×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

(OP)
What mey be typical head loss of an AHU heating coil being fed at bottom in comparison to one fed at the top ? The medium being water.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

water direction is related to heat transfer, uniformity of heat distribution, eventually influences heat capacity, not pressure loss.

wrong direction of control valve is another story, but you are not mentioning control valve.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

Pressure drop will be the same.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

(OP)
I thought water flow should decrease as hot water going up in the coil get cooled, thus denser, thus affected by gravitation drawn downwards thwarting the upwards flow of the hot water. The coil pressure drop should in effect decrease, while pump static pressure drop increase. Is not vertically positioned heat coil bottom connection wrong in principle ?
Mixing valve being connected correctly.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

Conservation of mass; what goes in at a rate must come out at the same rate

TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

What you described is called stack effect within hydraulics, and such physical process indeed exists, but for water you would need at least several meters height difference for such effect to be measurable at all. 20 meters height difference at 20 degrees temperature difference gives about 2,5 kPa of stack effect, so you can get a picture.

Such an effect has influence on distribution heating pipework calculation in high-rise buildings.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

(OP)
Drazen, then, swapping pipes on a heating coil fed at bottom and giving problems (insufficient flow on an unknown reason) would scarcely improve the flow ? Such as now connection of the pipes cannot be the reason for the inadequate flow ?

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

yes.

going back to practical probabilities - if you change direction of waterflow it is possible that your control valve will receive flow in wrong direction, and whil i cannot be certain, i can suspect that could be cause of problem - if your problem only exists when you swap connections.

you mentioned in your previous post that "mixing valve is connected correctly", but correctness of mixing valve connection can directly depend on water flow, i.e what is correct in one flow direction can be incorrect in opposite flow direction.

mixing valves normally have symbols on their bodies which, first show whether they do hydraulic mixing or hydraulic diverting, second they show what are inlet and what are outlet port(s).

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

(OP)
The valve is ESBE, series MG, it can pass in any direction - what I deduce seeing the descriptions I found. Most important : the supply at bottom of a heating exchanger is not so critical as I asumed previously. Thank you !

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

(OP)
Just now I have found a picture of the same exchanger I believe - and fed at bottom as it is shown it should direct water against the air flow, so, all is connected correctly.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

YuriB, your concern is sound but you're missing the reasoning behind typical heating coil installation with supply at the bottom (on the air outlet side) and return at the top (on the upstream air side). Water velocity increases and flow directions change upon entering the coil. This tends to strip gases out of solution. Gases rise in an aqueous solution. Running water from top to bottom goes against this natural occurrence and could cause head loss and vapor binding. The difference in pressure drop due to density changes in the water from a hot (top) inlet to a warm (bottom) outlet is negligible. The addition of waterborne air issues and head loss due to flow against vapor bubble release/buoyancy is more substantial. Mathematically, the density of a 140°F return is 61.38 lb/ft3. A 180°F supply is 60.58°F. A typical coil might have 12" between inlet and outlet heights. The density difference would cause a pressure difference of 0.006 psid, which really is negligible relative to coil pressure drop and other factors.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

(OP)
Water velocity increases and flow directions change upon entering the coil.

What do you mean ?
I am sorry that I cannot post the picture I drawn. The installation have performed some absolute morones, that is the problem.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

What do I mean, what do YOU mean? "The installation have performed some absolute morones, that is the problem." You lost me there.

What I meant was that a typical coil might have 3/4 inch piping to and fro, but reduce to 3/8 inch at the inlet and outlet fittings. This is by design, as a velocity increase lessens the laminar boundary layer and provides better heat transfer. For a 3 gpm coil (as an example), our 2.2 feet per second velocity would increase to about 9 fps through the coil tubing. The water then turns 180° a few times before exiting.

So with this hot water, the big rise in velocity, and the bends through a coil, gases can tend to leave solution.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

(OP)
We have received a cite to service recently and a more idiotic istallation I did never seen.

The heat exchangers in AHU's have two vertical collectors (possibly, one such HE may have 3/4 pipe collectors) feeding between them a dozen or so coils (maybe, one HE having them of 3/8 diameter). But as there are many of them, water velocity in them should rather decrease.

RE: head loss caused by wrong inlet /outlet connection of heat exchanger ?

(OP)
Why there is not allowed post editing ?

To clear, I described in my previous post not the idiotic installation I mentioned, but AHUs in general.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources