Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
(OP)
Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
I'm involved in a project where we need to bond plastics like FFKM (Kalrez) & PCTFE (Kel-f) in a device that in service will see saturated solvent atmosphere ( DMSO, Acetone, Acetonitrile, toluene, dichloromethane among the most significant) to 100°C, or with less aggressive environment will see close to 250°C.
Previous research by a colleague (including some testing) for a slightly different application suggests that Torr-Seal has the best resistance to the solvents (out of adhesives he looked at) but possibly doesn't bond the FFKM & PCTFE materials well and has a temperature limit of 120°C.
We typically use Chemgrip for bonding plastics like these but it does not stand up well to the solvents. We typically use MASTERBOND 10HT for high temp, but again not great with some chemicals.
I'm doing some digging and came across MasterBond EP45HT which claims solvent compatibility & good temperature performance does anyone have any experience using this http://www.masterbond.com/tds/ep45ht? (I'll try contacting them but apparently my colleague had trouble getting information from them previously and had concerns about their claims for some other formulations so I thought I'd see if anyone here has used it.)
In my colleagues research he also came across D.E.N. 438 Epoxy Novolac Resin but didn't get as far as testing it, and had concerns about it being tricky to work with in production.
A related formula D.E.N. 431 looks even better.
Another company they found was Arcor especially EE-101
Quick Google search turned up Loctite 325
If any one has any experience with these or suggestions of alternatives I'd appreciate it.
I'm involved in a project where we need to bond plastics like FFKM (Kalrez) & PCTFE (Kel-f) in a device that in service will see saturated solvent atmosphere ( DMSO, Acetone, Acetonitrile, toluene, dichloromethane among the most significant) to 100°C, or with less aggressive environment will see close to 250°C.
Previous research by a colleague (including some testing) for a slightly different application suggests that Torr-Seal has the best resistance to the solvents (out of adhesives he looked at) but possibly doesn't bond the FFKM & PCTFE materials well and has a temperature limit of 120°C.
We typically use Chemgrip for bonding plastics like these but it does not stand up well to the solvents. We typically use MASTERBOND 10HT for high temp, but again not great with some chemicals.
I'm doing some digging and came across MasterBond EP45HT which claims solvent compatibility & good temperature performance does anyone have any experience using this http://www.masterbond.com/tds/ep45ht? (I'll try contacting them but apparently my colleague had trouble getting information from them previously and had concerns about their claims for some other formulations so I thought I'd see if anyone here has used it.)
In my colleagues research he also came across D.E.N. 438 Epoxy Novolac Resin but didn't get as far as testing it, and had concerns about it being tricky to work with in production.
A related formula D.E.N. 431 looks even better.
Another company they found was Arcor especially EE-101
Quick Google search turned up Loctite 325
If any one has any experience with these or suggestions of alternatives I'd appreciate it.
Posting guidelines FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm? (probably not aimed specifically at you)
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?





RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
Any suggestions appreciated, thanks.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
I would have my doubts about the loctite acrylic adhesive, but have not checked your list of solvents to know for sure.
The biggest problems with any adhesive is the surface energies of the parts you are trying to get to adhere, both of which are some of the toughest to make work. The typical method is to etch the surfaces with things like ion beams and hydrofluoric acid, but if these are small parts, it can be tough to control where the etch is being done, and avoid damaging the non-bonding surfaces of the parts to the point that their chemical stability is compromised. As I'm sure you know.
FFKM is an elastomer, to be picky, but my point is that it is heat cured/vulcanized. This opens an opportunity to have it over-molded to the PCTFE part, with a suitable bonding primer/etch process done to the pctfe to enhance bonding. The process may not be feasible for your part, but it will give you the best results if you can make it work, IMO. Lord chemicals and molding shops with experience in FFKM elastomer molding will be your best friends here. I could probably point you to some people that could help, if you want a name, but I'm also fairly certain, given what I know of your location, that you know those Green WoolenFabric people quite well.
Good luck and don't sniff any open bottles.
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
We will be doing some testing, just deciding what to test is a good first step though.
I'll bring up the overmolding issue with the guy doing the detail design but I have a feeling it's a no go as the FFKM part is actually a bellows. I'm afraid I'm being dumb and didn't get your reference to the green woolen fabric folk, if you could be more obvious I'd appreciate it.
I looked again at some of the glues I listed, the Loctite is a no go on the temp range anyway (I was mixing up °C & F) and the Arcor EE-101 probably isn't good enough on temp either.
I'm waiting to hear back from Masterbond.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
Could you mold or form a lip on one of the parts which acted as a sealing lip around the glue/bond surface? Thus keeping the solvents away from the bond surface and the bonding agents. This lip might fit in a groove in the other part, and this groove could be filled with some material which did bond minimally and seal, but tolerated the solvents better, and was not the primary bonding agent, when the two parts were pressed together to form the primary bond. Alternatively, if you had a rubber (maybe not the best mat'l., but flexible enough) strip with a round hollow tube at each edge; the edges of this trip would be presses into a T-slot groove in each part and be held there by the slot, spanning the bond joint and keeping the solvents away. Maybe these ideas are too complicated if you can find a bonding agent which will do the bonding and tolerate the solvents.
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
I have a feeling that the space limitations and bellows complexity etc. may rule that out but I like the idea - like btrues 'molding over' idea.
An a similar product we were able to protect most of the adhesive seals using o-rings or gaskets etc. but we're having trouble doing that on this one.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
I would talk to Lord about your application. They have a lot of experience with bonding to elastomers, and their primers have to withstand subsequent moldbonding temperatures.
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
For some reason my initial search after Btrue's suggestion didn't get good results - user error I'm sure.
Thanks.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
This is for use on a special type of microsocope as a mini environmental chamber for samples. One end of the kalrez bellows is attatched to a kel-f part maybe an inch or so in dia, maybe .125" thick which has a bunch other stuff allready integrated in it and whose dynamics are fairly sensitive. One of the items mounted on this kel-f part will need to be heated to close to 250°C.
The other end has a bit more room and less stuff cluttering it and is further away from its heat source but still pretty cramped, especially vertically.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
I figured you were talking small.
If the bellows is being molded now, it may still be possible to overmold/bond to your part; whenever you are talking elastomers it's really the best approach for strength and chem resistance, i think. Might be worth talking to the people molding the bellows to see if its feasible, and you would probably need to be willing to pay for modifying or making a new mold/tooling. If the mfgr. of the bellows doesn't want to do it (part count just too low, and they likely don't want to be a custom molding shop) then still consider finding a custom shop, and working with their mold/tooling guys to figure out a way. I can think of a couple of ideas off the top of my head that might work, but I'd need to talk to somebody who knows about molding/bonding FFKM to know for sure.
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
Our purchasing/accounting also don't like adding new vendors - we have to make a pretty compelling case. However, I'll let the guy doing the design know about green tweed thanks.
As you guessed we're talking pretty low volumes - low double digits per year probably.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
In general terms, if a bellows has narrow enough convolutions, the core used to form the internal hollow can be a solid piece, and the bellows is stripped off of the internal core after molding by peeling/rolling it back or by injecting/blowing air under the edge. So, tooling can be pretty simple for a mold like that.
Adhesives - I'd get samples in of as many different breeds and varieties (epoxies like you are looking at would be my first choice too) and come up with some kind of simple test fixture that could be pulled/peeled or given the kind of stresses you think the bond will need to survive...then make a bunch of samples with different adhesives, soak them in your witch's brew of solvents, and go pull/peel/bend/fatigue them to failure and see what you learn. Assuming, of course, infinite time money and help, you should easily reach a solution...
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
For 'rigid' materials another colleague developed a standard sample shape which is basically a small 'dish' with some holes in the bottom. Idea is that you plug the holes with the adhesive of interest, then fill the dish with solvent and place on top of blotting paper or similar indicator. Then leave for X hours/days... and come back to check for leaks.
I have some concerns about the solvent evaporating - especially if forced to some temperature - though maybe he tops them up or something.
Our loads are relatively low so for our applications the 'sealing' aspect of the adhesive is more significant than the 'strength' aspect - hence this test set up. Plus this set up maximizes the area open to solvent attack.
I may have an intern to help with this testing - I checked and he doesn't have a history of huffing.
Thanks again.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
Guffaw. No worries, Kenat.
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
I saw a presentation about 25 years ago from a guy who was doing extremely violent surface treatments to fluoropolymers to make them susceptible to bonding. He was using very, very nasty reagents that made sodium look about as tame as water, but they were very effective at modifying the surface and didn't do anything beyond the first few molecular layers of the polymer. Bulk properties remained intact. He was a uni professor and I don't know if his work went anywhere, so I know it's not much good to you, but there it is FYI.
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
Molten, yes, hydrofluoric acid etch on pctfe is what I remember too, for bonding with an epoxy.
Yghr...sometimes it takes awhile for the memory cells to wake up, in this case 2 days after the OP prompt. Well, not bad for something I learned 20+ years ago. Kenat, the epoxy we used (epoxy potting/bonding/strain relief of pctfe jacketed leadwire) was a product from the National Starch Company. Google turns up that the adhesive product brands for that company were purchased by Henckel, which is also loctite's parent now I think. The brand name was Ablestik, which is still available on the Henckel website if you dig for it. The stuff would stick darn near anything to anything else, polyimide films, pctfe films, etc. Like an epoxy/nonwoven glass pre-preg, that could be cut to shapes and molded, then clamped and heat cured (200 F or thereabouts). Don't know much about solvent resistance, but it should be pretty good, as it's an epoxy base.
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
I heard back from Masterbond and they sent me the data sheet for ep125 which looks promising. Not sure it's going to meet DFMA goals as it's a paste with fairly high & long cure/post cure but hey, you can't have everything
http://www.masterbond.com/tds/ep125
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
Having finally made some traction on the high temp/thermally stable adhesive front, the colleague that identified Tor seal for an earlier application has just pointed out that PCTFE is only good up to about 120-130°C and may show dimensional instability below that!
I'm amazed I haven't had a panicked phone call from my consultant!
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
I spoke to my contractor and he is going to contact Henkel, he already spoke to Lord and they couldn't help and he was having trouble getting in touch with Arcor. He's going to contact Green Tweed too I believe.
He also reminded me that we may not need the kel-f as we don't have quite the same list of chemicals (especially acids) that my torr-seal colleague had - so I've quit panicking.
My Director (who likes to dabble in things that grab his attention) looked over his records from when he was helping my Torr-seal colleague last year and may have something as well. Some HT adhesive from Midland that he has some good data on chemical compatibility and is good up to 240° (I hope he meant C not F).
Thanks for the input everyone.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
Am I right in thinking that Kalrez/FFKM is not a candidate for Ultrasonic Welding? The materials to join it to would be SST & Alumina.
This resource at page 10 http://
Cheers.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
FFKM (and most all "elastomers") cures to its final form by crosslinking; applying heat (which is what the mechanical energy of ultrasonic bonding degrades to ultimately) will dissociate the crosslinks and/or burn/char the base polymer. So, it will never melt per se, and even if softened, won't re-bond even to itself, its material properties would have been destroyed.
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
I didn't think it was an option but wanted to be able to tell our production folks why.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
To do a heat weld, you'd need to use a "thermoplastic elastomer" - see ht
Most of them have pretty poor chemical/heat resistance.
RE: Bonding FFKM & PCTFE at temperature in solvent atmosphere
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?