standing. In the raised position the stair stringer is perpindicular to the platform and lowered it extends to the ground. Now here is the problem; the stairs used to be raised and lowered with a hydraulic pump system, now I am faced with the task of moving it with a non powered system ie. Torsion springs or some other means of stored energy. What I need to know is if there Is a method that I could use to lower the ladder and store enough energy to facilitate its return with little or effort. Any help or guidence would be greatly appreciated. Thanks

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

A counterbalace using a weight and pulley is common.

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

Hi mlong4765

Can you provde a sketch of the situation and some physical sizes/ masses of the stringer etc

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

(OP)
Sure I can whip up a basic sceth for you, as for the exact masses of the stairs I would have to track down the exact weights and sizes, but a ball park figure would be, stairs are about 350 lbs and dimensions would be 8.5ft long 3 ft wide and side of the stringers are about 1 ft tall.

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

(OP)
P.S I forgot to mention the platform is mounted on the front of a piece of mobile mining equipment

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

The link doesn't work for me

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

Make the stair a ladder that moves in a vertical plane like the bottom portion of a building fire escape. Like compositepro says, counter-balance it.

Ted

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

(OP)
Ok ill copy and paste it from my computer

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

(OP)
So far theese are good suggestions guys, thanks

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

(OP)
I like the idea of a counterbalance system but I was hoping to find something a little more rigid, I'm not sure how that would work on a piece of equipment that travels up to 30 mph through rough conditions.

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

Don’t most of these have a fixed stairway to within about 3 or 4' of the ground, then a flexible hanging ladder which can bend out of the way if it hits anything near the ground? My guess is that these are made up of treads which are attached to two very heavy pieces of cable, as stiles, so they are not too flexible as a person climbs them, but will bend out of the way if they hit something. Then fixed hand grabs (grab irons) can be reached from the ground for climbing these first 3 or 4 steps, and transition to the fixed stairway.

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

I can't see a cable/counterweight system surviving long on what appears to be a mining truck.

I'm thinking a torsion bar on or near the hinge line to balance most of the weight of the deployable stair, with a gas cylinder or two to fine tune the force required to lift it manually, and a sturdy latch to hold it in the stowed position.

I'm guessing the torsion bar will need to extend behind the plane of the paper for a fair distance, i.e. along the frame horn for a couple of feet.



Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

(OP)
@dhengr. What your referring to is a typical step used on heavy equip/ haul trucks, this ladder system was designed to eliminate that step and make an easier mounting process, the ladder system works great, but for reasons I can't mention the mine manager wants to replace the powered system with a manual/ un-powered system and that is my dillema

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

(OP)
@Mike Halloran. That sounds like a viable solution, and is similar to what I had in mind except I left out the torsion bar and instead had just a torsion spring system, I just wasn't sure how much force would be applied to the stairs on the return cycle. Is there a way I can latch the stairs in the down position and initiate the return cycle by simply unlatching the stairs or am I going to need some manual assistance with raising the stairs

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

I suggest some caution about implementing anything that moves when you unlatch it, because someone will find a way to get hurt when it moves. ... and they will have no trouble finding a product liability lawyer.

Regardless, you are ahead of the game if you have a suitable stair already designed. Given its weight, CG, and geometry, it's a relatively pleasant engineering exercise to work out the forces and torques required to move it over its range of rotation, either graphically or with Excel or whatever numerical hammer you have.

Actually, since you probably already have a physical stair available to mess around with, it might be quicker to mock up the truck's landing platform, and alternate design sessions with physical hacking sessions, measuring what happens and raiding the local junkyards for parts. Work fast, but be careful.




Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

(OP)
Thanks again for the advice Mike, I think I will move forward with this design and see where it takes me, i'll post the end results later.

RE: Help with potential energy quandry


I vote for the counterweight idea.

The problem with the torsion spring or bar is that you reduce your input energy by only 1/2 . Ideally the counterweight is theoretically much superior; you fight friction only.

Perhaps a little more thought should go into this before you discard it.

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

Start with a graph of force (if linear motion) or torque (rotational motion) vs. position that must be counterbalanced. Superimpose a graph of the input provided by the counterbalancing system.

Springs work well for linear systems. A garage door is a great example of this, where the weight diminishes linearly as the door opens.

Counterweights work best for rotating systems, as they match the non-linear (sinusoidal) function of force as the system goes through its range of motion.

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

a couple of thoughts ...

1) you show a single staircase deploying. maybe it's just a sketch, but i'd suggest using a double folding staircase ... ie one stage deploys, anf then 2nd (folded onto the first) deploys, this'd reduce the stowed height; but maybe you've already thought of this (deploying only 1/2 the staircase ?)

2) instead of unpowered, maybe a simple mechanical system with a lot of advantage ?

3) how are you going to inter-connect this with the truck ? presuably you don't want the truck moving with the stairs down ? presumably a sticker to this affect would be treated with the utmost distain by your operators ? so you need an interlock, presumably with the transmission, yes?

4) it looks as though it would be convenient to hide the counter-weight under the fixed staircase.

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

Dhengr mentioned a cable rail ladder. I have seen short ones on bucket trucks here. It looks like the cable is plenty stiff, but a person cantilevered from a rung necessarily bends the cable inward, so the ladder rails assume some curvature, which has to make the ladder into a serious knee-knocker. ... not something you'd want to climb regularly.

But suppose you made a cable rail _stair_? I.e., use two or four cables, mounted at a slant, with steps level, or level as could be. ... or one pair of vertical cables per step, cables of stepped lengths in an array.

Or, this might involve payments to the patent holder, a Lapeyre Stair using a single fat slanted cable as its backbone?

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

I have seen something similar on the back of the Marine Corps 7-ton trucks (MTVR). As rb1957 suggested they fold in half. It is a completely manual design. A quick google search did not come up with any detailed drawings of the ladder but it is worth looking into. This link shows a picture of what I mean, see the truck on the left.

Link

Doug

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

Maybe RB idea of folding stairs might work if keeping the CM of the folding setup fixed vertically so that the PE remains constant , which solves the problem, but you need a mechanism like a scissor jack to implement it .

The key is keeping the CM fixed vertically, which is less demanding than keeping t fixed ( as in a counterweight setup.

RE: Help with potential energy quandry

Or simply just rotate the stair with a folding counter "stair " link of equal weight that rotates opposite using a pair of meshed pinion gears at the fixed pivot.
Now you have the PE fixed and all you need is a handcrank to rotate one of the stair pieces, just overcoming friction.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources