×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Strip footings and residental slabs

Strip footings and residental slabs

Strip footings and residental slabs

(OP)
Hi folks!
Ive seen this to many times and I was always wondering wich system is "right".
Foundation system - strip footings under bearing masonry walls
Groundfloor slab - cast over strip footings or between them on compacted fill material.

Wich solution is right?
Maybe dumb thing to ask since it seems that contractors do this in both ways but I was always leaning toward the "in-between" solution.
Your thoughts and ideas...

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

Neither system is "right". Either would be acceptable under appropriate conditions. The more common for separately placed slab and footing is the "in filled" condition. For the 2nd condition where the slab is "sandwiched" between the footing and wall, it is usually done as a monolithic slab with a thickened edge condition that serves as the "footing".

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

One many basements, single and muti-family are built with a strip footing poured and the back or concrete wall then is placed on the strip footing and the slab poured later after utilities and drainage is installed. It is generally a region method and some local codes require the basement slab to be poured on the strip footing and have 4" of the slab in contact with the wall.

The advantage is getting the footing in quickly and providing a hard, level base to build the wall on quickly. In a cold climate, the basement can be excavated, strip footing poured and walls up an ready (4 days) for capping the first deck. In cold weather, the furnace can be hung from the deck to provide heat when the framing is dome and closed up. It make the interior ready for all trades to work under good conditions efficiently.

The walls are braced until backfilled and the basement slab is poured later (usually at the same time as the garage slab and sidewalks.

A big factor is the speed of construction when there is variable weather (cold, sudden storms, etc.).

Dick

Engineer and international traveler interested in construction techniques, problems and proper design.

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

(OP)
@Ron
WHat do you mean by "slab with a thickened edge condition that serves as the "footing"".
Can you post some sketch or drawing

@concretemasonry
Im not talking aboth basement slab. If this was the case I would probably choose to foundate all the structure on basement slab that would act as a raft.

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

Two advantages to Ron's detail:

1 There is only one pour instead of two, and

2. You only have to provide removable forms on one side of the footing.

These footings are found a lot wheere the bearing wall is at the very outside of the footing, but the reinforcing pattern is different.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
http://mmcengineering.tripod.com

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

Mike...I picked a detail off the internet. My detail uses hooked bars back into the slab.

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

(OP)
But your drawing is more a raft system than it is a strip footing!
All cast at once with reinforcing steel!

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

AnaAnt....in most cases in my area, the slab is essentially unreinforced so it really is not a "raft" or mat system. The reinforcement is only carried into the slab area to hold the inevitable perimeter crack together.

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

There are many solutions, but I think AnaAnt is right about the definition of a strip footing. Strip footings are not cast monolithically with a slab.

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

(OP)
@Ron
Ok, so you are providing minimum reinforcement steel to prevent shrinkge cracking.

@hokie66
Yes, this is why Im asking when "in-between or over" situation and never cast together if your having a strip foundation system.

When "cast over" you could say that strips act as end "supports" and at the same time slab is resting on the ground.
When cast "in-between" perimeter strips, its a clear situation - slab on grade, wich will hold partition walls, live load, dead loads (floor coverings).
But Im interested win your opinions, pros and cons...and which system to use and when....

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

As I said, there are many solutions, none of which are perfect. One thing though...casting a strip footing right up to floor level as shown on the left of your first picture is not wise. The footing should stop below the floor, with either the wall or slab starting there. Matching the top of the footing and floor level is asking too much of the builder.

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

Ron,
Do you use the thickened slab only on lightly loaded walls? Or, do you use the slab to resist the eccentricity caused by the wall being at the edge of the foundation. When we don't have the masonry wall directly on the footing, we have a thickened slab edge or concrete foundation wall sit on the continuous footing.

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

(OP)
@hokie66
Agree, but here the strips would be first casted.
Then later, ground slabs, between the strips. Strips would basicly serve as side formwork.
But here another thing that I see as a problem. Elastic settlement of strips.
If the settle eg.2cm, slabs wont follow and there could be hydroinsulation problems and crackings.

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

The solution you end up with will not only include your engineering input and experience, but also that of the contractor and wnat he is used to doing.

If you are worried about that differentialo settlement, then go to a crawlspace and eliminate the problem.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
http://mmcengineering.tripod.com

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

AnaAnt,
Yes, as I said, it is generally a poor detail, for many reasons. I can think of a couple of types of industrial facilities where that detail would be appropriate, but not for residential buildings.

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

(OP)
Hohie66 thanx for your response.
So you are in favour for "casted over strips" solution?

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

It is dependent upon many things. In my part of the country, highly plastic, expansive clays make some systems a poor choice. Slabs which are free to move allow with the soil can allow for expansion and settlement. Where stable soils underlie the slab, an integral method works well.
This is an older reference but cover the topic well:
http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?record_id=9804&...

RE: Strip footings and residental slabs

(OP)
@TXStructural
Thanx for the reference text.
This topic seems to be more oriented towards type I&II slabs (unreinforced and slightly reinforced).
Type III slabs are general raft systems where slab recives and transmits all load from superstucture to the ground.

Looking at drawings (pages 40,42 and 44) seems that all slabs are separated from foundations by an expansion joint.
Also on page 43, last sentense, its clearly stated that slab Type I&II should be "free of foundation walls, piers or footings, otherwise the slab is likely to experience flexural stresses wich it is not capable of resisting without cracking."
Questions to this quote: Is author saying this because of probable elastic settlement of footings, meaning it is better to keep footing and slab on ground /residentual slab)separated and allow them to behave independently in these cases?

Basicly footing and slabs should be cast as in the sketch attached.
What should be the width of the expansion joint or could the foundation and slab be casted seperatly (next to each other) but not connected by the reinforcement?



Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources