Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
(OP)
I'm having some troubles with a large scissor lift I custom designed.
The architect managed to build the ceiling height too low to match the distance between the main floor and basement level. If we had used a fixed canopy scissor lift the top would either rest two feet too low when lowered, or smash through the ceiling on the main floor. You can see the problem on the very left with purple and orange bracket dimensions.
Thus, I designed a articulating system to "catch" the canopy on support poles on its way down so it would remain flush with the top floor as the lift fully lowered.
The full up/down cycle worked fine when we had setup the lift in our shop. (Without the extension arms, nor canopy attached). However now, on-site when transition point occurs and the weight of the canopy (approx 4500lb) is removed the whole lift shudders slowly down the rest of the way. It is not a destructive shudder nor a "grinding" but more of a shuffling and shifting around as it lowers.
I initially was positive the problem was with the Counterbalance valves set to the wrong level. These were included in the cylinders as a safety device in case of a line breakage. However much to my chagrin, the lift did the same shuddering on the way UP as well as DOWN. Since our valves should be free flowing on the hydraulic extension stroke, I don't believe the problem is caused by the CB valves and might lay with a fault in the design of the support poles and the UHMW.
Is there a way a CB valve could be causing the problem on the way UP as well? I'm really starting to fear there may be another problem we're missing here, I had wished that it was just a matter of tuning the valves. What are your thoughts?
The architect managed to build the ceiling height too low to match the distance between the main floor and basement level. If we had used a fixed canopy scissor lift the top would either rest two feet too low when lowered, or smash through the ceiling on the main floor. You can see the problem on the very left with purple and orange bracket dimensions.
Thus, I designed a articulating system to "catch" the canopy on support poles on its way down so it would remain flush with the top floor as the lift fully lowered.
The full up/down cycle worked fine when we had setup the lift in our shop. (Without the extension arms, nor canopy attached). However now, on-site when transition point occurs and the weight of the canopy (approx 4500lb) is removed the whole lift shudders slowly down the rest of the way. It is not a destructive shudder nor a "grinding" but more of a shuffling and shifting around as it lowers.
I initially was positive the problem was with the Counterbalance valves set to the wrong level. These were included in the cylinders as a safety device in case of a line breakage. However much to my chagrin, the lift did the same shuddering on the way UP as well as DOWN. Since our valves should be free flowing on the hydraulic extension stroke, I don't believe the problem is caused by the CB valves and might lay with a fault in the design of the support poles and the UHMW.
Is there a way a CB valve could be causing the problem on the way UP as well? I'm really starting to fear there may be another problem we're missing here, I had wished that it was just a matter of tuning the valves. What are your thoughts?
-Kevin





RE: Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
RE: Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
I ask because this looks exactly like what one would expect something like this to be and since it's being added to a structure which has already been designed, and I assume approved for construction, that this is the sort of situation, with the restrictions mentioned above, that one might find themselves in.
Anyway, sorry if my speculation is way-off the mark, but as I said, I just had to ask
John R. Baker, P.E.
Product 'Evangelist'
Product Engineering Software
Siemens PLM Software Inc.
Industry Sector
Cypress, CA
http://www.siemens.com/plm
UG/NX Museum: http://www.plmworld.org/p/cm/ld/fid=209
To an Engineer, the glass is twice as big as it needs to be.
RE: Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
CompositePro,
The posts aren't anchored down yet, so the hope would be that they would find alignment when the lift finally reached the bottom. It seems to occur exactly when the weight of the canopy is removed which tells me if the problem is alignment then the canopy is somehow helping alignment.
What's surprising is that the poles don't seem to be lifting from the ground while the lift is shuddering while going up...
I intended for the slides to help support against buckling and to prevent "clanging" if the beams weren't perfectly straight and true. However, I suppose removing them might be one of the few options we have at this point that we could somewhat readily accomplish...
-Kevin
RE: Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
The weight of the canopy may be loading the bushings laterally so they "slide" with that load. When you remove the load, they don't have that constant force or friction.
Try bolting the poles down, the slight misalignment you will inevitably have, might also give you some lateral loading and possibly be a cure, if it doesn't bind.
Try lighter lubricant (oil).
Try adding a small weight offset to one side or one corner of the platform, and see if it still happens.
The redundant constraints (poles) make it very likely that not all 4 bushings are in contact simultaneously, and could promote the slip/stick condition.
RE: Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
John R. Baker, P.E.
Product 'Evangelist'
Product Engineering Software
Siemens PLM Software Inc.
Industry Sector
Cypress, CA
http://www.siemens.com/plm
UG/NX Museum: http://www.plmworld.org/p/cm/ld/fid=209
To an Engineer, the glass is twice as big as it needs to be.
RE: Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
Good observation, We'll definitely throw a few anchors and see how that affects things.
I had never heard the term stick/slip as a phenomenon but I'm certainly familiar. Now that you mention it, it certainly sounds like a possibility of what's occurring.
Lower friction lubricant also sounds like a worthwhile venture.
It seems like all indications point to problems other than the counterbalance valve. We'll be on the site tomorrow and I'll have to try these out, if anyone else has further thoughts do please share.
-Kevin
RE: Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
That's assuming that the free ends of the scissor aren't constrained by either the base or the bottom plate. A potential way out would be to put the wheels on the free ends in horizontal u-channels in the base and top plate to ensure that the free ends are always in the same plate as the pivot ends on the right side.
TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: Non-Traditional Scissor Lift Shuddering
There are actually no supports for the canopy on the surrounding concrete. The top and lower platform have identically sized platforms, thus anything used to support the canopy would interfere with the lower scissor lift platform as it traveled up through the opening. Definitely wish there was an ability to incorporate structure into the concrete but it had already been poured when we arrived.
IrStuff,
I'll take a look to see if the wheels are moving on the rollers, but from what I remember last Friday, the shuddering didn't seem severe enough to indicate a problem there. It's definitely a more of a "sloughing" then a rapid shudder. Big thanks for giving me something else to inspect with more scrutiny.
-Kevin