×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?
4

SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
Hello,
Another question on SCCR ratings for devices.  I am hopeful that this one gets answered.  When a device is rated to withstand 14kA fault current, is that a single line fault or 3 phase fault.

thanks
EE

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

Any fault. So that would mean a ground fault on one pole of a 3 pole device (the only way to have a "single line fault").

"Dear future generations: Please accept our apologies. We were rolling drunk on petroleum."
— Kilgore Trout (via Kurt Vonnegut)
  
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
I don't understand how the rating could mean any fault.  A 3 phase fault of 50kA per phase will do more damage to a breaker than will a single phase fault of 50kA.

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

Quote:

I don't understand how the rating could mean any fault.  A 3 phase fault of 50kA per phase will do more damage to a breaker than will a single phase fault of 50kA.
The keyword is "damage". How badly damaged, doesn't matter anymore. You'll still be needing replacements either way, you know?

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
Well, the point is to size things so that they are not damaged.  So my question is...If I have a device with a short circuit rating of 10kA, does this value refer to a single phase fault, line to line fault, 2 phase to ground, three phase to ground, or all?

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

All faults.

A single-phase fault beyond the rating will destroy one contact, which kills the breaker just as well as destroying all three.

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
So, the rating is for a three phase fault?

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

All faults.

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

In other words, 10kA flowing through any or all contacts is the limit.

10kA single-phase-to-ground
10kA phase-to-phase
10ka three-phase

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
I'm not sure that this makes sense to me.  Despite the currents being the same magnitude, the difference in energy absorbed during a 3 phase fault is about 3 times as much as a single phase fault.  

The contact rating is either 10kA on one phase (which means it's not rated for more than a single phase fault), or it is 10kA on all three phases (which means it can handle 10kA on a single phase and it can handle line to line faults and it can handle 3ph faults).  This is what I assume, but I'd like to know for sure.

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

Think about the breaker on a per-contact basis, not as a unit. Imagine it were three single-phase breakers.

It's the design of the contacts and arc-clearing apparatus that limits how much fault current it can interrupt. It doesn't matter whether the current is passing through one, two, or all three of the contacts.  Each individual contact can only interrupt the rated current.

In sum, a breaker with a simple 10kA rating is rated to interrupt:

10kA flowing through one contact (single phase)
10kA flowing through two contacts (phase to phase, or both to ground)
10kA flowing through three contacts (three phase, whether to ground or not).

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
SCCR is not about interrupting current, it's about withstand current.  This rating applies to breakers, but it also applies to every power component in the feeder and all branch circuits.  What is the interrupting current of a motor contactor, or a power distribution block?

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

Yes -- it means how much current it can survive and still be put back into service, whether it's a breaker, a contactor, or a terminal block.  In the case of a contactor or breaker, the interrupting capacity is integral to this.

The answer is the same.  It can take 10kA through any one of its terminals, or through some of them, or through all of them.

It can't take more than 10kA through any single terminal.

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

Perhaps it would help us to explain if you would post the problem you are trying to solve?

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
When a device is rated to withstand 14kA fault current, is that a single line fault or 3 phase fault?  How are these devices rated?
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
Maybe this would be clearer.  If I had a device rated at 14kA short circuit rating (not interrupt rating), and that device was subject to a 3 phase fault of 14kA per phase, would that device survive (according to the vendor rating)?  I think it would, but I can't find any information on it.

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

Multiply the answers for 10 kA by 1.4
Actually it is tested to withstand the fault current from a transformer with the listed available fault current, at a specified power factor and a specified X:R ratio.
The SCCR rating and the transformer available short circuit rating give a simple and usually reliable method to match transformers, service entrance devices and components. The actual withstand current of a device is higher than the rating to compensate for the fact that the actual instantaneous short circuit current that a transformer will deliver is quite a bit higher than the available short circuit current as calculated from the transformer impedance. Google asymmetric currents and DC offset.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

What can we do? It's either we don't understand your question or you failed to follow the logic behind our replies here! If the withstand rating is 14kA, then 14kA it is; never to be be exceeded in any kind of fault! Crystal!

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
Obviously the question has gone off course, which happens when I don't clearly state my question.  I am looking for documentation that states that the sccr rating of a device is for a symmetric 3 phase fault, RMS.  So that when I calculate the available short circuit rating at a given control panel, then I will use the worst case fault current, which would usually be a 3 ph fault.

It's clear that this documentation is not easy to come by, or someone would have acknowledged it by now.

Thanks for your replies.  

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

4
eeprom, there is no documentation that the SCCR is based on a three-phase fault or a single-phase fault.  It does not matter, it is a single number.

Do your fault current analysis, determine what the highest available fault current will be (note: single-line-to-ground is often the highest if the system is solidly grounded, depending on the ratio of positive sequence impedance zero sequence impedance).  Choose your equipment with an SCCR that is above the highest available fault current.

One more try at an example:

A device has an SCCR of 10kA. The (grounded Y) system fault current calculations indicate that a bolted three-phase fault will produce 9.8kA, and a single-line to ground fault will produce 10.5kA.  The device is not suitable, because a single-line to ground fault will exceed its SCCR rating.

Another device has an SCCR of 10kA. The (ungrounded delta) system fault current calculations indicate that a bolted three-phase fault will produce 9.8kA.  In this case, the single-line-to-ground fault is zero, and the two-phase fault is much less than the three-phase value.  So 9.8kA is the maximum available, and the device is suitable.

The point is that both of those devices have three phases connected to them.  The SCCR of the devices must be higher than the highest amount of current that will pass through any of the three connections.

In sum, the SCCR is not based on a three-phase fault or a single-phase fault.  It is to be applied to the highest available current that can flow through any one terminal.  A current exceeding the SCCR through one terminal of a three-phase device will probably destroy it.  A current exceeding the SCCR through two or three of its terminals will also probably destroy it.

"Highest Available Fault Current" not three-phase, not single-phase.  Whichever is higher.

 

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

Bingo. Better stated than I had done in the beginning.

"Dear future generations: Please accept our apologies. We were rolling drunk on petroleum."
— Kilgore Trout (via Kurt Vonnegut)
  
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

Yes, can't get any clearer than DRWeig's answer.

 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
Okay, phase II.  The SB4 states that only power circuit components need to be rated with SCCR.  Panels which contain only control components need no rating.  So, what is the definition of "power" circuit?  

Specifically, if I have a control panel with no external loads (motors and such), but I do have a panel heater and a panel light, how do those devices get rated?  Are these power components, control components, or neither?

I'd appreciate a reference to documentation if any of you can find it.  Thanks.

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

It should be quite obvious when looking at a panel. Devices hooked to the main power feed are power and devices not hooked to the main power feed (after a control power transformer) are control. I'm pretty sure there are some 1-line pictures in the standard illustrating this.
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
If it is obvious, I wish you would explain it to me.  I take for granted that I'm not smart enough to notice the obvious.

Not all panels have main power feeds, nor do they have control transformers.  Consider a panel with one PLC, a light, and a heater.  There is no external loads to the panel, however the heater and the light are not control devices.  I could easily argue that the panel heater is a load.

Where do these devices fit into the SCCR rating?  

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

UL has sometimes taken the stance that even 120 VAC PLC control panels must have an SCCR. I say sometimes because it really depends on who you talk to at UL. Mostly because most people don't care about SCCR ratings for single phase 120 VAC equipment.

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

Hi again eeprom,

Look at the glossary at the front of UL 508A, plus diagrams 6.1, 6.2, and 6.3.  

The diagrams are especially helpful.

The standard is also broken up into chapters, two of which are power circuits and control circuits.  Basically, if a device's specs are in the power circuits section, treat them as power circuit devices.

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
Thanks.  I am familiar with those diagrams.  In fact the lack of clarity is what led me to this forum.  But I hadn't considered the control versus power segregation of the manual.  Good idea.  Thanks.

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

The components you're talking about would require a CPT if it is not supplied...

Table SA1.1 spells much of it out too.

A PLC would likely have a CCN of NRAQ from under section 45 - control switching devices.

The Pilot light likely has a CCN of NKCR from section 46 - control circuit loads.

The heater likely has a CCN of NITW2 from section 26 - Enclosure Enviromental Controls. This isn't under the control or power sections so you have to decide.

Have you considered taking a UL course on the subject?
 

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

(OP)
LionelHutz,
Thank you very much.  I would love to take a course on this.  Maybe then I could write up a proper procedure for following this requirement.  It's just disappointing that UL could devise such a requirement that nobody seems to fully understand.  

RE: SCCR Rating - fault current 1p or 3p?

eeprom,

Coincidently, I got an e-mail from UL Academy just now, regarding 508A (link below and discount code). I've taken this course along with our whole panel shop, it's good.  Plus, you get to know the instructors -- they're good folks to ask for opinions when strange applications come up.

UL Academy 508A


Quote (UL e-mail):

Register for any UL Knowledge Services workshop with discount code PC412* before May 15th and receive 10% off!

 

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources