×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Creating a Fillet Problem

Creating a Fillet Problem

Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
I need to create a fillet at the intersection between two solids and I'm having trouble because Solidworks thinks there is a gap between them. I've tried everything to get rid of this infinitesimal gap but its no good.

Does anyone have anykind of suggestions because every time I use the fillet command it tries to round the bottom of one of the solids instead of creating a fillet between them.
I

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

Try using the Face Fillet option and picking the two faces. If these two solids are separate bodies in the same part file then make sure the "Merge Results" box is checked.

- - -Updraft

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
Where is the merge results box? I can't find it.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

A Fillet cannot be used between two bodies (non-merged features).
The Merge option is available when creating features.

So you will have to go back and edit the feature which was created last (of the two bodies being filleted) and enable the Merge option, before adding the fillet.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
The last feature that created was a knitted solid, and I checked the merge entities checkbox. Is that what you are talking about? because I wasn't exactly sure what it did.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

If you still don't have it working - can you attach the sldprt file here?

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
@rollupswx I can't post the file because it's confidential.

@CorBlimeyLimey I looked at both of the help links you posted, and neither was really helpful. The merge checkbox in the knit command appears to just merge similar geometry, not merge it with the base solid. The merge command for extruding doesn't help because I'm not extruding anything.

Since the problem seems to be that the face fillet command won't fillet between two different solids, which I think is silly. I tried combing the solids with Combine command but it failed due to unstated geometric problems, probably related to fact that their is an infinitesimal gap between the two solids.

So I'm sitting here unable to move forward.

Perhaps I could create the needed fillets while the knitted solid is still a bunch of surfaces, but that won't help with the gap between the two solids. Which will give me big headaches farther down the line.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

TerminusO,

It sounds like you are relatively new to SolidWorks. The problems you are having are unusual for a skilled user. If you are a new user I highly recommend that you invest in going through the excellent SolidWorks Tutorials (Help -> SolidWorks Tutorials).

If on the other hand you are an experienced user then you will need to find a way to share your file(s) with us. Perhaps you can recreate the same problem conditions on a new generic part and post that.

- - -Updraft

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
Yeah I haven't been using Solidworks for more than 8 months and I'm self taught, and I went through all the tutorials back when I started. I was formally trained in Pro-E so my Solidworks knowledge probably has some big gaps. I've only learned things as I've needed them to model things.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
I'll try to recreate the FUBAR situation in my other file in an example file.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

It would help if you explain what you do have in the way of solids & surfaces, and how they were created.
Why is there an "infinitesimal" gap? Can you not adjust the model to eliminate the gap?
Could you use a Sweep instead of a Fillet?

It's difficult to suggest how to achieve what you want, without knowing what you have.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
I created a surface by lofting between a bunch of different cross-sections and then used the surface extend command to extend that loft down to a surface that was created using the surface offset command (Set to zero offset), which I did because the extended surface loft slightly overhangs the face and I needed to knit that surface with other surfaces to create a surface so that I could use the extend surface command's up to surface function (because it only seems to accept a single surface). You'd think that having the extended surface coming down to the surface created by the zero offset surface would perfectly meet the solidbody but it doesn't, when I zoom in it seems there is the 'tiny gap' my newly created surface and the body.

Is there some sort of inherent geometric error in the functions I'm using? Am I doing this in an ass backward way? Am I just stupid?

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

try combine or merge to make one body then use fillet.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

Terminus0,
Instead of Up to Surface, could you have used the Up to Body option?
Is the gap measure-able, or is it just a visual graphics limitation?

It sounds like you are trying to fillet between a surface & a body or other surface ... both conditions are not possible.
Can you thicken the surface and then use the Combine function? If so you should then be able to add the fillet.
If the gap actually exists, can you extend the surface into the solid body (from which the zero-offset was created), and then thicken & combine?

Too may variables and too little information.

Are you just stupid? I doubt it, but then again there is yet too little information supplied to form a conclusive opinion. poke lol



RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
@saf12 I've tried using Combine it just fails for unstated geometric reasons.

@CorBlimeyLimey By the time I'm trying to fillet, both objects are solids. I've knitted together the surfaces into a solid.

I guess then my main problem is not doing the fillet

It is combining these two bodies.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

[quote]I guess then my main problem is... ....is combining these two bodies. [\quote]

Can you make up a dummy part that exhibits the same behavior without giving away any proprietary information.
(I can tell you from my experience when I have users do this exercise they often come up with the solution in the process.)

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
I was trying to do that yesterday, but I has real trouble replicating the same issue as in the real file.

I'll keep working on it.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

TerminusO,

Can take your real file and cut away the proprietary features, leaving only the problem area, and save that as a Parasolid and post that? Even though it would not show us how you made the features in that area, it would at least show us the result and we might still be able to help you.

Giving us something is better than nothing.

- - -Updraft

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

Quote (Terminus0)

By the time I'm trying to fillet, both objects are solids. I've knitted together the surfaces into a solid.
If the surfaces were successfully knitted, there would be no gap. A solid would not be created if the knitted surfaces were not watertight. i.e. No gaps.

Can you copy the part and then change the profiles, to get around the proprietary data, but leave enough to still show the problem? Even an image of the problem area might help.

Do the contents of the Solid Bodies & Surface Bodies folders match what you expect?

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

When you play with surfaces it's sometimes better to extend them through another surface and trim it back. That way you won't run into issues like this. Surf back through your feature manager and fix the issue there.

Dan

www.eltronresearch.com
Dan's Blog

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
Went back through and trimmed it instead of doing up to surface, didn't seem to help. Gap still exists, even between it and the surface I supposedly trimmed it to.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

Do you have active subscription? If so maybe your VAR could offer some help.

Do you belong to a local User Group? Maybe someone from there could take a look.

To offer more pertinent advice, the actual model features need to be interrogated. The parasolid file shows the problem, but not the underlying cause.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
Update, I finally got those two solids to combine, it only involved redrawing half the imported part manually.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
But I'm still having problems using the fillet command on this solid.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

Have you tried changing the radius of the fillet? Sometimes this will work.
B.E.

The good engineer does not need to memorize every formula; he just needs to know where he can find them when he needs them. Old professor

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
I've tried making the radius much smaller, thinking that the program might be failing because the radius was too big but it didn't work either.

I'm thinking is fillet even the best command to do what I'm trying to do?

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
Here is a parasolid of the section of the part I'm trying to put a fillet on.

http://files.engineering.com/getfile.aspx?folder=f...

(For some reason they uncombined when I made a parasolid of it, so you need to use combine again to attempt to use the Fillet command)

If anyone can put a fillet around the base of at least .1 inches or up. I will give them a high five.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
I think I may have figured it out, I needed to do the variable fillet command.

Well that makes me feel like forty seven million times better.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

The Import Diagnostics tool found & healed several Face problems, but there are still a few problems with faces on the RH side of the Imported1 body.

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

(OP)
Yeah, I've had some wonky geometry plague me for a while. Do you have any advice on how to deal with it?

Other than go back to when it was generated and try to fix it?

RE: Creating a Fillet Problem

I do very little surfacing, but you should be able to use the Delete & Patch and Delete & Fill functions. Failing that you may have to cut out bad portions and add new surfaces.
Sometimes even running through the export as parasolid & Import Diagnostics a couple of times will fix the problem.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources