×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?
3

What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

(OP)
Is there a good definition somewhere that determines what is the difference between a transmission system and a distribution system?

When I think a distribution system, I usually think of lines coming out of substation that have all of the equipment mounted on poles (transformers and circuit switchers). I am dealing with a 33kV system that has no pole mounted equipment, and customer load and generators are connected via substations. This sounds more like sub-transmission to me. Any thoughts?

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

I would say that the difference between distribution, sub-transmission and transmission is determined by voltage level. In ANSI, this cutoff is 60kV for transmission voltages.

http://books.google.com/books?id=Lo3b0OQsy0MC&pg=PA5&lpg=PA5&dq=ansi+transmission+voltage&source=bl&ots=ruGhHqj7MZ&sig=4fKSfBURPhGd55V03HmEUCwC3Cg&hl=en&sa=X&ei=k6bQT833Osj10gHcy5zYDQ&ved=0CGgQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=ansi%20transmission%20voltage&f=false

Distribution voltages would generally be no higher than 34.5 kV and often more likely to be around 15kV. The definitions could change based on what types of loads are in the area as well (industrial vs. residential).

There are many "it depends" to your question. The local (or regional) regulatory board may ultimately define this, as well as how the utility is structured (regulated or de regulated). Many utility companies, for example, are no longer vertically integrated, and have split up into separate transmission or distribution companies.

As far as the pole mounted equipment analogy, I would not necessarily consider that a useful one. There are many installations that utilize pad mounted transformers and associated switchgear at distribution voltages up to 34.5 kV.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

NERC can't even tell us what is a transmission system, so how are we supose to know.

In general, a distribution system is radialy fed, and has many distributive taps. The lower voltage idea, is a dividing line that has no clear level. But generally in the US, 15 kV class and lower is not transmission, and 69 kV and above is not distribution. What is inbetween is anybody's guess.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

"But generally in the US, 15 kV class and lower is not transmission, and 69 kV and above is not distribution. What is inbetween is anybody's guess."

Two of the big utilities I worked for called 69kV and 45kV "Subtransmission".

old field guy

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Quote (Cranky108)

What is inbetween is anybody's guess.
And that's why we have 24kV transmission and 35kV distribution.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

I found this in the Standard Handbook for Electrical Engineers:

Distribution Systems: "Broadly speaking, 'distribution' includes all parts of an electric utility system between bulk power sources and the consumers service-entrance equipments... In general, a typical distribution system consists of (1) subtransmission circuits with voltage ratings usually between 12.47 and 245kV which deliver energy to the distribution substations; (2) distribution substations which convert the energy to a lower 'primary system' voltage for local distribution and usually include facilities for voltage regulation of the primary voltage; (3) primary circuits or 'feeders,' usually operating in the range of 4.16 to 34.5kV and supplying the load in a well-defined geographical area; (4) distribution transformers in ratings from 10 to 2500kVA which may be installed on poles, grade-level pads, or in underground vaults near the consumers and transform the primary voltages to utilization voltages; (5) secondary circuits at utilization voltage which carry the energy from the distribution transformer along the street or rear-lot lines; and (6) service drops which deliver the energy from the secondary to the user's service-entrance equipment."

Transmission Systems: "The function of the transmission system is the transmission of bulk power to load centers and large industrial users beyond the economical service range of the regular primary distribution lines."

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Transmission system - needs step-down transformer station to further reduce the voltage to distribution level. Like highways
Distribution system - step-down transformers convert the voltage to end user's level, 120V, 240V, 208, or 600V. Like local roads or county roads

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

a distribution system is a radial system.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

[quote a distribution system is a radial system][/quote]

Not always true. Some weak transmission is radial feed and some strong distribution is dual feed.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Distribution is the portion of the system where the typical customer is served through one last utity owned transformer. Transmission is the portion of the system where there are at least two utility owned transformers between there and the typical customer. Exceptions abound.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Distribution as in the name, is used to distribute energy to customers. Transmission as in the nams, is used to transmit energy over some distance.

So what do you call a 7 kV delta circuit connected with one source, and has two generation sources, and three energy consumers?

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

A mess.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Thank you david. We call it one of a kind.

Why is a gas distribution system called distribution? Or gas transmission called transmission? It's the same concept, except we use voltage level, not pressure in a pipe.

In the gas world they have a collector system, which we don't normally have (except renewables) because we have large generators connected directly to the transmission.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Quote:

One of a kind.

As never again or over my dead body?

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

As in a rare set of conditions we don't see happening again.

Mainly small hydros, care takers houses, and a 911 relay tower. Very sparce.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

To understand this issue perhaps we need to study the history of the utilities in the US.

In the US there are approximately 3,273 traditional electric utilities and around 1,738 nonutility power producers ranging from investor-owned, publicly-owned, cooperatives, and Federal/ Authorities (TVA, ACOE, Bureau of Reclamation, NYPA, BPA, etc). In few decades ago NERC grouped all utility in 8 regional organizations (PJM, WECC, NPCC, FRCC, MRO, etc).

It is not a surprise in the US there is not agreement to classifying distribution and transmission voltages since each utility is an independent entity many of then in operation long history before regulating agencies.

Even at the distribution level today there is several system voltages variation that survives after many years in operation such as 7.2/12.47-kV, 7.6/13.2kV, 7.9/13.8-kV, etc. In the pass, not only voltage levels were the issue but also different operating frequencies including DC. (NOTE: DC distribution services in NY City was suspended a few years ago)

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

No more Dc services? How will I charge my cell phone batteries?

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

The only legal way is using a balloon and a cat...peace

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

I am kind of agreeing that it is a mess. Beside “balloon and cat” either legal or illegal, may be another way to get the cell phone charged: What about wireless power from low cost power generation located oversee?

As preposterous as it may sound, it is never-the-less very true as the utility retired the DC service for more than 4,500 customers in NY City 5 years ago. See the press Release below.

http://www.coned.com/newsroom/news/pr20071115.asp

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Next thing is they will end two phase service.

Some small towns still use 4160, or 2400 V for distribution.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

distribution system is a radial system.
studies transmission system guidelines have totally different from studies on the distribution system.
The exceptions are handled separately.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Mr. odlanor

I see your point, but let us look at a hypothetical situation and test this.

Let's say that Utility XYZ was once vertically integrated, owning transmission, generation and distribution. The transmission system was fed by multiple sources and carried electrical energy over long distances. The distribution system was radial and distributed the electrical energy to the end customers. The transmission system (per the old Utility XYZ) was internally defined and segregated as >69kV. Anything less was internally defined as distribution.


After deregulation (or librilisation), the company is now split (or sold) and we have 2 Companies, (XYZ (Transmission) and ABC (Distribution)). Let's assume that the intent of the breakup of the vertically integrated Utility model was forced upon the utilities, with the goal of offering customers "choice", or to end "monopolistic" practices. There, once and for all, the powers that be have made the legal definition and division.


Along comes further regulation / deregulation as well as a push for green energy / distributed generation. We now have all kinds of independent power producers feeding into the Utility ABC system with wind farms, solar, bio mass, etc. What was once legally defined as a distribution Utility, having a radial system, now has multiple sources on it's network. Is it then, once again a transmission utility, subject to the rules and regulations of that definition?

My point is that the answer lies somewhere between the legal (or regulatory body) definition and the technical one.

To the OP, although I am generally skeptical of Wikipedia, it has a fairly good description of your original question.

Transmission

Distribution

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

How about this. I believe it was a US Supreme court ruling on the definition of pornography and one of the judges states "I know what it is when I see it." ;)...

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

All right, I might as well put in my 2 cents worth. I go along with pwrtran and davidbeach. The relevant difference is that distribution systems either serve the end customer directly (secondary distribution) or through one transformer (primary distribution). If you have to go another step, it is either subtransmission or transmission, depending on the voltage. But then, there are industrial customers that have transmission service and own their own power transformers. This doesn't make the transmission line a distribution line.

You could also classify the system by whether or not it has voltage regulators. We have one municipal client that has both 25 kV distribution and 25 kV subtransmission. The subtransmission is used to serve regulator stations which have distribution feeders.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?


what I know, when designing an independent power plant to be connected to a substation with local load , owned by a distribution system (radial system), the connection of our Transmission Line to the substation, has restrictions:
- if Substation lose connection with the distribution system , TL should be automatically disconnected ;
- TL can only be connected to the substation after system returned;
- TL may not reclose;









RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Quote:

NERC can't even tell us what is a transmission system

Oh, but they can. And will.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

So exactly when will NERC tell us what a transmission system is? Only after FERC orders them to, and not before.
100 KV and above.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

Read the FERC/NERC report on the Southwest outage. Somehow it won't surprise me if we find the 100kV threshold coming down to some lower value.

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

I read it. They even presented it at the last syncrophasor conference in Denver.

So 92 kV is also transmission?

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

It might become transmission. Or we might just have to prove that everything we have below 100kV has no impact on the BES. What ever, more compliance documentation activities coming our way. Can you say "unfunded mandate?"

RE: What is the difference betweem a transmission system and a distribution system?

NERC seems pretty funded..... looking around

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources